6 ms·
> they'll get to look progressive for adopting this wage early, while mitigating their competitive disadvantage by forcing every other company to raise their wa
by ajross 8y ago
> they'll get to look progressive for adopting this wage early, while mitigating their competitive disadvantage by forcing every other company to raise their wages too eventually.
That's deeply cynical. In the process, they're actually paying real people more money. Which is sort of critically important if you care about this issue and not just taking pot shots at Amazon on HN.
- bostonscott 8y agoExactly what Amazon did on "sales tax." Against it, until their growth created a nexus in most states and required it. Now they have been one of the most forceful lobbyists advocating for it. They call it, "Main Street Fairness."
- mikeq101101 8y agoHe's right though. It's a great thing they voluntarily decided to pay their workers more. Forcing others to do so by the state's monopoly on force is immoral.
- Ericson2314 8y agoIf you critically care about this issue, the extent of which this is labor-driven vs PR-driven is crucial to the war in which $15/hour is just the first battle.
- austenallred 8y agoWhat do you mean by “labor-driven?”
- jonwachob91 8y agoI'm assuming it relates to the tight labor market giving workers the power to choose where they work at (as opposed to "this is the only job offer I have")
- prolikewh0a 8y ago>I'm assuming it relates to the tight labor market giving workers the power to choose where they work at (as opposed to "this is the only job offer I have") Lol no it's still not like that unless you have a high salary career, and most people don't have those.
- whatshisface 8y agoIf this is to be interpreted as evidence that the workers have bargaining power, it is only the first step in a progression of improving conditions (because now they're able to negotiate.) If it's just PR-driven serendipity then it might even be accompanied by worsening conditions elsewhere. This seems reasonable because people are a lot more reliable at fighting for their own interests than they are at considering the interests of others.
- cptskippy 8y agoIn the absence of a monopoly, those drivers are codependent.
- mbesto 8y ago> In the process, they're actually paying real people more money Except the OP was talking specifically about the company's plan to lobby. Yes, they're actually paying people more money, but if everyone has that same amount of money then you get wage push inflation. Then everyone loses. This is also why minimum wage discussions always spiral out of control...there really is no good long term solution for setting minimum wages.
- Siecje 8y agoUnless you are Amazon and people get more spending money. Yes everything else will go up with minimum wage but not right away.
- fhood 8y agoThis isn't necessarily the case, as shown by countries like Australia with very high minimum wages.
- virmundi 8y agoAustralia has a very high cost of living. Look at the cost of power.
- miemo 8y agothe cost of power is a political mismanagement unrelated to our minimum wage
- xori 8y agoFor context the Australian minimum wage is 12.94 USD and has the 12th highest cost of living in the world.
- tbarker25 8y agoThe minimum wage in Australia doesn't work the same way as it does in the US. Australian workers will under an award -- effectively a industry-specific contract negotiated by the respective union. An Amazon worker would likely be on the Storage Services and Wholesale Award. This starts at $20.72 (14.92 USD) for fulltime, and $25.90 (18.64 USD) for casual work. There's higher wages based on experience and responsibilities, as well as penalty rates. Public holiday pay starts at $56.98 (41.01 USD). As someone who has recently moved from Melbourne to Boston; if anything I feel like Australia has a lower cost of living. According to the one source I found, prices including rent in Boston, MA are 36.53% higher than in Melbourne https://www.fairwork.gov.au/ArticleDocuments/872/storage-services-and-wholesale-award-ma000084-pay-guide.pdf.aspx https://www.fairwork.gov.au/ArticleDocuments/872/storage-ser... https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?country1=Australia&country2=United+States&city1=Melbourne&city2=Boston%2C+MA https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?cou...
- samirillian 8y agoCynical isn't the right word for the problem in swebs reasoning. Of course Bezos is a villain. But if you get Amazon to do this, it's good for the country, regardless of motivation. So remain cynical but recognize that good politics can lead to bad companies doing good things.
- gowld 8y agoIf Bezos is a villain, his millions of customers are accomplices. Have you tipped your Amazon warehouse worker recently?
- samirillian 8y agoDon't think that's how villainy, accomplices, or tips work.
- cptskippy 8y agoI'm reluctant to say it's cynical because it's not necessarily negative or pessimistic so much as matter of fact. The Op isn't taking shots at Amazon by exposing their motivations. A higher Minimum Wage is coming and possibly be a priority for Liberals and Progressives after the November Election. Amazon has been receiving a lot of negative press recently for labor conditions and wages. Regardless of the benefits to others, there is a direct benefit to Amazon. Now if you want cynical... I think it's borderline delusional to think that a publicly traded multi-national corporation would do anything that isn't in it's business interest.
- eli_gottlieb 8y agoHot take: if you really want to take shots at Amazon, the best thing here is that their wage rates are going up, draining money from the General Bezos Evilness Pot and towards the employees, who can use it for things like unionization campaigns or pro-worker lobbying. If Amazon literally wants to spend its own money advocating for a shift of power from capital to labor via a minimum-wage rise or other improvements in workers' rights, well, I'm happy to see Jeff Bezos selling us the rope we'll hang him with.