3 ms·
Wow, that was not well researched. I suppose if they had titled it Google's Keystone problem it wouldn't have gotten as many clicks./cynicism Lets take the ar
by ChuckMcM 8y ago
Wow, that was not well researched.
I suppose if they had titled it Google's Keystone problem it wouldn't have gotten as many clicks./cynicism
Lets take the article though for what it purports to be, a review of Medium's first online book, which happens to be a piece of fiction that pilloried Google's culture because the author felt unheard at a company driven by engineering.
It isn't a surprise that voices go unheard in companies (large and small). If I had to guess, I would say the most common refrain I have heard from any employee who quit their job, it was "I tried to tell them what they were doing was wrong but nobody would listen, now look at where they are."
Does that point to any deep regional insights? No. Does it point out that people running companies are human and have blind spots? Well, yeah it does but that isn't exactly startling news.
My suggestion for folks reading the book and this comment are to take away one thing; "Learning how to communicate with the corporate hive mind is an excellent skill to cultivate." and the more practical corollary, "You can't tell someone anything they are unwilling to hear."
You just can't. Get over it. I have had the experience of telling the CEO of a startup that their blind spot was hiding a train coming at them, and that it would take down the company. They couldn't hear it, they rejected my analysis as fanciful and guesswork. And when the company was destroyed by that very train wreck? They were mad at me! Not the situation, not their inability to hear what they needed to hear. No the messenger was the problem, not the situation.
What I learned was that you can't tell someone something they don't want to hear, and if you force them to hear it and are correct, they can end up hating you for it. It is better to ask gently if they are open to alternate views and if they are not, just stop. Let them learn these lessons in their own way and be supportive of them once they fall down and are working their way back up.
There is a theme in "Bad Blood" where they start falsifying their test results because they believe that they are close to having things working and they just need a bit more time. I am sure more than one person said, "Wait, this isn't the right way to deal with this." But to hear that, you had to accept that maybe the whole test with only a drop of blood was not a practical idea. And to hear that, you had to consider the idea that the whole idea was not going to work. Net result, ignore the 'haters' and move on.
- Kalium 8y ago> It isn't a surprise that voices go unheard in companies (large and small). If I had to guess, I would say the most common refrain I have heard from any employee who quit their job, it was "I tried to tell them what they were doing was wrong but nobody would listen, now look at where they are." I'm always struck by how readily people equate "heard and understood" with "agreed with". It's very possible that a person can be heard, listened to, understood, and then the actions they want not be taken. Just because a person is heard is not the same as that person being agreed with. My advice for people is to take on board the difficult lesson that someone failing to do as you wish isn't the same as them refusing to listen to you. That your wishes or warnings are not acted upon is not the same as them falling on deaf ears.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI don't disagree, people contextualize the conversation with relation to themselves, but it is a bit more nuanced than that. This in particular is incomplete: It's very possible that a person can be heard, listened to, understood, and then the actions they want not be taken. Just because a person is heard is not the same as that person being agreed with. Is half the answer but the important bits it leaves unstated. To hear someone, you should be able to paraphrase their argument such that they agree that you're phrasing, is just as accurate as their original phrasing. And then you have to be able to share your decision process with respect to their argument so that they can see how you reached your choice of directions. If you do that, whether or not you choose make the change they suggest, they will feel heard by you. Conversely if you can't do that, they have no basis for believing you understood what they said and so they won't feel heard.
- Kalium 8y agoYou're right! The ability to understand, contextualize, and restate someone's point cogently and clearly back to them will leave them feeling they have been heard and understood. It's possible that my life experience might suggest that this sense of feeling listened to sometimes dissipates when it is not followed by the actions they would have you undertake. The ability to articulate why you have made this choice contrary to their wishes is, as you so correctly point out, critically important for having the other person understand. More completely, it can be very helpful in leaving another person feeling heard and understood when you choose not to do as they desire you to. It may be possible that not all people are so understanding as to accept that someone who heard and understood them might genuinely come to a different conclusion, even with a clear understanding of their points and lucid explanations of reasoning processes. It may also be worth considering how these techniques can, in some scenarios, interact with complex human systems. The techniques you wisely describe can be incredibly effective on a personal level! Yet, they perhaps can function less well when subject to an intermediating system. In such a scenario, some people might opt to interpret people choosing not to act as they suggest as a failure to hear and understand their points. In an organization, giving each individual the personal attention and explanation required to satisfy them and help them feel listened to can very easily become time-prohibitive. You're absolutely, completely, 100% right. It's just perhaps possible that there might be some further room for subtlety.