4 ms·
"First you need to understand that the Big Bang was not an explosion of matter into space, it was an explosion of matter and space (technically space-time)." T
by perl4ever 8y ago
"First you need to understand that the Big Bang was not an explosion of matter into space, it was an explosion of matter and space (technically space-time)."
This is a type of statement I have read many, many times, but to me, it's the same as saying "wakalixes!". I've never read anything that gave me a hint of why and how there should be a difference between two objects receding from each other and "space itself" expanding.
- ketralnis 8y agoNew space is being created between those two things. When they move 1 meter apart from each other through space, they'd move 1 meter back again to meet up. But when space itself is expanding between them, they've moved 1 meter apart but now to get back together they have to move 2 meters. This has some other subtler ramifications. It means that the space between the two objects can increase at faster than the speed of light (because you can't move through space faster than light, but space can expand faster than light). Also, with the Higg's field's nonzero rest value _energy can be created from nothing_ by creating space. Yes, this violates conservation of energy.
- kamaal 8y ago>>It means that the space between the two objects can increase at faster than the speed of light Say they are two objects in the universe A and B. New space is created between A and B faster than the speed of light. There is a USB drive carrying a dump of wikipedia on B. Does this imply information is now moving faster than the speed of light?
- danbruc 8y agoNo because the USB stick is going nowhere, it just remains at B. Imagine a tiled floor where A and B are the centers of two tiles, the USB stick also resting on the B tile. Expansion of space just means that you are constantly increasing the gaps between tiles maybe inserting new tiles every time the gaps become wide enough. The USB stick however just rests on the B tile not moving through space, i.e. reaching another tile, ever.
- kamaal 8y agoExplain to me how this works. A and B remain stationary while only new space gets created between them? By geometry, the shortest distance between two points is a straight line. If A and B are two stationary objects, with a straight line being shortest distance between them. Then space is basically a twisted thread like path between A and B, More thread is created every time instant 't' than light can travel through it? And if some one figures out a way to walk from A to B in a straight line then they can walk faster than anything that can walk on the thread?
- danbruc 8y agoUnfortunately I don't understand what you are suggesting or asking. Maybe this short video [1] with the classical balloon analogy will help you understand it better. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mnENgtCdObo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mnENgtCdObo
- kamaal 8y agoFigure 1: _ _ |_|---------------|_| A B Figure 2: _ -----\____ _ |_|--/ \-|_| A B Let's say there is constant speed 'c' beyond which one can't travel. Lets say we travel at 'c'. Figure 1 is the fastest possible way of going from A to B If more space is added, and yet A and B remain at fixed positions, the only way this model will work is the path(possible way to go from A to B) gets looped/twisted and turned. In this case A and B remain at fixed positions but new space gets created. Its also possible in this model that as more and more loops get created fast enough, even by travelling at 'c' one can never arrive at B. If the space is not looped or twisted this how A and B will move apart at increasing time instances t1, t2, t3 t1: _ _ |_|--|_| A B t2: _ _ |_|---|_| A B t3: _ _ |_|----|_| A B t4: _ _ |_|-----|_| A B ... tn: _ |_|---------------- A As you can see when we keep the space expansion a straight line the objects always move. But if we have to keep the objects fixed we have to loop, twist and turn the path(space). If the objects were stationary, this is how it will look t1: _ _ |_|--------|_| A B t2: _ _ |_|---/\---|_| A B t3: _ _ |_|---/|\--|_| A B tn: _ --- B |_|---/ |--- A (many loops).. Is this understanding correct?