3 ms·
Not at all. Having reviewed papers, my goal is to make the underlying experiment as clear as possible for readers when the paper is eventually published. I care
by UncleMeat 8y ago
Not at all. Having reviewed papers, my goal is to make the underlying experiment as clear as possible for readers when the paper is eventually published. I care about the methods being clear and the analysis being sound. I am absolutely not looking for "I think the authors are lying" warnings because this way lies madness.
If we expect reviewers to reject papers they find weird or suspicious then a lot of excellent scholarship will be rejected because established researchers are stuck in their belief systems. It also leads to serious problems when an author has obtained some hard-to-get data set and this is now a downside when it comes to review.
If the results are garbage then that will come out later when people work with the ideas presented in the paper.
- adrianratnapala 8y agoThat's because reviewers of experimental papers are not expected to reproduce experiments. In theoretical physics or mathematics a reviewer absolutely should follow the proofs and check they are sound. The humanities (as opposed to the social sciences) are theory fields, they don't have experiment but they advance knowledge by good arguments that require real scholarship to support even if they don't have crispness of proofs. Someone reviewing it should go "Yep, that paper make a real claim and argues for it well enough that convincing counter-argument would need to be a significant work of scholarship in itself". If a field of study produces a conversation made up of such arguments and counter-arguments, then it stands some chance of being growing repository of truth. Whereas if the field can't distinguish between it's own chatter and a hoax guided by mood affiliation, then the field is likely to be just chatter.
- TheCoelacanth 8y agoIf the field doesn't rely on experimentation, why did their papers include fake experimental data (e.g. one of the papers contained a bunch of fake data about their observations of dog genitalia)?