7 ms·
https://youtu.be/V1PcgtWAEnU https://youtu.be/V1PcgtWAEnU : already been done. Americans are far behind the Dutch. What frustrates me is that everyone is making
by jelliclesfarm 8y ago
https://youtu.be/V1PcgtWAEnU https://youtu.be/V1PcgtWAEnU : already been done. Americans are far behind the Dutch. What frustrates me is that everyone is making their version of the wheel in their corner instead of collaborating.
Right now, VC money should go to other things like AI, supply chain integrated into production, blockchain etc.
And they must have farmers as partners. Farmers completely distrust tech because we are not included. I gave up trying. It’s like we speak different languages but when tech is trying to create produce for MY domain,isn’t my participation and input necessary?
I am particularly bummed because I applied to YC twice and it always comes back to finding a tech partner. My tech is farming. I know stuff your roboticist or engineer can’t dream of because we live that nightmare of crop failure or machines failing all the time.
At this point, I think I am going to write stories like sci fi or fantasy and maybe someone will realize my vision(or not..who knows..maybe it’s not the right fit, but I will never know) after I am gone. I really enjoy coming up with theoretical solutions because at this point, that’s all I can do.
I would have discouraged Iron Ox from that idea. Who transplants one at a time when technology exists to do thousands at a time? Why? I can’t even wrap my mind around this.
- kodablah 8y ago> I gave up trying [...] that’s all I can do That's unfortunate that you feel this way. Quite frequently the ones I see succeed aren't the best at their tech either (be it their focused field or general tech). Tech VCs gravitate towards tech people. Surely that is obvious and you shouldn't give up after only consulting them. Let them solve things the only way they know how, and maybe you can find someone else to take a different approach with your ideas. Or maybe not. You shouldn't feel so slighted/jaded by it though. We all feel our ideas, be they ones proven in other scenarios or not, are workable.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoThank you.I am just collecting information and data and general trends now. And I am noting down what fails and what has succeeded. I feel like this might take longer but I am not failing on my dime. Perhaps that’s a good thing because I would have never thought about IoT or blockchain 4 years ago, but now I see how it can be implemented under the umbrella of Agtech. We need an ecosystem of sorts. And we need to be able to scale up as well as down. And we need solutions for 30 years down the line. One thing I find striking is that tech coming out is solving problems of today. But what good is that? I want to be able to predict how land availability and lack of water or climate change or labour shortage will affect me in the future so I can get ahead with a method that will eventually merge with the future painlessly. But I have also met some very helpful people in the industry who are more than happy to share or at least hear me out. There is enormous value in having people from other disciplines and others who are not farmers to be sounding board. I also know that including us has some value. By ‘us’, I mean smallholder farm operators and the farm workers. In big industrialized farms, it’s already mechanized and it’s just one step away from automation. They pain point is availability of labour.(and to a certain extent, regulation in California..dont know about other states) But in smaller farms, we are talking the difference between breaking even and loss. Especially if we are organic because we don’t spray and can’t have huge machinery. And labour is our biggest cost. Not availability of labour, but the cost of labour. Small scale farm bots are needed. They can scale. Massive autonomous tractors meant to 1000 acres of corn and soy is useless to us. I feel a kinship with the Lilliputian scale of indoor farming. I get it. I am also inspired by it. But outside, we got sunshine. And it’s free. Nothing is cheaper than free!
- mmt 8y ago> And labour is our biggest cost > But outside, we got sunshine. And it’s free. Nothing is cheaper than free! Would simulated and/or pumped-in sunshine cost more than (or even a significan fraction of) the labor? If not, that seems similar to the sunk-cost fallacy, substituting "free" for "already paid for".
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoThe former is for small acreage outdoor farms(biggest cost is labour when available) vs the latter which is for indoor farms with artificial light(can be automated. Light,energy are their biggest cost).
