52 ms·
“Silicon Valley is completely 100% liberal and that is a serious problem” is because most Liberal people genuinely believe they are the disruptive punk rockers
by gamblor956 8y ago
“Silicon Valley is completely 100% liberal and that is a serious problem” is because most Liberal people genuinely believe they are the disruptive punk rockers who are fighting against the evil forces of darkness. In reality, being Liberal is highly homogenous and unoriginal.
Silicon Valley definitely isn't 100% liberal. Not even close. The SF Bay Area is overwhelmingly liberal, true, but most male techies self-identify as libertarians, to the extent they choose to engage in politics, making the SV portion of the Bay Area comparatively conservative.
Moreover, you seem to be conflating multiple types of liberals into a single identity. Just as there are neocons, MRAs, white supremacists, and evangelicals on the conservative side, their are different types of liberals. You have treehuggers, bleeding hearts, socialists, progressives, pragmatists, BFL (business friendly liberals aka blue dogs), reformed Republicans, etc. Many of these groups (like the MRAs, neocons, white supremacists, and evangelicals on the conservative side) identify themselves by what they are fighting against. But the majority identify themselves by what they are for.
- mrfredward 8y agoWhile in the U.S. being libertarian is associated with being right-leaning, the small government vs big government debate is pretty orthogonal to left vs right. The silicon valley stance on economic matters doesn't fit cleanly into the usual liberal or conservative platforms. On social issues, it's more clear. Edit: I thought this was a fairly bland comment on my part, so can I ask what reasons people have for silently disagreeing?
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoOK, I'll not-silently disagree (though I didn't downvote you). The right can be either small- or big-government. (Cynically, the party of the "right", the Republicans, is big-government when in power and small-government when out of power.) But I see very little on the left that is small-government - certainly not the Democratic Party, and not much outside it. (I suppose at least some of the anarchists can be considered left, but as far as I can tell they are a very small group.)
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>but most male techies self-identify as libertarians, Aka "I'm a liberal but a highly visible minority of the people around me who call themselves liberals are extremists who have gone too far so I need to call myself something else to distance myself from them."
- olivermarks 8y agoAdding to @gamblor956 comments, the greater bay area - where I've lived for a quarter century - is still dominated by old money country club types with a separate highly transient population coming and going. The latest waves have been tech. The european concepts of 'liberal' and the US version (especially on the west coast which is completely different culturally to the east coast) causes endless confusion as like so many words in the English language mean different things on different continents and even places.