3 ms·
The net is slightly positive for the US, but the effect size is relatively small The benefit comes mainly from lower borrowing costs. The harm comes from the
by nabla9 8y ago
The net is slightly positive for the US, but the effect size is relatively small
The benefit comes mainly from lower borrowing costs. The harm comes from the higher exchange rate that hurts competitiveness of US exports.
https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/employment-and-growth/an-exorbitant-privilege https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/employment-and-gr...
>In a “normal” year for the world economy, we estimate that the net financial benefit to the United States is between about $40 billion and $70 billion
- bzbarsky 8y agoI suggest reading https://foreignpolicy.com/2011/09/07/an-exorbitant-burden/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2011/09/07/an-exorbitant-burden/ for a counterargument. The harm is not just export competitiveness; it's also other countries being able to export their lack of demand and unemployment to the US (via the exchange rate and balance of trade mechanisms, true, but the point is that the harm affects all of the US economy, not just export-oriented industries). As one specific example, the low rate of saving by US consumers is a direct consequence of the use of the dollar as a reserve currency. It's not clear to me that lower borrowing costs, even if those are present, outweigh even that one harm. And to be clear, "the United States" as a whole that's benefitting in the mckinsey report you link is an average. The actual benefits and harms from the use of dollars as a reserve currency flow to different people, and as far as I can tell that contributes to worsening inequality in the US, which is an effect (benefit or harm, take your pick) the mckinsey report doesn't seem to mention.
- amanaplanacanal 8y agoHow could the US keep running its enormous budget deficits if the dollar wasn't in this situation? It seems to me that either taxes would have to be raised substantially, or spending cut substantially, or US inflation would be much higher if other countries weren't soaking up so many of the excess dollars.
- nabla9 8y agoMost of US deficit is internal, not external. Federal reserve is the biggest owner of federal debt. The level of dept is internal issue for the United States. US has floating exchange rate and it adjusts automatically the international balances. Because US has no debt denominated in foreign currency, it is shielded from hyperinflation and other issues that Venezuela and other countries suffer.