35 ms·
It's a bummer, at one point Server was actually a pretty cool product, Network Homes and such were a great feature for Macs and it was approachable for a lot SM
by xoa 8y ago
It's a bummer, at one point Server was actually a pretty cool product, Network Homes and such were a great feature for Macs and it was approachable for a lot SMB applications. A nice GUI on some good open source features isn't a bad thing. I feel that Apple missed a bit of an opportunity there by being stuck in the 90s and early 00s mold where Macs weren't really considered at all, and thus of course businesses weren't so interested either very often. But times changed and if Apple had kept with it they could have both capitalized that and potentially carved out a profitable niche, it would have lined up well with current worries about over centralization and dependence on the cloud and services if Apple had a friendly product that let people do stuff at home. There were a lot more interesting possible features there that never got and now will probably never be explored in the same way.
Granted, the same can be said about a lot of Apple product possibilities, including desktop Macs period. And there are always tradeoffs: Apple's startup-type organizational structure makes multi-tasking hard, but also makes for fantastic focused products. If they were more traditionally structured they probably would have maintained the Mac a lot better, but would the iPhone have come to be in the same way?
At any rate it leaves a small hole for me at least, I don't mind handling things normally at work but I enjoyed playing with a nice GUI at home, and some small business I know still use Server. I asked for some suggestions on the Ars forums, and for anyone else wondering, one I was given that now looks really promising after first tests is Synology's DiskStation Manager, run standalone if you buy their equipment but also possibly under ESXi vis Xpenology (alongside macOS if that's still desirable for some of the remaining MDM functionality and such). I haven't dug deep into it yet but the GUI and power looks pretty nice, and ESXi will even run on Mac Pros in which case a macOS guest shouldn't even be a license violation. Something to consider anyway as a replacement. For simple network needs those running UniFi kit might find the controller is also enough, though right now it's a little shallow on some core features. Might still be good enough and again a decent GUI.
Anyone on HN have any other ideas for equivalents, with sane GUI defaults even if some CLI usage is needed as well? Are some free general distros these days fine for that, or have popular GUI managers that can go on top? I could see more specific distributions like FreeNAS being good for some applications depending on what exactly Server was being used for. Another storage focused option might be NexentaStor CE, though that is limited to 10TB.