10 ms·
Academic Grievance Studies and the Corruption of Scholarship
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ergothus 8y ago> Because open, good-faith conversation around topics of identity such as gender, race, and sexuality (and the scholarship that works with them) is nearly impossible, our aim has been to reboot these conversations. ... > a clear reason to look at the identitarian madness coming out of the academic and activist left I'm going to revisit the article later, because the first few paragraphs threw up many red flags, coming across as someones with a chip on their shoulder that sought out to "prove" themselves correct. Hopefully this is a misunderstanding on my part, but I recommend others attempting persuasion to avoid such signaling.
- unparagoned 8y agoYeh, it's kind of redicoulius how much of a bias there is. It sounds like some Sam Harris or Jordan Peterson disciples going out to battle for them. It's been established that journals of all kind, including physics are susceptable to accepting papers that aren't up to snuff. The is even an app which will write such papers for you. It's just a hit piece. I'm more interested in the reason why to be honest.
- kryogen1c 8y agoAs a serious JP fan I take offense to this. That is irrelevant, however. Did you read the article or just identify it as something you don't like philosophically and completely ignore it's merits? This is the exact identitarian madness in question. > It's been established that journals of all kind, including physics are susceptable to accepting papers that aren't up to snuff. The article is quite clear that it's not trying to sneak one slightly substandard paper under the radar. They write 20 papers with the same academic rigor as the accepted literature in the field. EDIT: typos
- ForHackernews 8y agoDon't take this personally but Jordan Peterson is a hack: https://www.currentaffairs.org/2018/03/the-intellectual-we-deserve https://www.currentaffairs.org/2018/03/the-intellectual-we-d... (Or, if you don't want to read that, listen to him flailing around in this non-political debate: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vsyZcKUP_-k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vsyZcKUP_-k )
- Mediterraneo10 8y agoIt is a shame to see you downvoted here for linking to that well-argued article. I know Jordan Peterson seems to have quite an impact on young men, but for older folks who have been around for a while, it is easy to see him as just this era’s Carlos Castaneda or other shallow (and probably rather ephemeral) spiritual guru.
- kryogen1c 8y agoI dont think its a shame at all - that article is not the least bit well-argued. It goes pages before it quotes JP or in any way tries to debate his views. Here are some excepts from this "well-argued article": >Jordan Peterson appears very profound and has convinced many people to take him seriously. Yet he has almost nothing of value to say. >They are half nonsense, half banality. In a reasonable world, Peterson would be seen as the kind of tedious crackpot that one hopes not to get seated next to on a train. >A more important reason why Peterson is “misinterpreted” is that he is so consistently vague and vacillating that it’s impossible to tell what he is “actually saying.” Actually quotes JPs book, in what the author clearly thinks the reader will find is a confusing way (i dont) >But here I am already giving Peterson’s work a more coherent summary than it actually deserves. Note that i did not pull those out of context; there is no supporting evidence. the author just... says stuff. This is the opposite of well-written. It is ad-hominem after playground insult. there is no point counter-point or debate format of any kind. the author basically assumes you think JP is not meaningful and then makes fun of the way he speaks.
- 8y ago
- Yoric 8y agoSeriously, there's an app for that? Do you have more details?
- kryogen1c 8y agoI don't remember when, but they discuss options here https://youtu.be/ras_VYgA77Q https://youtu.be/ras_VYgA77Q
- waterhouse 8y agoTo be flippant, it sounds like you're quick to assume bad faith, which would seem to support the first point you quote. The experiment they ran was to try to get terrible papers published in authoritative journals in certain fields. If they succeeded, this would point towards a serious problem with established practice in those fields; their suspicion of such a problem might be labeled a "chip on their shoulder" or a "hypothesis". According to what they say, they succeeded. As for it being "identitarian madness" and "coming out of the academic and activist left"—do you think either of those parts is false or is irrelevant to what they're studying? If not, how would you suggest they talk about it?