- mmt 8y agoI don't doubt it, but it still doesn't quite answer my question. (The answer may seem obvious to an industry insider but likely to anyone else). If labor costs, for any comparably-sized farm, dwarf artificial light [1] costs, then it would be a form of "penny wise, pound foolish" to opt for free light if it means incurring the labor cost. This is true, even if each is the biggest single cost in each scenario. [1] Even that needn't be 100% artificial, since windows and skylights exist, though, again, my ignorance as an outsider may preclude me from realizing something that might be obvious to an insider, like this option not moving the needle on cost.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI am not sure I understand. Let me rephrase your question to me as I understand it now: On one hand, there is a regular farm with farm labour and natural sun light. A traditional calendar picture farm. A tractor, some workers, rows of crops, red barn etc. On the other hand, there is an automated indoor farm with artificial lights. Are these the two scenarios that are being compared? I agree that indoor farming will likely seem more profitable even though lighting costs money. But it doesn’t happen that way because of 1. economies of scale. https://coststudyfiles.ucdavis.edu/uploads/cs_public/52/c9/52c99335-fcc8-44fe-9ce0-6a0bd5fbe006/2017headlettuce-final_-_5-25-2017.pdf https://coststudyfiles.ucdavis.edu/uploads/cs_public/52/c9/5... : UC Davis cost studies for lettuce. https://www.freightfarms.com/income-projection#proformabody-december17 https://www.freightfarms.com/income-projection#proformabody-... : freight farms income projection. Look at comment sections to gauge reception https://www.agrilyst.com/stateofindoorfarming2017/ https://www.agrilyst.com/stateofindoorfarming2017/ : agrilyst compilation of indoor economics. No one is named. https://www.scribd.com/document/318543132/10A-Dr-T-Kozai-Plant-Factory-APO-20160630-pdf https://www.scribd.com/document/318543132/10A-Dr-T-Kozai-Pla... : Japanese Prof.Kozai sharing their insights. Very helpful. 2. While indoor farming is being tinkered around with..someone still has to keep supplying lettuce to the Walmarts and Whole Foods and Safeway’s and Kroger’s and restaurants and consumers. 3. Right now, the advantage of outdoor lettuce farming is legacy. California lettuce companies have been doing it for so long that they have perfected it to an art form. But regulations are strangling and water is disappearing. Soon labour too. And it’s getging expensive. They do the best they can. They give medical, 15-27/hour including benefits, breaks, overtime and some even provide housing. But it’s not going to be sustainable because the public still wants cheap food. Even if indoor systems are automated, the jury is still out there if it would be profitable. Also..indoor plant specialists would want 60-120k. The Joses and Eduardos and Marias employed in the field demand much less. Make of this what you may...I am just throwing light on current ground reality. I have NO solutions or recommendations. These are bigger problems. I do know that food security is important. Local food supply is crucial for this. Food should be reasonably priced for everyone. Farming should be financially viable and sustainable for young farmers to keep doing what they do best. My solution is small farm robotics. Outdoors. Because I am not an indoor farmer. I only read about it. Perhaps there are other ways to deal with it but I am not equipped to comment more. I understand large scale production but I haven’t worked in it. Everyone is an employee in a corporate farm. I am a farm owner and a farm worker in my farm. So it’s worlds apart.
- sgwae 8y agoWhy do you think they don't have farmers as advisors/consultants already? While inefficient now, perhaps they could have a few hundred machines running around once they scale up. And it looks like they have a variety of "premium" produce versus just the cabbages in your link. Your website offers food from a "little farm". Wouldn't tech companies prefer to partner with experienced large scale commercial growers? In addition, you seem to take things (that aren't even criticisms) overly emotionally/personally, which would probably not be ideal in a cofounder.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoTech companies are not replacing management. Tech companies are replacing boots on the ground labourers and farm workers like me with bots. My website is a placeholder. I don’t have time to update things on social media amidst farmwork. I might during winter when cover crops are in. Large scale commercial growers can be partners, but are you saying small scale farmers don’t deserve the benefits of robotic technology and stuff that would help us make more profit without repetitive manual labour? This is exactly the sentiment that I sensed with tech people in Silicon Valley. That there is no value to saving heirloom varieties or using conservation techniques to protect soil and environment. Our small scale gives us room to grow varieties and food of the different people from all over. Fertilizers leach. Tillage destroys soil structure. Massive soil disruption gets rid of soil microbiome. Large scale commercial producers are important but local food is important too. That’s my opinion anyways. You are way off Mark when you say I take things overly emotional /personal. But I am not going to challenge you. It’s your opinion and you are entitled to it. Have a nice day. P.S: they are not ‘cabbages’
- organicaf 8y agoYou seem like a passionate co-founder to me jelli and I can see the value in what you're saying. Maybe SV can see it too, but they can't see the way to take that value and use it to extract a high ROI right now. Could you link your website?
