2 ms·
In your zeal to make a political point, you have selectively quoted from the article and the journal note. For starters, while a valuation firm can appraise art
by gamblor956 8y ago
In your zeal to make a political point, you have selectively quoted from the article and the journal note. For starters, while a valuation firm can appraise art for more than the taxpayer acquired it, that valuation is subject to audit and the IRS can (and frequently does) disagree. As the deduction is a % of the value of the art donated, the deduction could never be higher than the value of the art, let alone "exponentially."
Second, while private museums are a thing, the rules that a private museum must satisfy to qualify for non-profit status are fairly rigorous, and the scenario you describe would not qualify. Thus, a "donation" to the "museum" in your hypothetical would not yield a deduction. A donation to a DAF that loaned the artwork to that museum would likely violate self-dealing rules and lead to various sanctions, including potentially prison.
IKEA isn't a US charity, so none of the rules we're discussing apply.
- GFischer 8y agoWell, the New York times itself made the point about private museums. About the valuation, as I mentioned elsewhere, my mother used to work on collectibles auctions, and it is a VERY opaque world, with several ways to inflate price - using frontmen to buy other pieces by the same artist would be one way. I'm not a 0.1% and I'm not even from the U.S. :) , I just wanted to point out that in my experience such loopholes are exploited. In my country we get examples of charities being subverted very often. I do hope most charities are indeed that, charities.