- candiodari 8y agoYou're oppressing the GP with your white straight male science. You see your argument only makes sense if objective reality exists, as the argument fundamentally is about measuring objective reality. But objective reality has been firmly demonstrated to be false, and nothing more than a tool for oppression of women and minorities.
- dang 8y agoPlease don't low-rent ideological flamewar here. It's staggeringly boring.
- slivym 8y agoThey literally have a video in the introduction which documents them deliberately submitting papers that they've engineered to have problems in bad faith to try and manufacture evidence that bad studies can get into journals. They establish that they act in bad faith.
- claudius 8y agoWhile authors ideally should act in good faith and only submit good papers, the whole idea of having journals and editors and peer review is to filter out bad papers. The problem here is not some people "deliberately submitting papers" which "have problems", the problem is that those papers were accepted by "academic" journals. This is not "manufacturing" evidence, this is simply evidence. The bad guys here are not random authors but the journal editors and peer reviewers accepting this stuff.
- barry-cotter 8y agoThey got an article accepted in Hypatia, the flagship journal of feminist philosophy. I’ve never heard of any of the other journals and have no idea if they’re held in low regard generally but Hypatia is as good as it gets in that field. They may have had an almighty chip on their shoulders but they do seem to have proved themselves correct. They got articles accepted in the Journal of Poetry Therapy, Affilia, Fat Studies, Gender, Place and Culture, Sexuality and Culture, Sex Roles and Hypatia.
- barry-cotter 8y agoThe most impressive hoodwinking was of Hypatia which is the top journal in feminist philosophy. Obviously one sees why other philosophers might be dismissive of it now. https://feministphilosophers.wordpress.com/2007/07/11/philosophy-journal-rankings/ https://feministphilosophers.wordpress.com/2007/07/11/philos... > It can also be difficult to get publications in Hypatia taken seriously by one’s department: I know of at least one junior faculty member who was told that she needed to get some more ‘mainstream’ publications, despite her publication in Hypatia, the top journal in her field
- mrleiter 8y agoThat is not only an issue in academics, but in society as a whole. There is no culture of moderate discussion and respect anymore. Arguments are only valid if they fit the ideology. That is highly concerning.
- aortega 8y agoThis has happened before. Consider this: Current diversity politics is diversity of skin color or gender, but not of though. You are only allowed to think in a certain way if you want to belong to the group. This is not really diversity, it's superficial diversity.
- jimhefferon 8y ago> That is not only an issue in academics, but in society as a whole True, but academics needs to be able to stand apart.
- buboard 8y ago> but in society as a whole Academy is usually ahead of society in general. What you see today is the result of decades of activist science.
- Yoric 8y agoWhile this article is interesting, it does start from a pretty strong assumption: that the problem is specific to one branch (or family of branches) of Academia. I remember at least two similar scandals in very much non-social-justice-related branches of Academia. One was in postmodern studies, if I recall correctly, the other one I think in epistemology. In one case, the paper had been written to deliberately mean nothing, in the other one, I seem to remember that the papers had been generated with Markov chains. So, based on the same data, my personal conclusion is that some fields of Academia are vulnerable to bullshit, whether it's sophistry or simply using the right lingo. It is a pretty bad sign, and I suspect that it is correlated with fields in which results are hard to check/reproduce. It may also be correlated with ideology (I remember that this was the accusation towards postmodern studies), which doesn't mean that it is correlated with any specific ideology. In other words: promising research, but the starting hypothesis and its possible limitations need to be expressed more clearly, and much more data needed.
- kryogen1c 8y ago> I remember at least two similar scandals in very much non-social-justice-related branches of Academia. One was in postmodern studies, if I recall correctly, the other one I think in epistemology. In one case, the paper had been written to deliberately mean nothing, in the other one, I seem to remember that the papers had been generated with Markov chains. The article is very clear in it's methodologies and is interacting with the community in a long-term peer-reviewed manner. They were invited to peer-review other papers. This is not one substandard paper that was published in a no-name journal. If your field of academia is this vulnerable to nonsense, perhaps we should start considering the field not academic and purge it from out institutions of learning.