- jelliclesfarm 8y ago
- michaelbuckbee 8y agoA difficult thing to do with evaluating startups is clearly seeing where they can go vs where they are now. Consider Amazon: they were a bookseller because Jeff Bezos wanted to start an ecommerce company and books were a good starting place, but their trajectory and path grew to be so much more. Similarly, there's a bunch of robot startups that aren't really _about_ the thing they're trying to do right now, so much as they want to make general purpose robots that can handle all sorts of tasks. In this case they landed on farming, but there have been other seemingly dumb robot applications. For example: check out this massively expensive robot arm (that could easily kill a worker) that has been used instead of just putting the conveyor belt directly into the conveyor belt oven. https://youtu.be/uFSdxwRVh8A https://youtu.be/uFSdxwRVh8A That company isn't interested in Pizzas or restaurants per se (if they were they'd make something more like a frozen pizza factory) they're just using it as a proving ground. There is real innovation happening in the farming space but it looks like the video you posted or these automatic milking robots or something else that really helps out. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/23/nyregion/with-farm-robotics-the-cows-decide-when-its-milking-time.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/23/nyregion/with-farm-roboti...
- NegativeLatency 8y agoThat video fails to convey how the pizza robot arm is novel. What’s to stop someone else from getting an industrial robot arm and making it do the same thing?
- TeMPOraL 8y agoIt isn't. It doesn't really seem to even require an industrial robot arm (though that definitely buys reliability). It seems well within capabilities of DIY robotics. (Side note: building a pizza-making robot is one small dream of mine.)
- marcofloriano 8y agoWhat frustrates me is the tendency to use technology to replace humans beings. Then you don't know how to solve the shortcut in jobs. Couldn't we just slow down tech a little bit and let people do some good old hard work to keep getting their cut? Frustrating.
- NegativeLatency 8y agoWe could tax the wealthy and spend more on education, universal basic income, etc There’s not enough political will though.
- tomcam 8y agoHow much more should the wealthy be taxed? Who decides who is wealthy? For example, you are probably massively wealthier than many hundreds of millions of people in the world. How much should you be giving? How much would that contribute to your lofty goals?
- boomboomsubban 8y agoWhen we get to a point of automated food production, these goals aren't that lofty.
- nervousvarun 8y agoAgree but political will is a tricky thing here. How "representative" of our country (assuming you're in the U.S. apologies if you're not) are our politicians? How many are "wealthy" vs. the general population etc.?
- jelliclesfarm 8y ago1. Why would it frustrate you? I do the job in the field everyday. I am frustrated that my back and knees hurt. That I have to work in the sun and can’t find enough markets. 2. There is already a lot of technology in what you eat. Mechanization in factory style farms, cold supply chain, blockchain for lettuce at Walmart..the stock system..the inventory..everything. Not to mention that your food chain is owned by agri fertilizers and pesticide companies..and gmo seed. Bayer owns Monsanto now. The company that used slave labor in nazi concentration camps bought out the company that made agent orange. And that’s who is making your food and medicine. 3. I am also frustrated that farming methods aka hard work meant to feed a lot less people is now expected to feed close to 10 billion by 2050. On less land.
