9 ms·
Google Groups Data To Be Destroyed
- timtadh 16y agoI had moved several student org's at my university to private Google Groups because of the pages and files feature. Now that this is feature is being killed they will be screwed since they were using it as the repository for their meeting minutes and other important documents.
- chc 16y agoThey can just download the data and stick it somewhere else. It's inconvenient, but nobody is "screwed."
- alec 16y agoThe author of the article was disappointed that the service was being discontinued, but his main reason for writing seemed to be calling attention to how quietly Google announced that it was destroying data. People won't download the data if they don't know it's going away.
- chc 16y agoThat is clearly not the case for the commenter whom I was addressing. He knows, so if the files he is worried about are deleted, it's due to his inaction. I don't want to see anyone just throw up their hands and accept victim status when there's a better option. As for other people, I thought Google added a notice to the Groups files page along the lines of "Hey, dude, you might want to download this stuff before it goes bye-bye". I don't use the service, but that's what I heard. Was I misinformed? EDIT: Yup, it's there. The notice, in bright red at the very top of the page, reads: "Google Groups will no longer be supporting the Pages and Files features. Starting January 13, you won't be able to upload new content, but you will still be able to view and download existing content. See this announcement for more information and other options for storing your content."
- timtadh 16y agoI mean not so much my inaction as I am no longer running those groups :-p Actually what I was concerned about wasn't the disappearance of the data, but the disappearance of the feature. I chose groups because those features made it really easy to manage the entire group. I worked hard to set up a process around how the google groups worked. So the sense that the organization is "screwed" is that they will have to completely change the way the function internally and find a new centralized portal for managing there stuff. As far as the warning goes they gave plenty of warning. I am just disappointed the feature disappeared.
- adambyrtek 16y agoGoogle Docs and Sites are much better applications for managing this kind of content. Docs allows you to collaboratively edit documents in real-time with multiple participants and Sites can be a decent CMS or wiki. Just try both and you won't miss the old features that are being removed from Groups.
- sage 16y agoThe problem is that the users of my Google group aren't necessarily tech savvy. Now they'll have to remember that files are at one url and messages are at another. I'm pretty sure I'll have to repeatedly remind them of this. Besides, who's to say Google won't pull the plug on those other services in a year? It seems unlikely, but I also thought it was unlikely they'd remove those features from Groups.
- uxp 16y agoThe description of the group could simply point them to those URLs. The link would nearly be in the same place as it is now, and many un-tech-savvy people wouldn't even notice anything changed. In fact, I'd bet many would think that the feature got "Upgraded"
- Tomek_ 16y agoAuthor tried a cheap trick of attracting audience by using a title of a big "shock-value". But the truth is not as bad as that title suggest: the most important thing about Google Groups, discussions that is, are not going anywhere, it's only "Files" and "Pages" features that are going to be trashed.
- sucuri2 16y agoWhich is a big deal if you use this features. Plus, I run many groups and didn't know they were disabling these features, so they are not telling everyone about it.
- acqq 16y agoFor those who didn't use the features, here is how it looks like in one example: http://groups.google.com/group/groovyplusplus http://groups.google.com/group/groovyplusplus (Discussions 1090 messages) (Pages 1 page) (Files 1 file) Google announced: "we have decided to stop supporting the pages and files features." "Starting in November 2010, Groups will no longer allow the creation or editing of files and pages" "In February 2011, we will turn off the pages and files features, and you will no longer be able to access that content."
- uxp 16y agoI read this article this morning and thought, "Oh they're removing some feature I don't even know exists.", but didn't want to comment on it worrying that maybe I really do use it and it is useful. Then after reading your comment, I went to every Group I am subscribed to through Google Groups and couldn't find a single one that had a significant number of pages or files. The only group that did seem to use the feature is an old users group that has a very outdated iCal calendar and a group hackfest project from 2006 in a tarfile. Maybe I'm missing the point here, but why should Google be forced to maintain and update a feature of one of their products that from my observation, no one uses? If anyone is a member of a group that does use this feature heavily, what kind of files and pages do you have tied to your group, and couldn't those be simply moved to a sites.google.com address?
