7 ms·
But whoever made that decision, it was on the hardware side, not anyone at Microsoft. Bill Gates' famous comment isn't really a decision though. As it's usuall
by onion2k 8y ago
But whoever made that decision, it was on the hardware side, not anyone at Microsoft.
Bill Gates' famous comment isn't really a decision though. As it's usually cited it's just an opinion - '640Kb should be enough for anyone' means "I don't think any programs will need more than that!". If someone at IBM decided that there should be 640Kb of available RAM for programs it's believable that Bill might have simply been agreeing with them.
The main thing that's annoying about the quote is that it's trotted out as an example of how Bill was wrong, as if being wrong is something terrible that he should be ashamed of decades later. That's nonsense. Being wrong is fine so long as you change your mind when you understand that you are wrong.
- close04 8y agoTo follow up on that: as if stating anything that’s perfectly acceptable today but not years from now is somehow outrageous. “8 core CPUs or 32GB of RAM are more than enough for gaming” (c) 2018 Facts change and opinions change with them. Wonder if Moore’s law will get the same treatment now.
- logicchains 8y agoMaybe that's why Google Chrome was created, to prevent anyone ever again suggesting that any particular amount of RAM should be enough.
- 13of40 8y agoAt one of the Microsoft company meetings in the middle to late 2000s (I recall it was at Safeco Field) he claimed that when IBM was developing the PC he tried to convince them to use an MC68000 instead of the 8088. He said going with the 8088 set the industry back ten years. Assuming he wasn't making the story up, it's hard to imagine him making that quote or even agreeing with it.
- ghaff 8y agoHere's the thing though. Engineering workstations existed. There's a good argument that the "right" approach was to use an MC68K and, while you were at it, a "real" operating system whether a Unix or one of the 16-bit operating systems in use on minicomputers at the time. But there's also a good argument that, had you done a more open and mass market-oriented engineering workstation (whatever that meant exactly) at, what?, 2x the price point of an IBM PC--which, remember, didn't even always have a hard disk at the time--you'd not have been competitive with Z80 or 6502 machines. Even using the 8088 vs. the 8086 was a cost-saving move. A premium IBM PC might well have simply flopped rather than accelerating the industry.
- cmrdporcupine 8y agoIt's not clear to me that at the time the m68k was that much more expensive than x86. It certainly was not by 84/85 when the Atari ST was shipping as a sub-$1000 cheap home computer based around it. I think the bigger compelling piece for x86 was its continuity with the top-selling 8080/Z80 CP/M machines that were the effective standard at the time. IBM offered both PC-DOS (cheap) and CP/M (expensive), and wasn't sure which was going to win out. And PC-DOS was basically a kind of clone of CP/M, down to the API call names.
- 13of40 8y agoThis could be apocryphal (there was free beer at the company meeting), but I think I recall he (Gates) mentioned at the time that the existence of a solid chipset to support the 8088 was something that drove the ultimate decision.
- smacktoward 8y agoThere was also the fact that the IBM people working on the original PC had already established familiarity with Intel's architecture through their work on an earlier IBM product, the Datamaster (http://www.oldcomputers.net/ibm5322.html http://www.oldcomputers.net/ibm5322.html), which used the 8-bit Intel 8085. David J. Bradley (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Bradley_(engineer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Bradley_(engineer)) worked on both the Datamaster and the PC projects, and explained the reasoning behind the choice of the 8088 for the latter in an article in the September 1990 issue of Byte (https://archive.org/stream/byte-magazine-1990-09/1990_09_BYTE_15-09_15th_Anniversary_Summit#page/n451/mode/2up https://archive.org/stream/byte-magazine-1990-09/1990_09_BYT...): There were a number of reasons why we chose the Intel 8088 as the IBM PC's central processor. 1. The 64K-byte address limit had to be overcome. This requirement meant that we had to use a 16-bit microprocessor. 2. The processor and its peripherals had to be available immediately. There was no time for new LSI chip development, and manufacturing lead times meant that quantities had to be available right away. 3. We couldn't afford a long learning period; we had to use technology we were familiar with. And we needed a rich set of support chips -- we wanted a system with a DMA controller, an interrupt controller, timers, and parallel ports. 4. There had to be both an operating system and applications software available for the processor. Points 1 and 3 both reference lessons learned from the Datamaster project -- #1 is about the desire for the PC to overcome a limitation the Datamaster's 8-bit CPU had imposed on it, and #3 refers to the fact that the 8086 and 8088 were close cousins of the 8085, so the IBMers wouldn't have to learn a whole new architecture from scratch. It's not hard to imagine the decision coming down to Bradley (or someone else on the Entry Systems Division team) calling someone they knew at Intel and saying "we need a 16-bit processor as similar to the 8085 as possible that you can deliver in volume tomorrow. Whatcha got?"
- dep_b 8y ago> He said going with the 8088 set the industry back ten years. That's what it always felt like as an Amiga user. Not before DOOM there was much I liked on the PC. Release Amiga 1000: July '85 Release DOOM: December '94
- th0ma5 8y agoI saw an Amiga once in person around 86 and spent that next decade disappointed, but advocating that the future of computing was going to be great. Emotionally I still feel like we haven't caught up to the Amiga but I imagine that isn't really true, heh.
