18 ms·
New autonomous farm wants to produce food without human workers
- w0mbat 8y ago> New autonomous farm wants to produce food without human workers Good. I hate it when my food has human workers in it.
- jpm_sd 8y agoIsn't hydroponic farming already pretty low on labor costs? (compared to capital & maintenance costs) Edit: apparently not. The Engadget article is a bit better. "What we found is that the two biggest costs in the indoor farm are labor and electricity" https://www.engadget.com/2018/10/03/future-indoor-agriculture-vertical-farms-robots/ https://www.engadget.com/2018/10/03/future-indoor-agricultur... That tray-lifting machine looks expensive. Are plants other than lettuces suitable for hydroponic farming?
- elyonkiNIR 8y agoSource?
- bufferoverflow 8y agoAirponics is even better, but requires high pressure pumps. You can grow pretty much anything, as long as you feed the right nutrients and control the temperature and the pH.
- Brajeshwar 8y ago"Aeroponics" is indeed a good option but it does not need the "high" pressure pumps. We can pump with very low powered pumps. We, actually, formulate our own nutrients. We are about to start testing our automatic IoT solution to mix nutrients, measure the temperature pH and EC. Right now, we do the testing manually and we can slide the EC by a factor of 0.1 easily. For those interested here is a video of our lab. Our structures are vertical for our research. However, our commercial (big) deployments will be flat or an "A" system. Right now, we are leveraging the abundance of sunlight in the tropics (India). We can produce 10x the traditional farming without any stacking but at a fraction of the cost of other hydroponics/Aeroponics setup. Photos https://photos.app.goo.gl/XytrQYsQ0UaSKozV2 https://photos.app.goo.gl/XytrQYsQ0UaSKozV2 Locavore Demo Tour https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U2CRI61_DlQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U2CRI61_DlQ
- oh_sigh 8y agoAwesome work! I'm experimenting with a custom built, mostly-computer-controlled aeroponic myself, but it is way more on the hobby scale than this work you are doing. One question - do you have any kind of automatic way to clear clogs in the sprayer heads?
- organicaf 8y agoYou could... detect pressure build up -> assume clogged set pressure 0 open a solenoid connected to h2o2 with enough elevation to reach the clog detect flow increase ->assume unclogged close solenoid, set pressure 50 psi (or whatever) This might best be done with a hydraulic circuit rather than electronic sensors, by the way. Ie. to detect pressure build up have a secondary line with slight resistance before the nozzle that when pressurized triggers other hydraulic elements which cut pressure, etc.
- Brajeshwar 8y agoAs replied earlier, we tested and realized we can do much better by dripping it from top instead of the mist. We will also be doing flood-n-flush kinda method in the much bigger setup. Cleaning was one thing we learned the hard way and so the reason for our modified method. We will still be using mist spray method with other crops that has less dense rooting, etc.
- davidhunter 8y agoIn glasshouses a reasonably wide variety of crops can be grown hydroponically including tomatoes, cucumbers, eggplant, lettuce, cannabis, peppers. This Nat Geo article [1] has some interesting data/analysis on greenhouse growing in the Netherlands. The Netherlands are the leaders in high-tech greenhouse growing. Approx 0.2-0.33 of the world's high-tech greenhouses are located there. The biggest costs are financing/depreciation, labour and energy. The balance of these three costs changes significantly depending on your geographical location. I am the founder of a startup [2] based in the Netherlands and backed by Founder's Fund focussed on scaling high-tech greenhouse growing as a method of crop production. I have both a technical background in Reinforcement Learning and have spent time training as a tomato grower. Happy to answer any questions anyone may have at dave@optimal.ag. [1] https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/2017/09/holland-agriculture-sustainable-farming/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/2017/09/holland-... [2] http://optimal.ag http://optimal.ag
- ticmasta 8y agoRight off the bat they compare the production output of their robot interior farm with a comparable exterior farm "5 times the size" - which is another, more subtle, form of BS - how does it compare with a standard "meat powered" indoor farm? Production from hydro/hybrid is higher than traditional outside soil only. >> "What we found is that the two biggest costs in the indoor farm are labor and electricity" this may be true but it doesn't mean the costs of outdoor farming are lower, plus the added cost of land (good farm land is expensive to own or rent)
- KaiserPro 8y ago"plus the added cost of land (good farm land is expensive to own or rent)" Urban land is much more expensive per unit. not only that, but you have the Capital expense of the machinery and buildings, plus the operational expense of heating, lighting, ventilation, and fungus control. http://blog.zipgrow.com/indoor-hydroponic-farming-costs-profits http://blog.zipgrow.com/indoor-hydroponic-farming-costs-prof... has a good overview of the costs. $110k for 500 square feet. excluding building. Then you have the opex for lighting which is $1100 a month. You'll need heating in winter, which will similar cost. To put that in perspective, https://www.uklandandfarms.co.uk/rural-property-for-sale/east-anglia/norfolk/norwich-39764_423815/ https://www.uklandandfarms.co.uk/rural-property-for-sale/eas... grade II soil. $80k, buys you 211266 square feet, with change left over for tractor, plough, seed and tillage hire/buy. Moreover, its not an asset that will depreciate, unless one lets the soil blow away/don't improve it.
