3 ms·
Isn't population growth also more concentrated in metros where pedestrian and cyclist infrastructure is much worse? Moving from New York to Seattle, the biking
by bobthepanda 8y ago
Isn't population growth also more concentrated in metros where pedestrian and cyclist infrastructure is much worse?
Moving from New York to Seattle, the biking infrastructure there is appalling.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoSeattle has a much higher bike mode share than NYC, IIRC around two and a half times higher.
- bobthepanda 8y agoThat's mostly a function of New York's extremely high transit usage. New York doesn't often split out walking from biking or taxis, but the mode share of biking + walking + other looks pretty similar. Manhattan - https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/planning/download/pdf/plans/transportation/peripheral_travel_02c.pdf https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/planning/download/pdf/plans/tran... Downtown Seattle - https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/transportation/transit-ridership-continues-to-grow-in-central-seattle-while-solo-car-commutes-decline/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/transportation/tra...
- toast0 8y agoWhich of your two cities are you claiming appalling bike infrastructure? I just moved to the Seattle area, and the bike infrastructure doesn't seem bad (my path includes Bainbridge Island and Colman Dock -> SLU). Bainbridge doesn't have great infrastructure on my path, but it has low traffic and bike aware drivers. Downtown has slow drivers, generally bike aware, and a pretty good amount of bike lanes, although some were thoughtfully put on the curb side of parking, which means unaware passengers get out without noticing me, and intersections mean I'm coming into the stream of traffic that might be turning right, but the parked cars make it hard for both of us to see each other. I didn't bike to work in the bay area, because my commute would have been on high traffic, high speed streets with frequent traffic lights and poor bike infra. I haven't experienced New York though -- maybe you're saying its bike infra is appalling?
- bobthepanda 8y agoNew York has many parking protected lanes, so even though the driving culture is much more aggressive, I find it doable. Seattle has a great trail system, which is wonderful until you're trying to get off the trail. East-west travel within Seattle is particularly appalling. There's a lot of painted bike lanes, which I don't feel very comfortable in, particularly in Seattle where the driving culture is passive-aggressive and unpredictable (as opposed to New York, where it's aggressive but pretty predictable, so avoiding negative consequences is pretty easy)
- toast0 8y agoParking protected lanes seem pretty bad if there are frequent intersections or driveways. It's pretty nice going upwards on Western Ave (by Pike's Place), because there's not much reason for cars to turn there, and it ends at an all-way stop sign that always requires caution. However, the other one I run into, on 9th ave going north between Harrison and Republican is really hard to navigate. On the one hand, people's dogs run into the street to urinate, on the other hand, I have to slow down every time I approach the intersection, because I have no visibility of the flow of traffic because of the parked cars; and the flow of traffic has no visibility of me because of the parked cars, so I can't even get upset at drivers who are ready to make a right turn there and don't give me space.
- bobthepanda 8y ago9th and Western aren't parking protected; parking is on the inside of the bike lane, between the curb and the bike lane. Parking protected lanes have parked cars between the roadway and the bike lane. https://www.stlouis-mo.gov/government/departments/mayor/news/images/Example-Parking-Protected-Bike-Lane.jpg https://www.stlouis-mo.gov/government/departments/mayor/news... Parking protected would be something like 2nd, where the parking is on the outside of the curb; similar configurations can be found on part of Broadway, and Dexter south of Mercer St.
- toast0 8y ago