- kvs 16y ago
- binarycheese 16y agoGoogle Groups is one of the worst Google web apps (from a programming stand point). You cannot add code snippets easily, the search is horrible and you cannot even format code/text easily like in http://code.google.com http://code.google.com. Have they seen stackoverflow.com?
- jellicle 16y agoIt's October, right? And Google is notifying anyone who creates a Page or File that the feature is going to go away in February? (And it looks like they started doing so in September?) Seems like plenty of notice to me. One would assume that as the deadline gets closer, more prominent notices will be given. How many months do you need to move your data? Google should be held to high standards, both because they are an important part of internet infrastructure and because they've stated they aspire to high standards. Five months' notice meets those high standards as far as I'm concerned.
- yesbabyyes 16y ago"Beware of the Leopard."
- three14 16y agoI needed Google to decipher this excellent comment. In case it helps: "Yes," said Arthur, "yes I did. It was on display in the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying 'Beware of the Leopard'."
- metageek 16y agoThat's the display department.
- auxbuss 16y agoHitchhikers' with allusions to Zork. Let's geek... "But Mr Dent, the plans have been available in the local planning office for the last nine months." "Oh yes, well as soon as I heard I went straight round to see them, yesterday afternoon. You hadn't exactly gone out of your way to call attention to them, had you? I mean, like actually telling anybody or anything." "But the plans were on display ..." "On display? I eventually had to go down to the cellar to find them." "That's the display department." "With a flashlight." "Ah, well the lights had probably gone." "So had the stairs." "But look, you found the notice didn't you?" "Yes," said Arthur, "yes I did. It was on display in the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying 'Beware of the Leopard'."
- deadlyduplicate 16y agoIs this the start of the cloud computing dystopia that Stallman warned us about?
- erikpukinskis 16y agoThis is a perfect example of one of the Freedoms we don't have with web applications. Even with Microsoft Office you have the freedom to keep using the software today in the way you did yesterday. Even open source web applications don't have this freedom... If wordpress.org were to do this, those users would be in the same boat. I've been working on an open source infrastructure project to fix these issue for a while, but it's still pretty nascent. My "manifesto" on that is here: http://bit.ly/forkolator http://bit.ly/forkolator
- manveru 16y agoAnd for anyone who actually cares about proper linking: https://docs.google.com/Doc?docid=0AcmB_WI1jRkCZG41c2d4cl80OTJmOGpjNmNocw&hl=en https://docs.google.com/Doc?docid=0AcmB_WI1jRkCZG41c2d4cl80O...
- sedachv 16y agoHahaha, I'm dying from the irony! bit.ly etc. are pure evil, and are going to have a much more negative impact when they're gone than Google groups files.
- erikpukinskis 16y agolol. That is pretty funny.
- estel 16y agoPersonally it's more of a "I want to see what website I'm about to open in my browser" ideology than pithy moral meanings. But sure!
- 16y ago
- sp4rki 16y agoHum I see Google not making a big fuzz about it now, but saying that Google is obfuscating the announcement and the it destroys trust and all that is a false assumption until it actually happens. I'd expect email notifications and notifications inside the app to let me know the feature is being removed and how to move my data some time before the actual feature removal happens. I can't say Google has burned me until they do actually not inform me and 'destroy' my data. I think it's too early to say "Geez Google you're evil now!", and for the most part, this could be a small "Hey FYI, we're removing those features... we might not even be sure about it so we're not doing a big deal out of it yet." If this article was written 2 weeks before data was removed I'd understand, but as it is it comes out somewhat sensationalistic.
- charleso 16y agoDoes this mean the end of the DejaNews Usenet archive as well? The transformation of that unbelievably helpful resource into "Google Groups" was a crime. Geez, but I miss Usenet. Having _one_ forum on which everything related to a topic was posted was unbelievably helpful.
- adambyrtek 16y agoThey intend to remove only files and pages, which is something like a primitive wiki for your group. This feature was never widely used anyway and there are much better tools for the job (like Google Sites). BTW the Usenet still exists, even if it's not that active anymore.