- apendleton 8y agoYou can probably grow just about anything, but things with a long growing cycle, big root systems, heavy plants prone to falling over if not well-anchored, etc., are more work. So, fruit trees are a challenge, for example. They end up needing pretty involved scaffolding; I'd imagine that would be a particular challenge to implement with a robot.
- mLuby 8y agoSorry, fully automatic farms require villagers. :P https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Tutorials/Crop_farming#Fully_automatic_farming https://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Tutorials/Crop_farming#Fully...
- cjbenedikt 8y agoGreat. More unemployment creating tech. Oh, no, wait, all those farm hands can become highly sophisticated coders of course.
- maerF0x0 8y agoBut the price of producing that food will decline too. Market economics claims that will lead to a lower price.
- logfromblammo 8y agoStrictly from a nutritional perspective, fruits and green vegetables are better than grains, beans, and tubers. But the cost of farming them is [currently] higher. It is likely that automated farms capable of growing anything would produce the highest-value produce first, and the nutritional value of cheaper foods would increase. Your fast food burger would replace iceberg with leaf lettuce, then the pale flavorless commodity tomatoes with deep red juicy ones. Then maybe the bun will be made with some cauliflower meal in it. The price you pay for the burger will mainly be for the labor, facilities, and transportation, and the mean quality of ingredients will rise, rather than the price going down. If you make meals at home, you will likely have more options for pre-cut foods, and more distributor-packaged, fixed-weight bags with recognizable brand names on them. Rather than one whole head of cauliflower at a time from who-knows-where, you will get a 2# bag of pre-cut fork-sized cauliflower florets in a microwave-ready steamer bag from Edible Head Farms, with full nutrition panel, a recipe, and a heartwarming story about their plucky farming robots on the back. The market already knows you are willing to spend $X on cauliflower, and captures that same amount with lower production costs and a heap of value-adds like pre-processing, brand, convenience, and maybe flavor, if there's still room. The grocery store is already operating on 1% margins, and can't afford to take a hit on giving the same amount of shelf space to cheaper cauliflower. Your lettuce will come in stacked, equal-sized leaves for sandwiches, and in bagged, fork-sized bites for salads.
- cjbenedikt 8y agoUntil of course Coders Automating Their Own Job - https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/10/agents-of-automation/568795/?single_page=true https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/10/agent...
- maerF0x0 8y agoThis guy has been working on something of the same concept for a long time: https://automicrofarm.com/#about https://automicrofarm.com/#about
- ph0rque 8y agoAutoMicroFarm founder here. Thanks for the shoutout! I talked to Iron Ox founders (who went through YC, incidentally) a bit ago. They are focused on the robotics systems for commercial green houses, while I am focused on ways to grow food in your (residential) back yard.
- deialtrous 8y agoI'm not sure I understand the market of your product. Is the intent to trick people into gardening by making it seem "high tech" or trendy or something? Are people actually willing to do more work to grow food if you make it sound new/different? Most people don't garden the easy way, so it just seems like a tough sell to get them to do it a harder way.
