9 ms·
Miller Columns
- OskarS 8y agoI never use this view in Finder. I get the idea, to show multiple levels of the hierarchy at once, but I always liked the "collapsable list" view more. The horizontal space is better used as a table for further file attributes (filesize, last modified, etc.).
- bni 8y agoI agree completely, this is the "oh shit I clicked the wrong button" -view in finder. Its even worse in save dialogs. Sometimes using this abomination is the only way to go "up" in the filesystem.
- moftz 8y agoIt only really makes sense for trees that have low depth.
- OskarS 8y agoSometimes using this abomination is the only way to go "up" in the filesystem. Yes! So annoying that finder doesn't just have button for "go up in hierarchy" at least somewhere on every screen (whether it's regular Finder or a save/open dialog). It's totally baffling to me. We can find room for the "Tag file" feature nobody uses, but a "go up in hierarchy" button is apparently too much to ask for.
- jayrhynas 8y agoI know that some people still prefer a button, but cmd-up on your keyboard will go up a level in both Finder and in file dialogs.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoThanks, I've only been using macs for ten years or so and never knew :-). Discoverability of features is a thing. Having something that is hard to discover is almost the same as not having the feature at all.
- jacobush 8y agoTook me a loooong time to realize Visual Studio can pop out source windows, so I can put them on another screen, for instance.
- mthoms 8y agoWait... how?
- genocidicbunny 8y agoIf you have 2012 or newer, just grab the item tab and pull it to another screen.[1] You can also rearrange the tabs within a window to have for example, several files open side by side. [1] https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/visualstudio/ide/customizing-window-layouts-in-visual-studio?view=vs-2017#arrange-and-dock-windows https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/visualstudio/ide/customizin...
- konamicode 8y agoMy default VS layout is to have two full screens: editor on the left screen where I often have a source file and its tests open side by side and on the right screen - the source tree, the test runner, the output window, team explorer etc.
- jacobolus 8y agoThere is a menu option Go → Enclosing Folder, which clearly lists the keyboard shortcut. In general, responsibly designed Mac programs should have a menu option for every available command. This is highly discoverable (assuming users know to look in the menus, and the menus aren’t so long or deeply nested that the commands are buried). Unfortunately in an era of web apps, mobile devices, hacky cross-platform software, etc., fewer and fewer users properly learn the basic Mac platform UI conventions. This particular convention (commands available as menu options with keyboard shortcuts listed next to them) has been largely unchanged for >30 years. I’m not sure about the precise origin of the shortcut for opening the enclosing folder, but it dates from at least the beginning of OS X. One Finder shortcut which is less discoverable which you might also find useful is ⌘↓ (command-down) for opening a selected item.
- smoser 8y agoThe SO Apple site has some suggestions. Sadly some of the 'app buttons' are outdated. I'm interested making an updated one and throwing it on the App Store. https://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/25813/add-an-up-button-to-the-lion-finder https://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/25813/add-an-up-bu...
- ghostly_s 8y agoThere's a dropdown menu at the top-center of every file browser dialog that lets you jump to any parent level in the hierarchy, no?
- dreamcompiler 8y agoYes, but you have to cmd-click or right-click it.
- ghostly_s 8y agoNo? You seem to be talking about title bar behavior. There is a normal dropdown menu right in the top center of the standard 'Save' and 'Open' dialogs.
- dougmwne 8y agoThis was my selected finder view for many years and I found it visually busy, cramped, and kept way too much information on the screen than I needed.
- mhd 8y agoI've had a few co-workers who preferred this view. And without exception, they came from a Windows background, preferring some kind of indication where in the file system they are. Like the old Explorer tree or at least the breadcrumb view of its sad contemporary version. (Sometimes showing them them "path bar" helps, but not always.)
- BillinghamJ 8y agoInteresting. I haven't used Windows for about a decade and I switched to exclusively using this view in the last couple of years. I just find it much quicker to use with my keyboard etc as I don't want to be using my trackpad to navigate.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI could imagine you could have the best of both worlds: +-+-----+-------------------------+ | | | | | | | | | | | | |A| B | C | | | | | | | | | | | | | +-+-----+-------------------------+ Where B is the previous level of the tree, C is the detailed table view of the current level, and A is a compressed representation of all the previous levels (you could e.g. click on it to replace B with B's parent, and C would get replaced with details of B). Did anyone try something like this out?
- s_kilk 8y agoIIRC, Spotify used to do something like this, at least in the desktop app?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- XaspR8d 8y agoNot OP, but this is basically the same dream layout I've sketched for myself! Unfortunately it would give me the most day-to-day benefit on OSX, which is probably the place I'm least likely to see it implemented...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- juki 8y agoThat seems a bit similar to the Ranger[1] given as an example in the article. There's also ranger.el[2] for Emacs. By default in ranger.el (and I assume Ranger too, but I haven't used it), B is the current level, A is the previous level and C is a preview of whatever you have selected in B. You can hide the preview (so the current level would be C) and add more previous levels. There's no compressed view of all previous levels though. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ranger_(file_manager) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ranger_(file_manager) [2]: https://github.com/ralesi/ranger.el https://github.com/ralesi/ranger.el
- smrtinsert 8y agoFinder is just awful. Macs are only good for their screens and the cli.
