4 ms·
OpenID is not a perfectly good protocol. It is a total mess. Implementing it is an exercise in pulling teeth. Every major implementation was vulnerable to a
by patio11 16y ago
OpenID is not a perfectly good protocol. It is a total mess. Implementing it is an exercise in pulling teeth. Every major implementation was vulnerable to a timing attack until recently, which severely compromised the security of both sites which actually accept OpenID. The user experience is an abomination which requires users understand concepts which strike them like ancient Aramaic. Half of the spec, which you have to implement, is devoted to requirements put there for ideological reasons which no user is actually interested in (delegation). The core use case -- that any site on the website can ask for your holiest of holy credentials and you should just give them out -- appears to be the world's most widespread phishing attack, organized by sleeper agents planted on the spec committee whose dark masters tasked them with undermining everything we have ever taught users about password security.
- bambax 16y agoYes, but isn't the core use case the same with any third party identification service, such as Facebook Connect or MS Passport or whatever?
- joeyh 16y agoDelegation is of great interest to anyone who runs their own web site but prefers to not run their own openid server. (Won't touch the other trolling.)