- ph0rque 8y agoAutoMicroFarm's vision is to enable people with back yards to 1) grow the majority of their food in their back yard (asymptotically converging to 100%), and 2) spend a minimum of time and effort in order to do so (asymptotically converging to zero time and effort). AutoMicroFarm will provide products and services to that effect. I started out with aquaponics, thinking the end product would need to be high-tech. But it turns out that good design (which the aquaponics industry has not completely agreed upon yet) can obviate the need for high tech. Aside from aquaponics, permaculture goes a long way towards maximizing yield while minimizing time and effort needed on an ongoing basis. However, the time and effort is often front-loaded when the design is installed. Robotics, when ubiquitous and affordable, will transform agriculture, whether on a commercial or a residential level. In the meantime, there are lots of opportunities that I hope to capitalize on.
- 8y ago
- yurishimo 8y agoI wonder how they might deal with something like disease? Robots can easily monitor nutrient levels in the soil, but I wonder if there is a way to monitor the plant's health directly? Theoretically, the plants should be healthy given the controlled environment, but I imagine something will go wrong eventually. Cool concept nonetheless!
- wpietri 8y agoThere are good techniques for monitoring plant health in infrared. They're so common that it's a decent home-hacking project: http://www.richardmudhar.com/blog/2015/07/using-near-ir-to-look-for-photosynthesis-and-plant-health-with-ndvi/ http://www.richardmudhar.com/blog/2015/07/using-near-ir-to-l... It's also something that is done from orbit. E.g.: https://www.esa.int/Our_Activities/Observing_the_Earth/Copernicus/Sentinel-2/Plant_health https://www.esa.int/Our_Activities/Observing_the_Earth/Coper...
- jpm_sd 8y agoNever seen this before: Error 1005 Access denied What happened? The owner of this website (www.richardmudhar.com) has banned the autonomous system number (ASN) your IP address is in (7922) from accessing this website.
- korethr 8y agoLooking it up, ASN 7922 is Comcast. I guess he really doesn't like Comcast and doesn't want Comcast (or their customers) from reaching his site?
- maerF0x0 8y ago> "Over three billion dollars were lost in California alone [in 2017], because there's not enough people to actually do the operations in seeding or harvesting," Brandon Alexander, co-founder of Iron Ox Robotic Farms, told Engadget. "The average age of the farmer now is 58. And so one of the big issues just plaguing farming is that there's just not enough labor to go around. The problem is getting worse every year."[1] I call BS. There is almost always enough labor at the correct price. That means the juice wasn't worth the squeeze (or the employers are making bad choices...) . If farm hands were making $100 an hour I'm sure you'd see a lot more farm hands. Of course they'd also probably be losing money, so that's why we dont see that. [1]: https://www.engadget.com/2018/10/03/future-indoor-agriculture-vertical-farms-robots/ https://www.engadget.com/2018/10/03/future-indoor-agricultur... Edit: this quote was actually from an engadget article linked elsewhere in this post's comments
- SilasX 8y agoWeird. I distinctly remember reading an article 20 years ago that said the average age of a farmer is 58.
- howard941 8y agoYeah why did Alexander even toss in that bit about average farmer age and in the next sentence point out that there's not enough generic labor to go around at the price the average 58 year old farmer is willing to pay? Well-called BS it is.
- ijpoijpoihpiuoh 8y agoThat goes without saying. Anyone who thinks about it for even the least amount of time understands that you can get more labor if you pay a lot for it. "There is not enough labor to go around," means, "There is not enough labor to go around at prices such that we could competitively produce our goods and retain a desirable amount of profit," in essentially one hundred percent of cases. Your objection doesn't take anything away from the thesis that automation may be a way to become more competitive by cutting labor costs.
- maerF0x0 8y ago
- moneil971 8y agoReal-life Farmville?
- m000 8y agoMore like the first step towards Autofac. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6902176/?ref_=ttep_ep8 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6902176/?ref_=ttep_ep8
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- syntaxing 8y agoFrom a technical side, I do not really understand why so many companies use such a complex robotic arm with 5-6 DOF. Wouldn't a SCARA in this case be much better? They're easier to program, simpler kinematics, cheaper, and more robust.