- Mithrandir 16y ago> BTW the Usenet still exists, even if it's not that active anymore. GGroups has been the cause of most spam on Usenet for years. It's also sad because some of the people who aren't regular spammers think that when they post to a newsgroup via GGroups, they're only posting to that one server, and not on hundreds (if not thousands) of servers. Others think that GGroups and Usenet are the same, but not as many as the "un-spammers". It's too bad that this is going to happen, but... I guess that's Google for you. I wish that Google would instead try to prevent some of the spam on the Usenet, and not mess about with GGroups. :(
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- mattmcknight 16y agoI am wondering why they don't just integrate groups features into Google Apps (where you could use Sites and Docs to do this same thing). It leads me to believe (knowing nothing about the reality) that Groups was built on some different underlying technology stack that makes it more difficult to integrate... I had a JotSpot account that eventually became a Google Sites site, and the main thing that didn't migrate over neatly was the discussion forums. Also noticed this message on there: "Google Groups will no longer be supporting the Welcome Message feature. Starting January 13, you won't be able to edit your welcome messages, but you will still be able to view and download the existing content." Would it kill them to tell us why?
- duskwuff 16y agoI'm guessing that the removal of Files, Pages, and Welcome Messages are all for a single reason: spam. Spammers love Google Groups, because it'll host their landing pages (complete with graphics!) on a trusted domain. I'd be willing to bet that someone at Google got fed up playing whack-a-mole with Viagra ads.
- jsmcgd 16y agoThis is a good thing as far as I'm concerned. I don't think society is ready yet for the consequences of an internet that never forgets. I wish more websites would periodically delete content (with adequate warning).
- edge17 16y agoI actually find a lot of good content for debugging purposes in google groups
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- melipone 16y agoThat happened to me with my blog when they removed the ftp feature. I didn't want to convert automatically to a blogspot blog because I didn't have to time to deal with the privacy issues. Fortunately, I was able to download the data and I still have a web page for it that I could parse to convert it to another format but in the meantime I'm without blog. I still haven't decided to which format to convert my blog but I'm very tempted to convert it to an emacs org-mode format and then decide later.
- qeorge 16y agoThere's a big red warning at the top the welcome page (web version). Impossible to miss, although I know many people only use Google Groups via email.
- hughw 16y agoA bigger point Bruce makes is the issue of confidence in Google. Groups is consumer oriented, but as developers we've seen Google turn on a dime, change its mind, and leave developers who've bought in to their technology, out in the cold. Bruce mentions Wave... no follow through from Google. Anyone who pitched a Wave based service in their own companies or business plan is fired, but the Goog keeps rolling on unperturbed. Microsoft, whatever else you might say, never hung developers out to dry like that. Who's ready to build a full HTML 5 site now, and ask IE users to install Google Chrome Frame? Ready to bet your company on it? Six months from now, Google could get bored with it. Yawn. Not working out, fellas. But hey, it's open source, so you guys keep working on it, ok?
- jacquesm 16y agoI remember when google groups was still called 'dejanews' and I used it just about every day. Whatever I wanted to know, dejanews seemed to have the answer buried in its pages somewhere. The google took over and promised all kinds of great things would happen to the content. Only it never did. Google groups was the ugly stepchild in the google family, first dropped from the google homepage links, then completely neglected and left to rot. In a way it is surprising that it took this long for Google to make a decision on this, but it is a total waste of all the content in there. Are there any attempts to archive this stuff ? Is there a way to get the data in bulk ? I've seen first hand how important old data can be to people and I suspect this to be no different, the reocities.com project has been running for a bit under a year now and not a day goes by that I don't get notes from people that are insanely happy that their content was not lost.
- aufreak3 16y agoOn that notice page, Google suggests using "Google Sites" for pages and attach files to pages on the site. If it is straightforward for someone to do it, I find it strange that they don't do it automatically and tell the people "we'll be migrating your data to Google Sites" instead of taking it down.