7 ms·
Edward Tufte's impression of Windows Phone 7
- code_duck 16y agoMicrosoft definitely has a soft spot for blockiness and overly large fonts. There were doing this with the Kin too - I agree that it is overstyled and not the greatest interface from close-up.
- sp332 16y agoYeah, but at least it's Frutiger. I'm not a hardcore type nerd, but I remember that because it was the first thing about WinPhone7 that made me believe I might like it. Microsoft has made some fairly nice fonts like Calibri, Consolas, Cambria etc. so the fact they went with a really good third-party font like Frutiger told me that "NIH", seemingly endemic to Microsoft product development, was not an issue. It was no guarantee, of course, but it was an indication that the team was making a product that was seriously designed instead of just checking off features.
- Slimy 16y agoFebruary 17, 2010? So he hasn't used the RTM build? He probably one saw screenshots and blurry videos. Next!
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- yatsyk 16y agoduplicate: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1161922 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1161922
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- spot 16y agoIf that's the lock screen, it leaks a lot of real information. Yikes.
- recoiledsnake 16y agoThat's the home screen. The lock screen looks like this http://www.tech4mommies.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/Lock-Screen-1.jpg http://www.tech4mommies.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/Lock-...
- spot 16y agosame problem.
- keithwarren 16y agoThe irony here is that Tufte goes on about bad interfaces etc yet his own web site is hopelessly locked in 1995.
- bisceglie 16y agoperhaps you confuse style with design?
- keithwarren 16y agoHis site definitely lacks style but I would argue the design is from that era as well. To be fair, I doubt he designed the look and feel of his site - and the truth is most great designers tend to have crappy sites because they are busy with real work and dont need to market themselves that heavily. I would guess he is probably in that boat, he doesnt really care about his web site because he has much more important things to do.
- kenjackson 16y agoThat's odd. Most great designers I've seen have pretty good sites. If not a bit gawdy, but certainly never this frumpy.
- slantyyz 16y agoYou have to remember that Tufte's area of specialty is in the area of visualizing quantitative information. He's not a designer (although he is a sculptor, apparently) or GUI guru even if he has opinions on them. Clearly a "dated" design isn't enough to stop you from visiting a site. Hacker News definitely has a dated feel too.
- Kliment 16y agoDoes it? I think it's the wave of the future. Or at least I hope it is. It's as close to pure content and zero chrome as I've seen anywhere. Tufte's site may look old, but it's fairly information-dense, and the comment system is the best I've seen anywhere.
- macrael 16y agoThis analysis seems spot on. Windows Phone Seven's low information density has troubled me from the first time I saw it. On a small screen like a phone, pixels should be precious. The fact that the contacts app uses a fifth of its screen telling me that I'm in the contacts app seems objectively wasteful.
- Avshalom 16y agoUnless Microsoft decided to approach it as a phone first and a tiny computer second, and from the homes screen being ~50% phone features I'm guessing they did. Information density on a phone can be extremely low.
- crux 16y agoEdward Tufte's impression of Windows Phone 7: 'Ooh, look at me! I'm Windows Phone 7! I think I'm so smart! Look at all my buttons! I'm Windows Phone 7! Typography! A bloo bloo bloo!' I'll take the karma hit; I couldn't resist.