- Yoric 8y ago> If your field of academia is this vulnerable to nonsense, perhaps we should start considering the field not academic and purge it from out institutions of learning. I seem to remember that the non sensical paper was in the top journal of postmodern studies. I don't remember details about the Markov chain papers. Also, I have seen bullshit papers in established journals in computer science. Not many, but then, computer science results are somewhat harder to fake than humanities, and I don't think there were many social engineering attacks on CS journals such as the one described in the OP. So, yes, it seems that the OP describes a real problem. For the reasons mentioned above, I do not believe it is limited to social-justice-related-branches. You are right that this should serve as a wake-up call. Personally, I believe that such wake-up calls are useful for a domain, once in a while. The ball is now on the side of editors. If they manage to raise the bar for accepting papers, their field will have benefited from this work. It is also possible, as you suggest, that the field is not of academic interest. As I have read exactly 0 articles from the publications targeted by the OP, I have no factual base to discuss this. edit grammar
- mpweiher 8y agoBackground video by the authors: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kVk9a5Jcd1k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kVk9a5Jcd1k
- slivym 8y agoI'm not a big fan of this article at all. Firstly, if you want to try and actually persuade people of a point don't preface your entire discussion by deciding to use an epithet to describe what you're discussing. How can I take seriously someone who goes straight in and goes "This is grievance studies"? It seems kind of funky how meta it is to adopt that epithet and then go on to make the accusation that the people you are talking about are acting in bad faith. Reading through the methodology I'm really struggling to see what the actual value of what they're doing is. For example - the Dog Park study: >What if we write a paper saying we should train men like we do dogs—to prevent rape culture? Hence came the “Dog Park” paper. If you want to assert that this is a nutty idea - please back up that claim. Because I feel fairly comfortable arguing that we can learn a lot about social constructs by studying how they differ in other species. There's nothing wrong with that concept. Maybe there's something glaringly wrong in that particular paper, but these authors do nothing to actually demonstrate that. Later on that go into detail with this. That paper is meant to have implausible statistics. Ok, what is peer review meant to do? Reject studies that have implausible findings? We have a word for that - Bias. The correct response to a paper with implausible findings is to publish it and let people follow up and do their own studies. That is the system working correctly. As for advocating for outlandish actions as a result of the study. Well authors are welcome to suggest anything that like as a result of their research. Publishing it doesn't imply endorsement. It implies "This is a real study". So let's talk science. I have a confounding variable - bad studies got published because it's better to publish lots and let the academic community decide the merits of the study than to censor what you think is either implausible or has troubling parts. That explains all the results of this study without the wildly insulting and vaguely conspiracy theorist assertion that these papers get published because of an agenda on the part of academics.
- calahad 8y ago"Maybe there's something glaringly wrong in that particular paper, but these authors do nothing to actually demonstrate that." He first states that the particular paper's flaw is the use of implausible statistics, then goes into more detail: "There was also considerable silliness including claiming to have tactfully inspected the genitals of slightly fewer than 10,000 dogs whilst interrogating owners as to their sexuality (“Dog Park”),"
- danieltillett 8y agoWell at least we now have a good use for the neutron bomb.
- dang 8y agoPlease don't post like this here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- danieltillett 8y agoMy post was a bit flippant, but it does capture my strong feelings on this matter. Not that is matters now my post has been downvoted to oblivion, but I do think we need a complete clear out of the Arts facilities and to start again from scratch. The arts are far too important to be left in the hands of the people who have passed through an arts degree of the last 40 years.
- kodis 8y agoThis looks like Sokol version 2.0. A bunch of hoax papers designed to demonstrate the lack of rigor in what some of the Social Science journals accept.
- lukev 8y agoIf you find yourself in strong agreement with this article, it'd probably be worthwhile doing some introspection what's actually bothering you -- the fact that some publications (apparently) lack academic rigor, or that you oppose them ideologically. Based on the tone of the original article, it's pretty clear what's motivating them. Hard to imagine them summoning the same outrage if they'd managed to sneak in some bogus papers to a physics or medical journal (which, by they way, has happened.)