- khawkins 8y agoActually higher degree of freedom arms with 6-7 DOF have simpler kinematics and are easier to program, in general. This is especially the case if you're using sensing and a lightly unstructured task. An end effector pose has 6 DOF (3 translation, 3 rotation). A robot with fewer than 6 DOF can't physically reach all poses in its task space, so if sensing says go here, the kinematics will often say it can get close, but not exactly. A robot with exactly 6 DOF can usually reach all poses in its task space, with a catch. Typically there are only a discrete number of joint configurations for a given pose (like 4 or 8). Thus, if you want to reach a certain pose but all joint configurations are in collision then you are in trouble. Adding just 1 more DOF, making it a 7 DOF arm, ensures that the arm can generally reach any pose with an infinite number of configurations, the last dimension used to plan avoiding collision. If you use motion planning and sensing for all of this, instead of something like a teach pendant where you carefully set all of the desired poses manually, then higher DOF is easier.
- syntaxing 8y agoAre high DOF robot arms easier to program? Most of the ones I've seen are usually done through human "mirroring" where the arm is moved in a generic fashion (and fine tuned by surrounding sensors) by a user and recorded similar to the pendant method you mentioned. I totally understand that a SCARA arm has a lot less flexibility. But wouldnt a low DOF arm be beneficial for an application like this, where the parts being grabbed and placed are in a highly gridded configuration?
- outworlder 8y agoMaybe the explanation is not technical. Which one looks 'better' or 'more sophisticated'? SCARA or a robotic arm? Which one is going to attract more investors?
- nanomonkey 8y agoI personally would love to work on a farm, but not the type you see today. Monoculture and pesticide laden farming practices make for boring work with little to no cultural value. It seems to me that we would see more adoption of farm positions if we provided smaller, integrated farm plots where folks that had their fill of urban living, wanted to raise a family and be closer to nature could be apart of a community. Sort of a replacement for the sterile suburbs where people go to raise families, only with flexible family focused farm jobs. I realize there are intentional communities that provide this, but I wonder if the ag industry is missing out on an opportunity also.
- tdb7893 8y agoI think the issue is that small farms aren't very efficient. My wife's father owns a small farm in Iowa but has another job because it just doesn't make enough money to afford even his pretty meagre lifestyle. Having been around farms in small communities I think that people in cities have idealistic views of what farm life is like.
- sambull 8y agoThey're almost talking about a fundamentally different type of farming. If your just plowing, growing a several crops and using fertilizers and pesticides, your highly dependent on things like price of fertilizer, price of seeds, price of diesel, price of pesticides. Now the hard goods manufactures are killing the secondary market for farm implements and building implements that can't be owner serviced, which makes the farmer even more dependent on price to service those equipment from the dealer only. All of these easily surmountable in a big operation, but stacked against the farmer next door.
- nanomonkey 8y agoI think this depends on your definition of efficiency. For food production to land use, small polyculture farm techniques have been proven to produce more yield. If you're only interested in man hours to yield, then yes large scale farming techniques are more efficient.
- mattberan 8y agoThere's a place called Revol Greens in Medford, MN that is already doing semi-autonomous growing and they are profitable, low error and delicious. Check it out.
- robbrit 8y agoUnrelated to the article (since I couldn't get to it), but it's interesting to see that MIT Technology Review does not allow you to browse in Incognito mode.
- danans 8y agoAs hopeful as I am that we find a technological breakthrough that allows large scale, highly energy efficient production of crops, I'm always struck by that fact that these facilities seem to only produce leafy greens. IINM, to make a dent in the larger agricultural system, these facilities will have to produce high calorie and protein bearing crops, like grains, beans, etc.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoHarvesting of grains is already highly automated, I don't know about beans but peas certainly are as well. Leafy greens along with soft fruit need quite a bit of labour which is in short supply in higher income countries. It makes some sense to target them.
- loceng 8y agoI wonder what the reason that leafy greens would be the "lowest hanging fruit" to go after at first? I assume because they are rapidly growing and would therefore yield a high crop yield, and things like baby spinach in grocery stores always feels brutally expensive - so perhaps a good starting point in terms of retail markup possible? Lightweight, high price point, etc.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoLeafy greens are low hanging goals because 1. Quick turn around (45-60 days) 2. Easy to create hybrids suitable for whatever environment 3. Single harvest(as opposed to tomatoes where there is flowers, ripe and unripe and over ripe fruit amongst canopy all the time).4. We are not trying to make it flower or fruit which makes nutrients easier. 5. Low energy. Doesn’t need a lot of light or heat.