- gilrain 8y agoThe movement of most music players, led by iTunes, away from Miller columns as the default navigation paradigm has sucked for me. For me, nothing works as well as three Miller columns: Genre, Artist, Album.
- peterburkimsher 8y agoI'd like to rewrite a cross-platform, mobile-friendly version of iTunes 10, as a side project. Right now I'm unemployed. Please contact me if you'd be interested in emailing me once a week to remind me to make progress on it.
- sephware 8y agoWhat language / framework / technology stack would you use to make this?
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoAgreed. Losing that and coverflow leaves iTunes with just the annoyances. MusicBee on Windows works better than most everything else, and keeps the three column view as one of the many options. Haven't found anything I can live with on the Mac yet. Never saw the point in Finder windows though, preferring the default, or two linked folders in one OS window like DirectoryOpus (Amiga and eventually Windows) and most ftp clients used to do it. That's better when needing source/dest, or diffing two folders etc.
- coldacid 8y agoOneCommander makes for a nice combination of Miller columns and [orthodox file management](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File_manager#Orthodox_file_managers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File_manager#Orthodox_file_man...) (the two side-by-side directories, i.e. what DOpus uses as its layout). Quite a few GUI (S)FTP clients still use the orthodox layout as well.
- tzs 8y agoIt's still there. Click "Songs" under Library in the sidebar. That causes a "Column Browser" menu to appear in the "View" menu. Select "Show Column Browser" from that. It's a toggle. That menu also lets you choose which columns to enable. The choices are Genres, Artists, Albums, Composers, and Groupings.
- ideonexus 8y agoCould anyone recommend an open-source software for cataloging generic objects that allows setting up these columns of categorization dynamically? I've been looking for such a software, preferably web-based, that could be used to catalog and categorize anything with some configuration. Edit: Not just for file-browsing, but for adding any kind of list.
- azeirah 8y agoThe only thing that comes to mind is Nelson's ZigZag, but to call it practical and usable in its current state (gzz), is already a stretch. http://xanadu.com/zigzag/ http://xanadu.com/zigzag/ Look for gzz It's a super interesting structure, but I don't believe there is a friendly version of it out there somewhere.
- themodelplumber 8y agoYou reminded me of the file manager Ranger, which is indeed for file browsing, though files and folders are also one possible model/paradigm for cataloging and categorizing just about anything. (In fact in many ways, computers and especially unices reward you for cataloging information using this paradigm) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ranger_(file_manager) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ranger_(file_manager)
- marliechiller 8y agocame here looking for ranger and wasn't disappointed. i love it!
- severine 8y agohttps://www.tagspaces.org/ https://www.tagspaces.org/
- Sir_Cmpwn 8y agoYou could model your data as a filesystem with FUSE and then use any file browser.
- gnomewascool 8y ago
- pavel_lishin 8y agoI could have sworn Norton Commander used a similar layout, but it looks like it just had columns, as well as a left-right split for viewing two directories at once. (One of my earlier memories is my grandmother teaching me how to launch a game on their computer; I can still remember her saying "н ц".)
- k__ 8y agoAFAIK nc had multiple layouts
- Boulth 8y agoWhat game was it?
- pavel_lishin 8y agoTetris, I believe; I'm not sure which version. This would have been late 80s or early 90s.
- ronjouch 8y agoThanks. Didn't know this UX came from Smalltalk, I always assumed it was kinda-exclusive to macOS' Finder/iTunes and heavily patented by Apple.
- mprovost 8y agoThe live demo of Smalltalk-78 that was posted here a while ago shows it off quite nicely. https://lively-web.org/users/bert/Smalltalk-78.html https://lively-web.org/users/bert/Smalltalk-78.html
- etatoby 8y agoI fumbled and clicked around for a while, but I still don't have the slightest idea of what I'm looking at and how to use it. Except for the obvious "an ancient operating system emulated in Javascript."
- ghostly_s 8y agoClick-and-hold the right mouse button on the desktop, and select 'Open a Browser' from the lovely ornate dropdown menu. You'll see a miller column browser at the top of the window.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dkersten 8y agoI came across it the other day in a vid o form 1990 about Lotus Inprov rubbing on NextSTEP. The Wikipedia page mentions it was used by Next, but I also find it interesting that I saw it there just a few days ago :)
- sorokod 8y agoLooks like the layout used by Ranger ( https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ranger_(file_manager) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ranger_(file_manager) )
- smrtinsert 8y agoI love these. I've always thought a textual filter at the top of each column would solve the scrolling issue.
