4 ms·
> It is true that housing prices in urban areas have risen astronomically in many regions of the world, and while we may well see a correction, I wonder if thes
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> It is true that housing prices in urban areas have risen astronomically in many regions of the world, and while we may well see a correction, I wonder if these these areas have simply become way more valuable than they used to be.
They are, in the short-term. The problem is that high housing costs have a slow, long-term corrosive effect on a city. Companies have to pay higher wages for workers to achieve the same standard of living, which makes them less competitive. So, for example, you see a lot of tech companies springing up in Austin now. It doesn't happen overnight, but it happens.
It also creates a large net transfer of wealth out of the city whenever someone moves. Someone who moves in with half a million dollars in net assets would normally be a boon because they would go use that money to patronize local businesses, but now they have to spend that and a good chunk of their salary going forward on housing, which goes to the seller who is moving out of the city and taking the money with them.
The housing ratchet is also completely unsustainable. The people who already own real estate want prices to increase rather than decrease to justify the high price they already paid and generate a competitive return on that huge amount of money, but when housing is already the majority expenditure for city residents, costs long-term can't increase faster than wages, and the higher wages get for the same standard of living the less competitive local companies are.
Eventually you reach a limit on how high housing costs can sustainably go, but once you hit it, nobody wants to put down a million dollars for a house that won't appreciate at all when they could be getting some ROI on the same money in the stock market. Then prices finally start to decline, but people definitely don't want to pay $950K for a house that will lose value, so the decline is rapid. This is, of course, catastrophic.
It's almost impossible to avoid this once the values are already ridiculous, but what the article suggests can mitigate it somewhat: Sustained moderate inflation combined with a large increase in the housing supply, so that real values come down even though nominal values are stable. Then the crash is in real value rather than nominal value, so people don't end up with underwater mortgages, and it can ideally happen over a period of a decade or so rather than instantaneously in a way that causes a local economic crisis.
- timcederman 8y agoI think for most folks actually living in these high cost areas, capital appreciation is not the primary motivation. Also I disagree that they are universally destructive - how else do you explain the long term success of high price cities such as London, New York City, Hong Kong, etc.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I think for most folks actually living in these high cost areas, capital appreciation is not the primary motivation. Sure, they want a house so they can live in it. But who wants to pay a million dollars, which you either have to pay interest on (if borrowed) or can't collect interest on (if not), when it's only going to be worth the same amount of money in 30 years? At 5% interest, the lack of equivalent appreciation more than quadruples the opportunity cost of buying the house over the course of 30 years. It changes what they're willing to pay. > Also I disagree that they are universally destructive - how else do you explain the long term success of high price cities such as London, New York City, Hong Kong, etc. It has always been the case that some cities are more expensive than others, but that's not what we're talking about. Nor are we talking about small affluent sections like Manhattan. If you look at, say, Brooklyn, it was historically affordable to ordinary people (and 20 minutes from Manhattan). That's what's changed. And there's no way housing in San Francisco isn't a massive bubble. It's hard to predict how long it will be before the crash, but it's obvious that it's not sustainable.
- timcederman 8y agoThey said that about Australia 15 years ago and the heat in the market is only just coming off. Housing prices aren't just going up in San Francisco. It's the entire Bay Area. In the last collapse, houses in "good" locations didn't lose any value. There was a pause for a couple of years (or in cities like Palo Alto, none at all) and then they started going back up again. Other cities, e.g. Alameda (http://rereport.com/alc/charts/a_all_sfr.png http://rereport.com/alc/charts/a_all_sfr.png), suffered losses of over 50%. I expect to see something similar if there is a collapse of the overall bubble, but there will still be extremely expensive housing. We've been through it all before. https://www.nytimes.com/1990/08/29/business/california-sees-housing-boom-become-slump.html https://www.nytimes.com/1990/08/29/business/california-sees-... edit: also I said they're not "universally" destructive, which I stand by, so long as some affordable housing options remain.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> They said that about Australia 15 years ago and the heat in the market is only just coming off. It is absolutely true that housing bubbles can span decades. But the longer they grow, the bigger the pop. Unless you deflate them first by increasing supply. > In the last collapse, houses in "good" locations didn't lose any value. The last collapse wasn't caused by the same things. What happened then is that banks loaned money to people who couldn't pay it back, which inflated housing prices until they started to default. The people who live in Palo Alto had better credit, didn't default, and could still get a loan even after the crisis (or didn't need one), so the houses in that area didn't lose value. What's happening in this case is that housing in some areas is getting so expensive that even people making six figures can barely afford it. When it gets to the point that they actually can't afford it, the high end status of the neighborhood won't save them. And a crash doesn't have to result in cheap housing. It can be a move from preposterously expensive housing to "only" very expensive housing. But if that's a 50% reduction in value, people are going to be unhappy. > also I said they're not "universally" destructive, which I stand by, so long as some affordable housing options remain. You may be right that if you consider only the most expensive houses, they may not lose as much value, because they're the ones that are actually worth ten million dollars. But non-universality is a small consolation if the effect still hits 85% of the local housing stock.