- beerlord 8y ago$/kg
- danans 8y agoThat makes sense. I suppose the argument for this tech is from a business and product quality perspective, which I get. It doesn't seem to have much to do with lowering the natural resources (water, fossil fuels) spent per calorie of food produced at a large scale, though.
- foofoo55 8y agoSeems like wheel-reinvention. There are already many companies providing machinery for large-scale optimized horticultural operations. I used to work with this one: https://www.visser.eu/ https://www.visser.eu/ Notice the task-specific machines and the high plant volumes, such as transplanting machines capable of handling 35,000 plants per hour.
- tw1010 8y agoWhat does this mean for subsistence agriculture? Is starting a self-sufficient religion all of a sudden much cheaper and feasible (after the up-front robot cost has been payed)?
- kibwen 8y agoAside: try opening this tab in an incognito window. In Firefox it works fine, but on Chrome you get "Hello, we noticed you're browsing in private or incognito mode. To continue reading this article, please exit incognito mode or log in." Not even complaining; it's their site and they're absolutely allowed to restrict access to paying customers only, and I commend the frankness with which they admit that they need ad revenue.
- SilasX 8y agoWait, I thought Incognito mode wasn't supposed to give telltale signs of being Incognito, besides e.g. lack of cookies, which is indistinguishable from a new user?
- kibwen 8y agoI figured StackOverflow would have a thread with ways to detect incognito mode, and sure enough: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/2909367/can-you-determine-if-chrome-is-in-incognito-mode-via-a-script https://stackoverflow.com/questions/2909367/can-you-determin... Here's a jsfiddle to demonstrate: http://jsfiddle.net/w49x9f1a/ http://jsfiddle.net/w49x9f1a/ TL;DR: the disabling of the filesystem API gives it away.
- tomp 8y agoa quick Google search suggests that the Filesystem API is disabled in incognito Chrome... I never understood why APIs like this would ever be disabled. Why not just have it return "blank" responses?! Same goes for e.g. iPhone "access to contacts/location/etc"...
- andrewla 8y agoI don't think it's ad revenue -- they say on that page that "Visitors are allowed 3 free articles per month (without a subscription), and private browsing prevents us from counting how many stories you've read. We hope you understand, and consider subscribing for unlimited online access."
- 8y ago
- dwighttk 8y agocall me back when they are making money
- mythrwy 8y agoI knew it, always these little salads. That isn't food, it's a condiment. Also pretty sure its a ton more efficient to grow these in a field, under the sun. Want to make a cool robot? Make a field scale planting/harvesting robot for this and that might have some application. This is just a gimmick.
- wessorh 8y agoprogramming organic farmer here, we live in a 7 acre organic farm north of Berkeley. The robots aren't going to win in agriculture, maybe you could do with with pot; but not with lettuce. There is lots of stupid money in the system and this is just one example.
- hughes 8y agoIn Asimov's giant underground cities, robots toiled on the exposed ground above to produce food for the masses. Interesting step in that direction.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoThis is one of my future farm scenarios (like Italo Calvino’s Invisible Cities, I am going to come up with a hundred diff future ways to farm!)..Asimov is awesome but I am also inspired by Kim Stanley Robinson’s Mars trilogy. Anyways...underground cities with aqua/hydroponic farms and orchards and livestock on the surface. Permaculture style farming!
- kidsnow 8y agoThere has to be a way to have a standard container of dirt, and have it move around various "stations" on a set of tracks or rails, where it is tended to at each station by robots.
- contingencies 8y agoThis article is all over the place and then apparently quotes an academic out of context. The real problem with indoor farming is not setup cost. For the fundamentals: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ISAKc9gpGjw&feature=youtu.be&t=13m26s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ISAKc9gpGjw&feature=youtu.be... ... Bruce Bugbee, Utah State University Department of Plants, Soils and Climate, has studied plant growth in controlled environments for most of his career presents the results of his analysis of the environmental effects of Vertical Farming/Indoor Agriculture (September 2015). With regards to the machinery shown at the top of the article, it is standard industrial automation equipment you can purchase off the shelf, apparently not even hardened or substantially adjusted for outdoor use.
