3 ms·
It is the event horizon that never forms. The problem that is never dealt with is that when the density of material goes up, gravity goes up, time dilation thro
by oldandtired 8y ago
It is the event horizon that never forms. The problem that is never dealt with is that when the density of material goes up, gravity goes up, time dilation throughout all the affected material increases. From our perspective, everything throughout the affected material and region slows down - that includes any compression effects to increase the density. There is no opportunity for the effects to generate an event horizon to occur in finite time. If the event horizon cannot form then you can forget about any singularity ever forming.
It is just assumed that the event horizon and all of the associated effects will occur in finite time. It is taken as a given that "Black Holes" exist without questioning all of the assumptions being made regarding these entities. When anyone questions this view, the amount of disdain and ridicule expressed to them is just ridiculous.
Those expressing such disdain and ridicule do not even attempt to answer the questions - it is immediate ad hominen attack. This is the attitude that encouraged me to investigate the matter further and the conclusion is that those experts who support the idea of "Black Holes" have a mindset of "we are the authority and who are you to question us". They are so blinded by there own brilliance that they cannot see the forest because they have their noses up against the ground. It is a sorry state of affairs when dogma gets in the road of investigation.
There are no stupid questions, ever. However, there are many non-answers given.
- AgentME 8y agoThe event horizon might never "complete" in finite time either, but from the outside it can become increasingly indistinguishable from a complete event horizon over time as the black hole's mass compresses along the surface of the event horizon. Light escapes from the mass less and much less often over time. Black holes were originally often called "frozen stars" to emphasize how from our point of view, the mass never quite made it into the interior of the event horizon. Relevant: https://astronomy.stackexchange.com/a/14239 https://astronomy.stackexchange.com/a/14239. It seems like you're just placing restrictions on the term "black hole" that no one else is.