5 ms·
On the other hand, to my knowledge very few if any small-and-cheap double-Gauss "nifty fifties" are particularly great wide open on modern high-resolution senso
by Sharlin 8y ago
On the other hand, to my knowledge very few if any small-and-cheap double-Gauss "nifty fifties" are particularly great wide open on modern high-resolution sensors. Though it could be argued that the current drive for ultra-sharpness among the "Ad-Am" crowd again stems more from prestige—and the tendency to pixel-peep—rather than any real need. Especially in a world where the vast majority of photos are viewed at low resolutions, highly compressed, and on small screens.
Mirrorless, with its short backfocus distance compared to SLRs, does bring onto table the feasibility of inexpensive and compact "normal" lenses for APS-C and smaller sensors. The Panasonic 25mm f/1.8 for MFT is a good example, as is the recently announced Canon EF-M 32mm f/1.4.
- foldr 8y agoIf you'll forgive me for adding some of the usual anecdotal noise to this discussion, I have been surprised before by how well older lenses perform with modern sensors. For example, I bought a Nikon 40mm f/2.8 G AF-S DX Micro to replace an ancient 55mm pre-AI Micro Nikkor, but found that the Micro Nikkor produced noticeably sharper results. I was using a D3300 with a 24MP APS-C sensor. The pixel density of that sensor exceeds the practical resolving limit of 35mm film in the 1960s by a wide margin. (It would be a 50MP sensor if it was full frame.)
- rangibaby 8y agoI can think of a few possibilities: - AN lens is over-engineered. They didn't have CAD to help them design a lens that is perfectly "sharp enough" at a certain resolution so just made a design that had way more resolving power than it needed. The downside is that the AN lens probably cost more new when adjusted for inflation. e.g. Voigtlander lenses for Nikon may seem expensive but adjusted for inflation they are comparable in price to Nikon's made in Japan, all-metal lenses from back in the day. - Sample variation. Maybe your new lens is a dud; it happens - user error. More than once I have seen a lens review call a lens soft when the test picture is obviously not focused correctly
- mauvehaus 8y agoMost of the reviews of the Pentax fifties contain words to the effect that they aren't super sharp around the edges of the frame wide open, but that they sharpen up by f/2. I don't have any background in optics, but I've operated under the assumption that most lenses at full aperture necessarily compromise some resolution for speed, meaning you have the same loss of resolution with a 28mm or 35mm lens at full aperture. Are other focal lengths of different designs where this doesn't hold true? Do modern sensors have enough more resolution than film that they show the loss of sharpness in the lens at smaller apertures? I'm curious because I'll be looking for a (used) DSLR body at some point in the next few years. At least in the Pentax world, most of the commentary about old lenses on new bodies centers around the lack of the mechanical aperture coupling on the newer bodies, and the compromises stemming from that (stop-down metering, mostly).
- rangibaby 8y ago> Do modern sensors have enough more resolution than film that they show the loss of sharpness in the lens at smaller apertures? Film quite obviously shows soft corners too, just most people didn't care because they weren't obvious at the sizes normal people view or printed photos. I wouldn't worry about soft corners to be honest. It's like criticizing a classic muscle car because it has a slower 0-100 than newer ones
- jasomill 8y agoI agree. And if your underlying question is "are these lenses going to take good pictures with this camera", the best advice I can give is: try it! I say this because some of my favorite lens/camera combinations are those with issues far beyond mere unsharpness, and that would likely be rejected by the mass of Internet forum cognoscenti in favor of native lenses that I know from experience that I'd never use even if I already owned them. Case in point: an old Arri/Zeiss 16mm f/1.2 cine lens that I shoot on Micro Four Thirds, despite the fact that it was designed for the much smaller 16mm (motion picture) format: in spite of edges are soft at all apertures, corners that aren't so much "soft" as "missing altogether", an overall image almost certainly less sharp than the average native kit zoom, and various other technical considerations compromising optical performance, I enjoy both the process of shooting with the lens and the results when I do. So why, then, should I give a damn what the Internet thinks? Whereas, I sold the more "appropriate" Panasonic 15mm f/1.7 native lens several years ago, at a considerable loss, for lack of use.
- rangibaby 8y agoGreat for what? fast 50's flare ("vintage glow") wide open can make them great for portrait photography because it gives a pleasant quality to skin. It's a shame that pixel-peepers get to define what a good lens is these days, but unfortunately they are the people who buy new, expensive lenses... ...Nikon making their flagship lenses for their mirrorless camera "slow" is a very good sign to me. It is a sign that they are concentrating on their photo-taking ability rather than specs. I think they did serious soul searching after their dud 105mm f/1.4 (it's great at f/1.4, as long as you only want one eye in focus)
- Sharlin 8y agoYes, the dreamy glow can be useful in certain situations, but on the other hand many feel the effect is overused and passé. Plus you can always achieve it in post, but you can't make a dreamy-glowy photo sharp. A sharp lens is strictly more useful in the digital era.
- rangibaby 8y ago> Plus you can always achieve it in post, but you can't make a dreamy-glowy photo sharp. Actually it is possible to mostly get rid of the kind of flare I am talking about in post. It depends on the lens but often the are actually have high resolution wide open, just the flare makes them look softer. > A sharp lens is strictly more useful in the digital era. Sure, if sharpness is the only criteria you judge usefulness by. Nifty 50 lenses are still tiny and cheap and sharp enough for most things.
- jasomill 8y agoLens resolution doesn't necessarily translate to maximum image sharpness in particular shooting scenarios, digital or otherwise. For instance, when subjects are not neatly aligned near a narrow plane orthogonal to the lens axis, employing a bit of lens tilt may enable shooting at a considerably larger aperture without losing focus on any of the subjects. In such cases, as a result of diffraction effects at larger apertures, a tilt/shift (or view camera) lens that fares comparatively poorly in resolution tests may nevertheless produce a sharper image of the subjects than a lens without movements could ever hope to produce, even in theory. Yet many feel tilt/shift effects are overused and passé, and mistakenly believe they are always achievable in post…