- throwaway5250 8y agoWith due respect, ideology is ultimately the only reason that anything gets done. RMS would never have created GNU, with all of its fabulously useful result, had he merely thought that existing tools were of insufficient quality. The whole point of academia is that people who oppose you are going to take their best shot at ripping your work to shreds. If your work can withstand their worst, we'll all know that it's (probably) really good stuff. Alternatively, if your work blows over in a light wind, better that everyone should know as soon as possible.
- collyw 8y agoAndrew Wakefield managed that. It did receive a lot of criticism.
- rajekas 8y agoWe can all agree that cultishness is a general human failing and leftist cults are as likely to form as Branch Davidians. Historically, some of those cults have caused immense harm. Nevertheless, this article strikes me as being deliberately written for its own cult members. Its air of injured rationality is exhibit A in grievance studies, the white people version. Is there some vast underground of fence-sitters waiting to be convinced by their argument? I doubt it. Instead, the article is catnip for those who share the same grievances as the writers. Sure, they have one more data point that the other side is gullible or stupid. I am more than willing to admit that portions of academia are cultish with guru figures who can easily destroy your life. However, all one needs to do is look outside the ivory tower and ask if there are real injustices in the world, and the answer isn't hard to find. The vast majority of activists I know, women and men fighting for the rights of women, people of color, animals and trees have no interest in the battles over grievance studies. This is not an article written in good faith. Which is to say, it's propaganda.
- lallysingh 8y agoNo. It's an article that's pointing out a problem with a field of study that points out problems. Which is not just a valid concern, but rather critical to keeping that field of study from the problems of groupthink. > However, all one needs to do is look outside the ivory tower and ask if there are real injustices in the world, and the answer isn't hard to find. The vast majority of activists I know, women and men fighting for the rights of women, people of color, animals and trees have no interest in the battles over grievance studies. > This is not an article written in good faith. Which is to say, it's propaganda. I don't know what you're trying to say here. It sounds like you're saying that because you don't care about the problems listed in the article, and that there are other problems to talk about instead, that by focusing on these problems in the article, it must have been written in bad faith?
- karmajunkie 8y agoI couldn't get through the preface with a straight face. There's something really meta about a study which is attacking ideology within academia that is clearly driven by the authors own ideological bias, which presumably had not find a welcome audience in these fields. Labeling a wide swath of the humanities as "grievance studies" belies their ultimate aim, which is to discredit them on an ideological basis rather than on the merits of the arguments.
- lallysingh 8y agoOk, but let's not discount the work ad-hominem. Are the fields subject to problems of behavior inconsistent with principles the fields typically consider important? If one important principle is fairness between groups of people, then substitution of one group for another in matters of treatment shouldn't alter the results without consideration. If you wouldn't treat group A this way, then it would be inconsistent to accept treating group B the same way without discussing why. And that discussion should be held to some rigor. Without it, we're just talking about group A "vs" group B, instead of principles of how all groups should be treated. Yes, clearly grievances of each group are worth study and analysis. But it deters from the significance of their results if they accept the creation of isomorphic grievances. [spoken, rather obviously, as a computer scientist peering into this field of study from the outside]
- tomcam 8y agoHonest question: what is their ideological bias based on what you read in the preface?
- gambler 8y agoYou're setting up an entirely non-falsifiable argument. Do multiple publications of obvious nonsense in peer-reviewed journals prove nothing to you? How do you know there are no other authors doing the same thing with different intent? What level of nonsense would have to get through for you to question the validity field?
- fiatjaf 8y agoYou're attacking their study with your ideology.
- honkycat 8y agoNot convinced this study is ethical, but I do find it humorous. 7/20 bullshit studies published is a lot of studies, full stop. The methodology with which they pursued the publishing of the studies is telling as well. I don't think it discredits these fields enough to re-brand them as "Grievance Studies" but I do think a 35% success rate by pandering to the journal's obvious biases says something important about the quality of discourse in these fields.
- buboard 8y agoStill though, the study need to control for the opposite hypothesis (submit right-leaning but sound-looking papers)