3 ms·
No 3G sim card support means instant fail. Seriously, this is a no-brainer feature.
by malandrew 16y ago
No 3G sim card support means instant fail. Seriously, this is a no-brainer feature.
- raganwald 16y agoWould you care to back your prognostication by short-selling AAPL?
- malandrew 16y agoNo. Just because I think this is fail doesn't mean I'm bearish on the stock. I'm as much of an Apple fanboy as anyone else (I use a MacBook Pro, Cinema Display, iPhone, etc. I've been using a MacBook Pro since 2003), but I'm not going to give them a free pass on a necessary feature in an ultra-portable laptop.
- zyb09 16y agoWell your fault for using an iPhone, just get a Froyo device and make your own WiFi around you!
- slantyyz 16y agoOr, your fault for being an American! You can tether your iPhone in other countries. Well, at least you can get a MyFi.
- mechanical_fish 16y agoYou can tether the iPhone in the USA as well. You just have to pay AT&T for the privilege. We'll see how expensive the tethering is after we have carrier-vs-carrier competition for the iPhone in the USA.
- thenduks 16y agoThey probably couldn't get carriers to agree to a iPad-like 3g plan for a laptop.
- malandrew 16y agoDo they even have to get carrier permission to include a sim card slot for GSM systems? The only reason I can see them leaving this out is because unsuspecting users will end up with a horrible user experience when they get their first month's bill at the end of the month. Apple would have to create a user interface to protect users from themselves by blocking a lot of unnecessary inbound and outbound network access when on 3G and also showing them how much of their monthly bandwidth they have used so far.
- thenduks 16y agoI'm with ya, and I don't think they'd need 'permission'... but usually Apple announces a deal to go along with stuff like that, you know, $15/month 3g plans on iPads. Basically what I'm saying is that the carriers will be super pissed if all the sudden all of their users are using all of their purchased bandwidth because they can shove a card into their laptop. It's like ketchup, the majority of people don't use all 500mb/1gb/whatever of data per month, but they still pay for it. The telecoms want to keep it that way.
- malandrew 16y agoTrue. True. However something tells me Steve doesn't care what the carriers think or feel. I know I don't care what they think. In fact, putting more stress on the digital networks may give the carriers in the U.S. the ammunition they need to get the FCC to let them abandon POTS. The truth is that money going to support legacy POTS is taking money away from digital network investment. The FCC should allow common carriers to abandon POTS on the condition that all that money get poured back into digital network bandwidth and rural network expansion.
- slantyyz 16y ago"I'm not going to give them a free pass on a necessary feature in an ultra-portable laptop." Everyone's use case is different. 3G is not even close to being what I would consider a "necessary" feature. I'm way more disappointed that there's no built-in gigabit ethernet, as I'm generally required to plug in when on-site at a client. The dongle helps, but dongles suck.
- malandrew 16y agoThe least they could do is treat the MacBook Air the same way they treat the iPad. They should offer two versions: one with 3G and one without.
- slantyyz 16y agoApple products tend to have a very opinionated design. They were probably of the opinion that the current market for 3G enabled MBA's was too small to justify adding space to the device's internals and having another SKU.
- raganwald 16y agoI'm with you on this one. If I had shorted AAPL because I thought that AppleTV wasn't going anywhere... That would have been an epic investment FAIL, to use your term :-D
- malandrew 16y agoWhy did this get downvoted? This is a machine meant for portability. Not everywhere has WiFi and when you take into account all the different wifi accounts (like boingo which is impossible to cancel), you end up paying a good portion of what could have been spent on 3G service. Also, not every country is like the US where wifi is ubiquitous.
- raganwald 16y agoI didn't downvote you, so I can only offer a guess. It could be that your particular wording came across a little abrasively, so some people may have felt that while the subject was interesting, the tone of the comment might discourage open discussion and instead lead towards heated and personal flame exchanges. Compare and contrast to: Odd that there's no 3G sim card support, this is a machine meant for portability and touted as what happens when a Macbook hooks up with an iPad... Which has 3G as an option.
- malandrew 16y agoThanks for the explanation.
- rimantas 16y agoDo other Apple notebooks have 3G? They are meant for portability too. It does have USB port. Get some 3G modem, problem solved (not being in US I just use my iPhone tethering with 1st gen Macbook Air for this).
- wmf 16y agoBuying a separate data plan for your laptop is a no-brainer? I've already paid for 3G data; I'm not paying again.
- malandrew 16y agoAs more and more devices come with 3G built-in, market forces would dictate that the supply side will change to meet this additional demand. One possibility is that more network will be built out so that people can have more than one 3G plan for the price of one 3G plan today.
- ghshephard 16y agoA) Use a USB 3G Dongle, or B) Use a MiFi over WiFi. The MiFi has the additional advantage of being able to network your iPod Touch, iPad, Kindle, and Laptop all at the same time.
- malandrew 16y agoPlugging in a USB 3G Dongle all the time or carrying around a MiFi kind of defeats the purpose of having a laptop as small and portable as the Macbook Air, doesn't it? For me, anything that is constantly plugged into the USB is an inconvenience. That's why Bluetooth was invented. USB and Firewire are good for the occasional connection.
- cwp 16y agoNah. Outside the US, you can tether a laptop to an iPhone. You might want an iPad to be the only device you have to carry, but with a laptop, it's not unreasonable to also carry a phone. Why duplicate the hardware and the dataplan? Even inside the US, there are other ways to connect to a cellular network. Sim card support might actually be a useful feature, but it's far from a no-brainer.
- malandrew 16y agoWith tethering you don't get "instant on" internet. You have to make sure your laptop is connected to the phone and that the phone is connected to the internet. The ideal solution is one where the laptop can connect to the internet as soon as you open the lid.
- semanticist 16y agoIf your battery (on both devices) can handle it, bluetooth 'tethering' (the term getting increasingly inaccurate) is a good compromise. On the iPhone, you can leave it turned on and it only activates when requested. Turning it on is as simple as selecting 'connect' from the bluetooth icon in the menu bar. You probably wouldn't want on-board 3G to connect automatically anyway (for cost reasons if nothing else), so it's not much more work. But the down side is that leaving bluetooth on will affect battery life on the phone and laptop. Everything's a compromise.