4 ms·
That's not BS. That's you stating explicitly something people familiar with the issues see as implicit. Both CEOs and journalists, as well as most readers of M
by wpietri 8y ago
That's not BS. That's you stating explicitly something people familiar with the issues see as implicit.
Both CEOs and journalists, as well as most readers of MIT's Technology Review, understand that you can get more labor by raising the price. The implicit understanding is that a) most Americans don't want to do back-breaking manual labor for a living, and b) most Americans also want food to be cheap. This is an ongoing problem in agriculture and has been for decades.
- cptaj 8y ago>Americans don't want to do back-breaking manual labor for a living This makes me wonder... Autonomy is the biggest hurdle for these technologies and manual labor is the reason they are needed. Why aren't we meeting halfway and using remote controlled robots instead of autonomous ones? That way workers could do the job from anywhere in the world without having to break a sweat and you'd only need a fraction of the investment to get it running.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoI assume the tech isn't there, but mechanical turk for manual labour sounds like a fun concept, in a black mirror sort of way. Can't wait for Uber to try to solve its self driving cars with this.
- abrichr 8y agoSee: Kindred.ai
- emiliobumachar 8y agoI'm not in either field, but I imagine that the issues with remote control are the same issues with full automation. Mostly gripping and locomotion. I assume it's not very hard (for experts) to build an AI that would push the right buttons at the right times.
- thrower123 8y agoHave you ever watched any streams of somebody trying to play Job Simulator or other similar VR games? We have a long, long way to go with input tracking and control to get anything close to human dexterity over telepresence.
- howard941 8y agoI haven't but I take your point. How do surgeons operating remotely overcome the problems?
- mrguyorama 8y agoA whole lot of training and VERY expensive robots
- dwighttk 8y agothey use robots that cost millions of dollars
- Cerium 8y agoRobotic assisted surgery involves the surgeon using an expensive console in the same room as the operation. As others have said, the systems require a fair amount of training to become accustomed to. The training requirement is offset by the additional capabilities that the robot brings that humans do not possess. In particular robotic tools have a larger range of motion than conventional minimally invasive instruments do.
- sien 8y agoThey don't really. Telesurgery is a bit of a myth. It's been done a few dozen times. It doesn't make that much sense economically. It's actually cheaper to fly a surgeon or a patient around for the few occasions when it really needs to be done. Most surgery still isn't done with Da Vinci robots or whatever. Surgeons with their hands can do many more things. That's not to say those robots are not amazing, it's just that they don't do everything. The military is the one area where it might make sense, but have a close look. They don't do it either. Instead the US military has an amazing extraction system where someone injured in battle in the middle east can be at Rammstein within hours.
- maerF0x0 8y agoThe specific part I was calling BS on is >there's not enough people to actually do ... IMO there are plenty to do the work. There are not enough people who are sufficiently incentivized to do the work at the wages that farming pays. This is in comparison to other choices people have be it easier work or higher paying.
- jklinger410 8y agoThat's just shorthand for the market will not sustain those wages. Unless you have a greater point or suggestion to make, why waste time on pedantry?
- sueders101 8y agoI think it’s worth pointing out. We see the same ‘we can’t find people to hire’ point being made by tech companies trying to find developers. The solution is the same for both: pay more. If you’re going to use shorthand it make it accurate. Just say ‘we can’t/don’t want to pay for the workers we need’.
- qubax 8y ago> That's not BS. It is BS. > a) most Americans don't want to do back-breaking manual labor for a living No. Most american don't want to do back-breaking manual labor for peanuts. As maerF0x0 said, raise the wages and watch how many americans love back-breaking manual labor. It's strange how the tar oil fields in south dakota are able to attract workers from all over the country. > and b) most Americans also want food to be cheap. Don't all humans?
- nitwit005 8y ago> most Americans don't want to do back-breaking manual labor for a living If it was just some cultural thing, then we'd have more than enough immigrants to correct for most Americans not wanting to do it. The problem is that there exists no cultural group that wants these jobs, native born or otherwise, at the pay and benefits offered. People switch to better jobs as soon as they find one. > Americans also want food to be cheap I assume everyone would prefer if everything is cheap? This is a problem that effects any business.