- hyperpallium 8y agoMaybe consider inspiring farmers as a goal? Like, Elon's initial plan of a greenhouse on Mars. Also, the market concepts of innovator, early adopter, early majority, late majority, laggard came from potato farmers, showing that some of them are innovators, just like every other group. Target them.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoThat’s what I do now. I have a once monthly techie meet farmer roundtable. So far it has been very tough to get farmers interested. Some like the romanticized notion of ‘farm life’ without realizing that it still runs on fossil fuels and cutting edge mechanical tech. I have been able to get a few of them interested no doubt. Few, but it was worth searching for them. There has to be a ‘farm stack’...because it’s a lot of things. When I see a weed thinning machine start up bought for 300 something million, I am awed that just one simple function that isn’t even that essential with proper management is so expensive. This was Blue River Tech bought by John Deere. And what did John Deere do? They shut down lettuce thinning and took it to cotton which is a commodity crop and is one of the crops that uses pesticide sprays a lot. A good notion but it’s not food. Which brings everyone back to square one and more $$$ going into something that has already been invented but retired. And even if companies like John Deere own these tech, they control it tightly. I wonder how many lawyers are in their payroll. Farmers in California just lost the right to repair tractors with software in them. DMCA (https://www.forbes.com/sites/jasonbloomberg/2017/04/30/john-deeres-digital-transformation-runs-afoul-of-right-to-repair-movement/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/jasonbloomberg/2017/04/30/john-... ) Can you imagine if one of those giant autonomous machines breaks down? Having smaller bots that swarm and take care of small acreages is less risky. Mitigated crop loss. It serves both small farmers and large farmers. Most ‘large farms’ are really corporate farms that outsource growing instructions and protocols to smaller farms and buys their produce. They contract farmers to grow what goes under their label after packing. Packers are not often growers. Distributors are not always packers. And then there are brokers, wholesalers and retailers. The supply chain is long!! The lettuce is at least a week old before you can buy it! Small local farm operators can get food via a smaller supply chain. I also want farming to be climate change proof and ‘future proof’. It’s easier to pivot smaller systems than larger massive ones. I am making quick points but there is a lot of nuance depending on location, geography and kind of crops grown. This is why Agtech needs farmers and growers as partners. We know all the gory details and gnarly bits about our specialities. Take pests like bugs. It differs not just from crop to crop but also differs with soil type, geography, season and sometimes we don’t even know why or how. It’s not possible to standardize this intelligence. So a weeding machine meant for the lettuce fields of Salinas, CA may not work elsewhere. It will become unbearably expensive to work out a system for a common farm marketplace. But it’s easy when we have a general purpose platform and process with minor changes depending on circumstance that can be cloud based and open source based on local farmers input. For this it has to be small and cheap. And most importantly farmers need to trust tech. VCs have chosen to create for a few massive consolidated large scale farms(not selling to them,btw but leasing) instead of making it possible for everyone to farm. It’s like the smart phone. If Apple made a $30000 gold plated phone, few might buy it but when they make cheaper ones with plastic cases, everyone can have one. And Apple makes $ from services and apps and what not. Plus they will be repeat buyers. I struggle to explain this to finance folk and tech folk who now think they are bosom buddies with the VC folk now that they got a couple rounds of funding. There are real pain points that are not being addressed. In the field, I can already see future pain points. 30 years from now..if there is no fossil fuel..if climate change occurs..if soil changes..if water disappears..whatever. But no one who can make it happen is listening.
- joejerryronnie 8y agoYou're looking for funding in the wrong place. You should be in California's Central Valley. Sure, there's not the flood of startup capital you'll find in the Bay and you'll probably need to bootstrap initially. But you will be taken seriously and you'll be in daily contact with your customers while you iterate on your product. Then you can show the VC's in the valley real traction and a tangible market.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI hear you. But I am not trying to replace labour in BigAg. I am trying to replace labour with machines in smaller farms that can’t afford hired labour. In most parts of the world, their food comes from 2-3 hectares. That’s the average size. Also. I doubt if there is any infrastructure or support in central California. UC Davis might have some ways to collaborate with small farms but in my limited and personal experience, I find that they prefer to work with their own..alumni and school network. I am an immigrant and didn’t obtain my education here. I get it, but I don’t have to like how the system works. That’s why YC selection process bummed me big time. I have a reasonable network that I built since I started farming four years ago. But it WAS hard and it’s never enough because I don’t ‘belong’ here or the networked university system. Lest it seems like I am whining, I want to say that I am just being realistic. I also know when to cut loose from a sinking dream. I guess I will keep trying but I am not emotionally or passionately invested anymore. My time is precious and I can’t waste it trying to impress people who see things differently. I am still a good writer. I will write instead. I am hoping that it will fulfill me. But sometimes..from time to time, I got to roll my eyes when I see wheels that will never roll being reinvented with so much $$$! With the OP, I don’t have a dog in this fight as it’s Indoor Ag, but I have learned a lot about automation and data collection by understanding indoor systems and philosophy. Iron Ox is like Amazon’s Kiva or Fetch Bots. I don’t get it.
