2 ms·
The article is correct that contact names were essentially the same as port numbers in TCP. This was a time of great experimentation in LAN protocols (and netw
by gumby 8y ago
The article is correct that contact names were essentially the same as port numbers in TCP. This was a time of great experimentation in LAN protocols (and network protocols, what we would now call layers 1-4 or maybe -5). By the mid 70s most used thicknet (later called 10base5) coax using CSMA with exponential backoff (Metcalf's greatest invention at PARC IMHO), so chaosnet was a local example (of several in New England alone, at the time). There wasn't really anything off the shelf at the time.
CHAOSNET and lispms are historically intertwined it's true, but hardly inextricably so. For example the file servers referred to in the article weren't (until much later) lispms too, but our standard PDP-10 mainframes, so there were multiple implementations of chaosnet immediately, and it was also used for mainframe-mainframe communication (yes, you could transparently use remotely stored files back in the late 1970s). The earliest machines sold by Symbolics and LMI were just MIT CADRs build externally and badged by the manufacturer, by the time they built their own machines the Ethernet standard (also using 10base5) was starting to get traction and their machines used that instead. I did deploy and use a chaosnet system at the Centre Mondial in Paris because they had a KL-20 and some CADRs, but that was a rare case; possibly the only one outside USA, or possibly even outside the east coast of the USA.
Article is correct about the deep ties between BBN and MIT-AI. Honestly at the time of the ARPANET switching to TCP I really thought of the other address types as transitional anyway, so I'm not surprised more address types were never used. Though the whole point of the idea of an Internet was the union of all other networks (and the origin of the idea of the "cloud" -- a radical idea at the time, though focused on routing) the early model was either protocol-translating gateways or TCP.
When the net switched over from NCP to TCP it didn't really feel like it affected me until 1984 when I could telnet directly from my machine at PARC (a Dolphin or Dorado -- they were also in a machine room with the display and kbd on my desk!) to my machines at the MIT AI lab. It seemed magical not to have to log into an intermediate machine. This was thanks to a pup gateway (pup was PARC's equivalent to chaosnet, or perhaps I should say that the other way as pup was first) and sadly I eventually realized that it wasn't using a chaosnet gateway on the MIT side (the PDP-10s had their own IMPs). But by the time I moved back to MIT this worked in the other direction as well.