3 ms·
That's an interesting opinion, stated like a fact. :-) I have three responses to that: 1. The opinion is certainly a radical one, i.e. at odds with almost ever
by svat 8y ago
That's an interesting opinion, stated like a fact. :-) I have three responses to that:
1. The opinion is certainly a radical one, i.e. at odds with almost every typographer. Walk into a library and pick up a random book or magazine (by a good publisher), and you'll almost surely find justified paragraphs. It's only some self-published books or typewriter / computer printouts that tend not to justify. It is an interesting exercise to try to find a physical book (that you have access to) that contains non-justified paragraphs — I looked at 65 books at home (that have paragraphs) and all of them (across multiple languages) use justification. (In the poetry books I had to look at the preface...)
I checked previews online of some books by typographers and font designers, and (of course) they also contain justified paragraphs: Robert Bringhurst's The Elements of Typographic Style, etc. I am aware of Eric Gill's An Essay on Typography that is not, and contains a section called ”The Procrustean Bed”, and that's about it.
2. The problem being solved, for which the algorithms are being compared, is how to generate justified paragraphs. The top-level comment (by pgtan@) that started this thread, was also about justified paragraphs (that's what I was pointing out in the comment you replied to). As an analogy, when discussing algorithms for the traveling salesman problem, one can reject the problem by declaring that sales must be done online, which... seems somewhat a change of topic.
3. Even if what you want is non-justified (ragged-right) paragraphs, you still need to choose line breaks. The choice is not always unique. The Knuth–Plass algorithm covers this case too (with the right choice of penalties and glue), and has something to offer here too. It's in the paper :-) http://eprg.org/G53DOC/pdfs/knuth-plass-breaking.pdf http://eprg.org/G53DOC/pdfs/knuth-plass-breaking.pdf (Search for "ragged")