- Animats 8y agoIt's happening. Here are some automated weeding systems in use in central California.[1] "All these machines use a camera to detect the crop, a computer to make decisions on which plants to keep/remove, and then activate a kill mechanism." Most of these things are implements towed behind a tractor, not robots. These implements seem to be built up from a row of detector/computer/actuator modules, so if a module fails in the field, you should be able to unbolt it and bolt in a spare, then take the broken one in for repair. Electronics for a module is probably cell phone level. So far, they're not as flexible about weed/plant detection as they could be. But there will probably be a training system where you go out with a cell phone pointed down at the field, swiping left for weeds and right for plants, until the machine learning system is trained. There's a lot that can be done, and is being done, by hooking up inexpensive vision systems to actuators on agricultural implements. Here's a nice example - a cultivator which is stirring the soil around each plant while not touching the plants.[2] The main problem with automated vegetable harvesting is not that it can't be done, but that for some crops the infrequently used machinery isn't cost effective compared to hiring large numbers of people for short periods. [1] https://www.growingproduce.com/vegetables/automated-weeders-arrived/ https://www.growingproduce.com/vegetables/automated-weeders-... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DhqNmRuBPsw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DhqNmRuBPsw
- Iv 8y agoHere living on the hackerfarm allowed me to discuss with people who have farming insights before even starting my project. I have participated in community farming and gardening before sketching a thing or writing a piece of code. Manipulation of plants in a clean room is easy, it is also remote from any real world application (outside space or maybe arctic farming). You should at least aim at greenhouses tech.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoTrue. And it’s pretty advanced and it’s only getting better.
- ag_dart 8y agoI am working on aviation and robotics for a project and I've been looking to talk to someone in farming to get some insights on how this product might be used in agriculture. Do you think we can talk? What might be a good way to direct message you? Thanks!
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoMy user name at gmail
- safgasCVS 8y ago"My tech is farming". Absolutely The word Technology means 'the skill of crafting', but its become hijacked to mean anything with a microchip That so few people can feed so many using such a small amount of land is a massive tech innovation
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoThank you for saying that.
- Animats 8y agoThat Dutch hydroponic system is nice. It has many of the features of cost-effective mechanization. The system is mostly water tanks in huge greenhouses, with automated handling equipment around the edges. Plants are handled in trays much larger than humans can handle, so fewer units have to be handled. There's not a lot of wasted motion; the cycle taken by the growing pallets is about as short as it could be. Looks like a profitable business.
- wiz21c 8y ago>>> Looks like a profitable business. But is it a business worth purusing for humanity. Have you ever tasted hydroponics lettuce ? It's so inferior in taste and the sensations it gives in your mouth. It may have all nutrients, but if nutrients is the point, then let's eat soylent green.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoThat just means there's space for improvements to be made. There's research to be done on what makes plants tastier, and there's work to be done in applying such research. But yes, being able to produce fresh food better, faster and in more controlled way is definitely worth pursuing for humanity.
- deialtrous 8y ago>But yes, being able to produce fresh food better, faster and in more controlled way is definitely worth pursuing for humanity. But it isn't better. And why is making worse food faster worth pursuing for humanity? All the available evidence seems to suggest that a rural agrarian lifestyle provides more happiness and fulfillment. It would seem that we should be pursuing how to move people into the country to grow their own food, not how to support the highest possible population of humans at the expense of those humans and everything else on the planet.
- wiz21c 8y ago>>> There's research to be done on what makes plants tastier, and there's work to be done in applying such research. there's earth, rain and sun and millions of years or R&D already done and proven successful. I really wonder what kind of research youo want... What you may want is : tasty food for everyone on earth. But that's not science, that's much more politics.
- choochootrain 8y agoi'm coming at this from the tech side but with an appreciation for the small scale farmers who have done this for generations. my family was all farmers and here i am now. i'd love to understand your vision if you're willing to chat. my email is in my profile.
- decacorn 8y agoi suggest you try pitching to Jason Calacanis. He likes entrepreneurs with deep domain knowledge. you can find his direct email for pitching on his twitter.