3 ms·
https://xkcd.com/1987/ https://xkcd.com/1987/ Don't get me wrong, I like Python. If you're a non-programmer and you want to start programming, and you want to
by danShumway 8y ago
https://xkcd.com/1987/ https://xkcd.com/1987/
Don't get me wrong, I like Python. If you're a non-programmer and you want to start programming, and you want to be useful and to be able to automate stuff quickly, you should learn Python.
Especially where math and statistics stuff is concerned -- I have a friend who recently started programming, and Python was his entry point. Unfortunately, the environment problems that everyone says are solved are still a pain. I had to troubleshoot his setup a lot; in particular it was a pain to make sure that if he called `python` from the command line it would be the same version as his IDE.
And Python as a language is just kind of big. It's the same problem that Javascript suffers from -- sure, you can learn just the basic stuff, but will that help you when you're looking at other people's code online? Will that help you if you're checking out an OS project? That kind of ecosystem matters for accessibility.
Both Python and Javascript have this philosophy of "there should be a library for everything". But what that means is that there's a ton of extra stuff just floating around, and no matter how much you tell people to ignore it, they don't. It's not a bad thing, in a lot of ways it's a very good thing. But it has consequences.
Python adds onto that with the idea that everything should be readable. So there are multiple ways to iterate over an array, and the syntax sometimes subtly changes so the code looks cleaner. These are, again, not bad things. But they have consequences. They increase the number of concepts you're wrapping your head around.
Compare Python with TI-83 Basic. A much, much smaller standard library that you can teach even a brand new programmer in like, a month. A few interesting restrictions (limited variables) that subtly push towards more advanced concepts (I learned how pointers worked on the TI-83 before I know what the word meant).
I think this is why people gravitate towards platforms like the Pico-8. There's something refreshing about being in a bounded environment where all of the concepts are kept small. Learning to program for the first time is about experimenting and learning to go in depth with a couple of concepts, not learning a wide variety of concepts.
That friend I was talking about eventually went back to doing a lot of programming in Excel instead of Python. Python was more powerful, and he played with it a bit, but he has an entire grasp around how cells in Excel interact with each other, so he's able to do creative stuff by just thinking about the stuff he already knows. He can write a program on paper without being at a computer. In contrast, when he wanted to do something creative in Python, he had to go Google "how do I do X"?
- thanatropism 8y agoI do a lot of "creative" work in Excel too. Finance/business stuff where the shape of the problem itself is ill-defined. It's a whiteboard, not a "programming language" -- nothing that isn't visible will ever happen; nothing is programmed. ---- I had to write codes for my dissertation in Matlab because that's what my advisor knew. Matlab is popular in research because so many ideas are already whiteboarded in matrix formalisms. I feel like Python is like this, but for object-oriented programming: rewriting my dissertation codes in Python gives me uglier code because of numpy, but it's easier to package it in such a way that it can be reused and extended. (I.e. it's not its mathematical nature, it's "parameterizable encapsulation". This is even better seen in something like Flask). I think you're saying that Python isn't great at procedural programming. I disagree -- the syntax is simple and it's there -- it's just that not a lot of relevant open source projects rely on a procedural style. Contrast: Python isn't great at functional programming; it's very hard to express ideas like functors and monads.
- danShumway 8y ago> I think you're saying that Python isn't great at procedural programming. No, I'm saying it has weaknesses as a first programming language for beginners. Of course Python is practical, that's why it's so insanely popular. The reason my friend went back to Excel wasn't because of a weakness in how Python is structured or what types of programs you can write in it. He left it because he didn't like needing to look up how to do things, or look to see what library supported what function. Excel is limited and inflexible, but he knows the "API" by heart, so when he's doing something creative, he's spending more time thinking in depth about the concepts he already knows, and less time learning new concepts. Python is just big. There's a lot of it. There are multiple ways to do everything. That's good, and I like that about the language. But it's also kind of bad. You can ignore a lot of it, but that takes effort and it limits what resources/tutorials you can look at online. Being able to grab someone else's code off the Internet and learn from it or change it for your own projects is nice. But if you want to do that for Python, you need to be good at the language first. That's what I think the strength of very small languages are. You can hold them entirely in your head without too much effort, so as a beginner you're able to spend more time applying them, which is often the fun part of programming for a beginner anyway.