- mistermann 8y ago> It's almost impossible to avoid this once the values are already ridiculous, but what the article suggests can mitigate it somewhat: Sustained moderate inflation combined with a large increase in the housing supply, so that real values come down even though nominal values are stable. I'm having trouble understanding what inflation means in this context. From the article: > There is a way out, but it’s not a pleasant one. The economically unpleasant period of the mid-1970s, when GDP fell sharply and inflation rose to 25%, was relatively short-lived, largely because the inflation bailed out the housing market, which had already become overblown in 1973. Only a similar but more prolonged period of inflation, which will depress real house prices even as nominal house prices decline less, bailing out the mortgage market, will enable the British economy to avoid the truly disastrous situation of mass mortgage default. > Provided the inflation takes place as required, the young will manage to navigate this situation successfully. They will be able to negotiate salary increases, as we were in the 1970s, so that their living standards keep up, more or less, although they may feel pinched. The declining real value of homes will bring more and more possible house purchases into their view, although they may find the landscape very short of mortgage lenders. Since the period of price decline is only beginning, the luckiest will be those too young to have got themselves on the housing ladder at inflated prices, not the silly Millennials, but post-Millennials. If we're speaking about price inflation, isn't that literally what a massive housing bubble is, the mother of all price inflation scenarios (setting aside the fact that government statisticians cook the books in various ways in order to show shelter costs are perfectly inline with other prices, completely regardless of what prices are really doing, because it's abnormal)? And if we're speaking about monetary inflation,well, where did all the money come from in the first place to make housing so expensive? Yes I know, when one house sells in a neighborhood or city everything is revalued, but when you've been at it for 10++ years and have had significant turnover of the entire inventory, this excuse begins to run thin after a while. If GDP growth is more or less flat, and there isn't negative growth in other areas like consumer spending, where is all the money coming from to execute the transactions? Is anyone aware of any articles that try to mathematically reconcile this on a macro basis, because it makes completely no sense to me. At least in Canada it appears to be almost pure magic that at most will only take a periodic breather before the relentless upward march resumes (see the slight dip during the 2008 global meltdown, the devastating crash in oil prices that only caused a flatline in oil-rich Calgary, or real estate capital gains in Vancouver being larger than earned income). As silly as it sounds, I am starting to believe that we're somehow mis-measuring something fundamental somewhere in the system, and that this time really is different. If it isn't, then how can this be quantitatively explained? Sure, it's easy to handwave it away with "the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent", but can one reconcile that with the actual reported numbers? Does what's happening add up?
- kosei 8y agoCan you give a couple examples of this happening? I've lived in NYC much of my life and housing prices have continued to rise for most of 30+ years, so your statement isn't something that I quite understand from experience.
- bobthepanda 8y agoNYC suffers from two distinct factors that have allowed it to sustain such a long boom in real estate prices. As a global financial and cultural center, it has enduring appeal for outsiders and foreigners to buy housing. Very few cities have this. And since these outsiders tend to pay cash, they're hard to outbid. This can distort the market a lot, because wealthy people get pushed down into upper middle class housing, upper middle class people get pushed down into middle class housing, and the shit rolls downhill until the poor can't afford to live anywhere. The other thing is that New York had really bad lows in the housing market in the 70s, to the point where people were burning down buildings because the insurance money was worth more than the property value. It's hard to go anywhere from there except up.