>Yes (if by implausible you mean unconvincing). Reject and resubmit with more powerful statistics. I should clarify here- I mean implausible by the standard of

>Yes (if by implausible you mean unconvincing). Reject and resubmit with more powerful statistics. I should clarify here- I mean implausible by the standard of common sense, but backed up by the statistics presented in the paper, which was the case here.