- samstave 8y agoIt's not as much about the fact that people don't want to do the work, it's about the quality of life said work allows. These cheap farm laborers need housing food schools medicine transportation goals a life. What robots do is reduce all that ripple effect of societal load on all the other aspects of sustaining the labor force and their human needs. Focusing on simply labor and it's price for the task at hand is stupidly myopic. And reveals the greater impact autonomous robotic labor will really have. Let's assume California's Central valley in 50 years time is vast swaths of robotic farms. All other human infrastructure in these places die. Restaurants, stores, schools, housing, police fire etc fall back to early 1900s levels (or some smaller density level of the past)
- bcoates 8y agoFarm labor is a tiny fraction of the cost of retail food. It's not material and there is no dilemma. It is extremely material to the narrow profit margins of farms, so you see a race to the bottom with importing slave labor, terrible practices, etc. But enforcing labor standards and minimum wages wouldn't add much to the average American's food bill, even assuming farms couldn't avoid some of the hit by using less or more productive labor.
- SilasX 8y agoThose views are only in tension as long as labor is a significant fraction of the cost of farm output. But the most labor-intensive part the supply chain (per pound of apples) is picking it. This source [1] gives 1000-2000 lb/hour as a typical output rate. At $50/hour, that would only account for ~5 cents/lb. Even if you had policies that firehose-flooded the labor market, that still only saves you a trivial amount on the price of farm output. (I'm guessing most of the cost of apples comes from the price of the land and capital.) It just doesn't look like there's this huge tradeoff we're facing that could justify massively increasing the labor supply. A better explanation would be that, if everyone else uses unauthorized[2] labor, then you have to do it yourself to keep up. [1] https://www.thepennyhoarder.com/make-money/side-gigs/like-work-outside-make-28-hour-picking-apples/ https://www.thepennyhoarder.com/make-money/side-gigs/like-wo... [2] "illegal" is apparently taboo now, but "undocumented" is Orwellian.
- reaperducer 8y agomost Americans don't want to do back-breaking manual labor for a living Nobody from any country wants to do back-breaking manual labor for a living. But the whole "jobs Americans won't do" is nothing more than a political slogan/talking point. The reality is that Americans will do any job, provided they are fairly compensated. More than once, it's been in the news that a factory/food processing plant/etc... has been busted for having illegal workers, paying its workers below minimum wage, or both. A week later, the factory has to hire legal workers and Americans for the previously under-paid jobs, and there's a line around the block of people willing to now work for a fair rate of pay.
- throwaway5752 8y ago"More than once, it's been in the news that a factory/food processing plant/etc... has been busted for having illegal workers, paying its workers below minimum wage, or both. A week later, the factory has to hire legal workers and Americans for the previously under-paid jobs, and there's a line around the block of people willing to now work for a fair rate of pay." I've never heard that, could you provide a couple of concrete examples?
- reaperducer 8y agoWish I could, but I get most of my news from traditional media. I remember there was a meat packing plant in Colorado a few years ago. I tried Google News, but it's apparently incapable of showing anything but the most recent stories.
- jonathankoren 8y agoThis appears to be the Colorado meat packing plant the parent mentioned. https://www.denverpost.com/2013/01/14/fear-from-swift-plant-raid-resonates-in-greeley-six-years-later/ https://www.denverpost.com/2013/01/14/fear-from-swift-plant-...
- cheez 8y agohttp://www.chicagotribune.com/g00/business/ct-biz-hostess-cloverhill-bimbo-20180201-story.html?i10c.encReferrer=&i10c.ua=1&i10c.dv=22 http://www.chicagotribune.com/g00/business/ct-biz-hostess-cl...
- nickthemagicman 8y agoDo they have to work for cheap though? Are the margins that slim that the owners can't afford to pay their workers more?
- stephengillie 8y ago> most Americans don't want to do back-breaking manual labor for a living, and b) most Americans also want food to be cheap. Combine these and you're right. Most Americans don't want to do back-breaking labor for a pittance. Grocery checkers (union) make $18.50/hour. Bus drivers (union) make $29/hour. Journeyman (union) electricians make $50/hour. Try paying more than $15/hour for farm labor and you'll have more applicants than you know what to do with.