3 ms·
Not unusual for business people or anyone to have varied income from year to year but also that does not relate to actual assets or (the original point 'net wor
by dagw 8y ago
Not unusual for business people or anyone to have varied income from year to year but also that does not relate to actual assets or (the original point 'net worth' which is ironically a better measure of what you can pay (assumes liquid of course..)) Also what about someone with an inheritance or trust money?
The tax people already have methods for dealing with all those scenarios for tax purposes, so it's essentially a solved problem.
Once again with the speeding fine it seems oppressive for the same 'crime' to charge someone $100k because they have income or assets and have that money to pay.
At least the way it works in Sweden, many fines are defined essentially in days wages and not in money. So the judge doesn't sentence you to pay $100k, they sentence you to pay 45 days wages[0] and the judge neither knows nor cares what that works out to be in actual money. So as such the fines are exactly the same for everybody.
[0] The actual formula is slightly more complicated that literally your daily wage.
- gist 8y ago> the way it works in Sweden, many fines are defined essentially in days wages and not in money. So the judge doesn't sentence you to pay $100k, they sentence you to pay 45 days wages So explain how that makes sense because it doesn't take into account the savings of the individual? If I have a million in savings and I am retired or how do you determine 'wages' with a self employed person? I am not saying there aren't ways to answer or address this. But it is not simple and not fair the way stated other than a revenue scheme for the government. If the idea is to create a disincentive that has not been done using daily wages. (Some people live hand to mouth as well so they are particularly impacted)