- OliverJones 8y agoHmmm. Planting and harvesting workers, and their machines (combines, etc), move around to follow the seasons. A useful tech for these folks might be a weather- and demand- aware Lyft-like system. But they probably already have it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jelliclesfarm 8y agohttps://youtu.be/V1PcgtWAEnU https://youtu.be/V1PcgtWAEnU : already been done. Americans are far behind the Dutch. What frustrates me is that everyone is making their version of the wheel in their corner instead of collaborating. Right now, VC money should go to other things like AI, supply chain integrated into production, blockchain etc. And they must have farmers as partners. Farmers completely distrust tech because we are not included. I gave up trying. It’s like we speak different languages but when tech is trying to create produce for MY domain,isn’t my participation and input necessary? I am particularly bummed because I applied to YC twice and it always comes back to finding a tech partner. My tech is farming. I know stuff your roboticist or engineer can’t dream of because we live that nightmare of crop failure or machines failing all the time. At this point, I think I am going to write stories like sci fi or fantasy and maybe someone will realize my vision(or not..who knows..maybe it’s not the right fit, but I will never know) after I am gone. I really enjoy coming up with theoretical solutions because at this point, that’s all I can do. I would have discouraged Iron Ox from that idea. Who transplants one at a time when technology exists to do thousands at a time? Why? I can’t even wrap my mind around this.
- kodablah 8y ago> I gave up trying [...] that’s all I can do That's unfortunate that you feel this way. Quite frequently the ones I see succeed aren't the best at their tech either (be it their focused field or general tech). Tech VCs gravitate towards tech people. Surely that is obvious and you shouldn't give up after only consulting them. Let them solve things the only way they know how, and maybe you can find someone else to take a different approach with your ideas. Or maybe not. You shouldn't feel so slighted/jaded by it though. We all feel our ideas, be they ones proven in other scenarios or not, are workable.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoThank you.I am just collecting information and data and general trends now. And I am noting down what fails and what has succeeded. I feel like this might take longer but I am not failing on my dime. Perhaps that’s a good thing because I would have never thought about IoT or blockchain 4 years ago, but now I see how it can be implemented under the umbrella of Agtech. We need an ecosystem of sorts. And we need to be able to scale up as well as down. And we need solutions for 30 years down the line. One thing I find striking is that tech coming out is solving problems of today. But what good is that? I want to be able to predict how land availability and lack of water or climate change or labour shortage will affect me in the future so I can get ahead with a method that will eventually merge with the future painlessly. But I have also met some very helpful people in the industry who are more than happy to share or at least hear me out. There is enormous value in having people from other disciplines and others who are not farmers to be sounding board. I also know that including us has some value. By ‘us’, I mean smallholder farm operators and the farm workers. In big industrialized farms, it’s already mechanized and it’s just one step away from automation. They pain point is availability of labour.(and to a certain extent, regulation in California..dont know about other states) But in smaller farms, we are talking the difference between breaking even and loss. Especially if we are organic because we don’t spray and can’t have huge machinery. And labour is our biggest cost. Not availability of labour, but the cost of labour. Small scale farm bots are needed. They can scale. Massive autonomous tractors meant to 1000 acres of corn and soy is useless to us. I feel a kinship with the Lilliputian scale of indoor farming. I get it. I am also inspired by it. But outside, we got sunshine. And it’s free. Nothing is cheaper than free!