- forinti 8y agoI must have been 12 or 13 years old when I first met an IBM PC. I was used to 8 bit micros having BASIC right away (and colour). But you couldn't do anything with a PC before using two floppies. First DOS then whatever. It just seemed awful. Why would anyone want one of those?
- nsxwolf 8y agoI was used to all the 8 bit machines and their graphics and sound too, but I was enthralled by 80 column BASIC and DOS with its hierarchal file system as well. I saw it as a separate branch of computing entirely. And once EGA came out, it quickly started to surpass the 8 bits as a gaming platform too.
- Narishma 8y agoThat's not correct. If you don't have a floppy disk, the PC boots into ROM BASIC just like the 8-bit home computers of the time.
- 13of40 8y agoSimilar story with me. I got an Amiga 1000 and did a fair bit of assembly coding on it, then ended up writing some 16-bit x86 assembly for school later on. Being used to having sixteen 32-bit registers, then all the sudden having to use AX, BX, CX, and DX (and don't forget they all have slightly different purposes!) was like being brutally shoved back into the 80's.
- jecel 8y agoNote that IBM introduced a 68000 machine just over a month before the PC came out, which caused some confusion at that time. http://www.old-computers.com/museum/computer.asp?st=1&c=623 http://www.old-computers.com/museum/computer.asp?st=1&c=623 But 1981 was just too early for 68000 non workstation machines since the early chips were slow and expensive. The 1983 Lisa was limited to 4MHz, for example, in contrast to the 1984 Macintosh's 8MHz. I remember the price of the chips dropping from over $100 to less than $20 in just one year back then.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoThis I can believe. It's reasonably well known that the first PC design was deliberately crippled in order not to impact on sales of the dedicated word processor, the IBM Displaywriter. The 8086 was thought too powerful and would compete against existing IBM products, so the 8088 was chosen. Other changes to expansion and bus architecture were on the same basis. I spent over a decade completely failing to understand how it could succeed against Amiga.
- SilasX 8y agoI'm not even sure he was as wrong as people claim. They used to do a lot with very limited memory. Now, modern computers "need" hundreds of megabytes for a chat application, and slow down for the latest Gmail revamp. The quote serves as a reminder of how well we used to economize on memory.
- Brockenstein 8y ago>If someone at IBM decided that there should be 640Kb of available RAM for programs it's believable that Bill might have simply been agreeing with them. Yeah, "640k should be enough for anybody (specifically in the context of a conversation about current hardware of software and not necessarily in perpetuity)"
- forinti 8y agoIt wasn't even wrong. There wasn't a need for that much memory on a desktop then. You could already do wonders with 64KB on an 8bit micro: edit text, run spreadsheets, play games. You would need more for multimedia or web surfing, but that was still in the future.
- Klathmon 8y agoExactly! It's like saying today that 64gb of ram should be enough for just about everyone in their personal machine. In 10 years, that might be a hilariously small number, but for right now, it's way more than the extreme vast majority will need.
- lisper 8y agoThere is a limit though. By the time you get to the point where you can store more high-definition movies than you can possibly watch in a lifetime you have definitely passed the point of diminishing returns. And with non-volatile storage, we're pretty much already there.
- Klathmon 8y agoUntil a new format comes out which requires magnitudes more storage? I can already imagine vr-style videos pushing 8k with huge dynamic range and very high framerates becoming more common if the technology continues to go that direction, and suddenly a full video export in the highest quality becomes a magnitude (or 2!) jump larger. As videogames become higher resolutions, they require higher res textures, and less compressed audio, and more detailed models. Not just like 50% more detailed, but 10x more detailed. Sure, we are beyond the point now where it's pretty easy for the average person to store all information they ever could need on spinning disks for pretty cheap, but once that next "thing" comes out that requires a magnitude more, we are right back to looking silly for thinking 5tb should be enough for anyone!
- lisper 8y ago> Until a new format comes out which requires magnitudes more storage? No, even that has a limit. We're getting to the point where humans will be unable to perceive additional improvements in resolution. It's no different from audio. CDs are unchanged from when they were introduced 36 years ago because humans cannot hear the difference between a CD and "higher-qualitY" audio. There is a point where that will happen for video: when you can fill the entire field of view of the human eye with video the same resolution as your fovea at ~100FPS, that's it. There is no more room for improvement.
- CyberDildonics 8y agoNo, the point of the 'quote' is people trying to make a point that 'even Bill Gates' can't predict the future need for technology requirements expanding. Of course that's wrong, and most of the time it is used by people who don't understand the trade offs made in incremental advancements in tech standards.
- joering2 8y agoHe didnt understand he was wrong. He never learnt a lesson. Years later when Microsoft was launching their Zume audio player, he played a fool on the scene with bunch of people acting that he never heard if iPod.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ma2rten 8y agoI don't think the point is that Bill Gates should be ashamed. It's a reminder how fast technology changes and that the assumptions we make today could be invalidated just as quickly.