- raindropm 8y agoI love it so much. The only Finder's feature(well, aside from label) I miss when using Windows Explorer. I can fly through my folder hierarchy quickly with just directional keys, with crystal clear picture of where/how deep I am in the directory. Windows have an alternative File manager with Miller Columns called OneCommander, though it is quite sluggish compared to Finder.
- infogulch 8y agoAlt+Up in Windows Explorer navigates to the parent directory. And Alt+L/R does browser-style forward/back. These combined with typing the file name to select it makes it pretty easy for me to navigate. One nit I do have is that when you first go into a directory the selection is a bit funky; nothing is selected by default so enter doesn't do anything, but if you press Down it selects the second item, so if you need to go to the first item (pretty common in practice) you have to do this awkward down-up-enter to get there. Edit: Reading comprehension is hard.
- Birch-san 8y agoTry pressing Space instead of Down.
- theandrewbailey 8y agoNeat! Thanks for the tip. This might be as useful as when I (accidentally) discovered that Ctrl+W closes Explorer windows. It even works on Windows 98!
- Birch-san 8y agoOther shortcuts that changed the way I use Windows: Alt+Space (open window management context menu) Shift+F10 (right-click using the keyword) Ctrl+Shift+Escape (launch task manager) Windows+E (open Explorer window) Windows+X (open context menu of random useful things) Ctrl+L (select address bar) Home (go to start of line of text) End (go to end of line of text) Ctrl+{direction} (move by one word) Windows+{number} (focus a process from your taskbar) And some useful things in the Run menu (Windows+R): sysdm.cpl (System Properties) inetcpl.cpl (Internet Properties) %APPDATA% (goes to C:\Users\%USERNAME%\AppData\Roaming)
- ageofwant 8y agoRanger does this very well. https://github.com/ranger/ranger https://github.com/ranger/ranger. Perhaps midnight commander (mc) has a similar mode.
- ghostly_s 8y agoYep, love ranger. And if you use the right terminal emulator, there's a flag that will enable honest-to-god image previews in your console!
- dpwm 8y agoI remember using these somewhere, perhaps a music player, and how amazing they were. It's interesting to note that Thunar (XFCE file manager) and Dolphin (KDE manager) have removed Miller columns, in KDE's case because the column view had "been used by only very few people but was tricky and time consuming to maintain." [0] A slight side note, I've been a fan of Mark S. Miller's work for a while now and I never knew these were named after him. Mark S. Miller's other contributions, particularly his work on popularizing capability-based security[1] and the E programming language[2] are well worth looking into if you're interested in how easy secure, race-condition-free, distributed computing could be made. [0] http://ppenz.blogspot.com/2012/01/dolphin-20-status-update.html?showComment=1325669619833#c91135672311802014 http://ppenz.blogspot.com/2012/01/dolphin-20-status-update.h... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capability-based_security https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capability-based_security [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E_(programming_language) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E_(programming_language)
- ryanjshaw 8y agoCame here to say much the same. I spent much of my youth reading reading ERights.org [0] and related capabilities-based security sites (Hardy, Shapiro, etc.). Weird how it seems nothing ever came of it (or am I wrong?). [0] http://www.erights.org http://www.erights.org
- pcwalton 8y agoMark ended up designing several things in JS (like WeakMaps), influenced by his work on Caja (object capabilities for JS). I ran into him a couple of times while he was doing standards work with Dave Herman. I would be surprised if he was not involved with Fuchsia. Fuchsia has object capabilities written all over it.
- 3rdAccount 8y agoCan you explain the Fuschia part in more detail?
- elvinyung 8y ago
- dkersten 8y agoI personally never liked these. I’m not sure why, but I find them awkward and clunky for some reason.
- zymhan 8y agoI find it amazing that there are no Linux GUI file browsers listed that support the column view still.
- farss 8y agoThis drives me nuts. Why is it so difficult to maintain?
- anotherevan 8y agoAgreed. I just commented that I remembered seeing Miller columns once, years and years ago on someone's Mac's Finder and really liked the idea. Now I'm really annoyed to read that Dolphin had it but dropped it.
- stevedekorte 8y agoEvery smart phone uses this interface but presents it one column at a time. It's a powerful and beautiful design.
- dfox 8y agoI think that for this layout to be truly useful the underlying tree has to have particular structure (not too deep an very wide), things like music library or Smalltalk Browser matches this well (mostly because the depth is inherently fixed), while arbitrary tree structures (think Unix filesystem) does not. Another case where this kind of view is very useful is when the user only has vague idea where in the immense hiarachy the thing that she searches for actually is (think online component catalog, with Farnell's eshop having quite similar but by default hidden navigation tool)
- vansteen 8y agoYou either hate it or love it. (personally, my default view in OSX Finder)
- anotherevan 8y agoI remember I saw this once, years and years ago on someone's Mac's Finder and really liked the idea. Now I'm really annoyed to read that Dolphin had it but dropped it.