- jelliclesfarm 8y agohttps://youtu.be/xxAaKpRMOTw https://youtu.be/xxAaKpRMOTw : this is outdoor baby spring mix operation in California. I know whose this is...the grower, packer and distributor..they have perfected it to an art form. When I see social media photos of a young person leaning over a baby plant grown hydroponically with a pair of baby scissors, I have to wonder if they have a clue about the scale and economies of growing outdoors by the established growers. Having said that, my position has always been that lettuce(and strawberries) should be moved indoors because they are ground huggers. Lettuce has been easy to automate indoors but strawberries have continuous fruit production and a canopy and keeps on going for a longer season. So it has proved to be meow difficult. Also needs a lot of targeted lighting because it has to fruit and flower. Automation is a beautiful thing. It comes from a keen study of the repetitive movements that goes into the task at hand. But machines can never replace humans everywhere and for every crop, but it can certainly make farming better. When I attended TechCrunch this year, in one of the panels, (robotics investment by VC) the moderator asked if replacing strawberry pickers with ‘roombas’ is unethical because the strawberry pickers won’t have jobs. I was very upset and am pretty sure she hasn’t picked strawberries bent over or even seen the workers do this for hours and being paid by the clamshells and not by the hour. It is also this kind of thinking that is holding back technology and innovation. Let’s find them other jobs. Better jobs. Make education accessible. Who knows..the strawberry picker could be a genius or a musician or just someone who wants a simpler less back breaking job. Who are these tech people and moderators and VCs go try and ‘save’ farmers and farm workers who desperately need tech to help them. Instead these are the kind of concerns I heard at TechCrunch. It was very disheartening. I am not very hopeful. They are all throwing $$ down the drain and america’s crutch is cheap labour. Europe is far ahead because they don’t have cheap labour. Japan, Middle East and even down under, they are innovating because their pain points are ageing population, water availability in deserts and in Oz.nz, labour. China is making great strides and surpassing EU with their farm tech innovation and especially with robotics. We are being left behind because we are allowing something so essential as food production, distribution to become fodder for politically correct faff talk. I was thinking to myself..that it makes no sense. If you break down some of the concerns ‘tech folk’ who want to ‘help’ farming into words and meanings, it was just dead words...killed by the sword of ignorance and hubris. Unethical to replace strawberry pickers with robots? It was very painful to hear that kind of talk.
- abalone 8y agoWe need to talk more about the energy consumption of these farms. They are marketing themselves with "green" branding but.. they are indoors and use artificial light. One study found hydroponics use 7X more energy: "At this point in time, hydroponic farming of lettuce cannot be deemed a more sustainable alternative to conventional lettuce farming techniques, but it provides promising concepts that could lead to more sustainable food production."[1] And yes conventional agriculture has other negative impacts (water, transport, land), but I'm not hearing much about energy use from these startups. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4483736/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4483736/
- freeflight 8y ago> One study found hydroponics use 7X more energy Hydroponics also create a lot of wastewater, its a fact rarely mentioned but when the goal is sustainability then created waste should also be accounted for. Aquaponic systems don't have that issue because they copy a natural ecosystem on a small scale. Imho that's where the future of human food production needs to go.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI agree that aquaponics is ‘cleaner’ than hydroponics but now we are into fish farming and not just growing plants as food. It’s certainly the more organic option. There is a company that is trying to use organic/natural hydroponic nutrient inputs than just what’s been used all along. It will take some time(and testing) to adapt.
- iancmceachern 8y agoCheck out our product in this space, Growstrip by growcomputer. We just launched on Indigogo go here: https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/the-growstrip-by-grow-computer#/ https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/the-growstrip-by-grow-com...
- carapace 8y agoOur automation should be more biomimetic, rather than making our agriculture more mechanical. For example, there's a fellow who shows how to integrate small-scale alcohol fuel production into a Permaculture farm: http://alcoholcanbeagas.com/node/518 http://alcoholcanbeagas.com/node/518 (Permaculture is a form of applied ecology.)
- PostOnce 8y agoCan't wait for the mergers & acquisitions that leave one guy owning the autonomous farm, autonomous delivery trucks, self-checkout-only supermarkets, and bank that issues the card you use to pay for it. Also, he's your boss.
- blobbers 8y agoOnce skynet takes over the headline will be: 'New autonomous farm wants to produce fuel without human workers' ... fuel for the robots.
- jhoechtl 8y agoI always wondered why we have ti pay for our basic needs given the degree of automation we have achieved. Is this the beginning of the golden era?
- gdubs 8y agoAs a technologist who’s gotten into farming (specifically permaculture and agroforestry), I think it’s great that we’re exploring all avenues to keep up with feeding the billions of people on the planet, but I think we’re also giving up a lot of what makes us human the more we distance ourselves from the land, and from food production.
- wes-k 8y agoFor personal gardens, there is a cool open source project called Farm Bot: https://farm.bot/ https://farm.bot/