3 ms·
I would point out that a lot of the techie disdain for "MBAs" isn't at MBAs in general (though there is some of that), but specifically at "Harvard MBAs", the h
by jerf 8y ago
I would point out that a lot of the techie disdain for "MBAs" isn't at MBAs in general (though there is some of that), but specifically at "Harvard MBAs", the high powered business types that are trained to swoop into a company, assess best how to tear it to bits, sell the pieces, and make a tidy profit for themselves and their paymasters while disrupting the lives of everybody else involved, and possibly the industry as a whole, or perform a variety of other such things that involve offloading all the risk and pain on to the employees while taking the profit and value for themselves.
There is a time and a place for such shenanigans but the techies of folklore saw it happen in a lot of bad places in a lot of bad ways.
Some of the rest of the disdain for MBAs is that a lot of such courses are aimed at the general public; if you are the type that had a computer science degree in your past, you will find the course to be slow and the coursework to be trivial, and you'll probably quite correctly feel you'd be better off on at least the most direct level (ignoring "networking", etc.) studying it yourself. But I kept my qualification to the speed of the course and the homework carefully; the ideas inside can still be useful and valuable, it's just they'll come at a rather slow pace compared to what you may be used to and wrapped in a lot of BS (to you) coursework.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoI think the bulk of the antipathy is directed toward the Excel/SAS jockeys who blindly use metrics to force an "improvement" in the business without understanding the business they are supposedly skilled at managing. Then there are those who want to make themselves look valuable by instituting change for change's sake.
- seppin 8y agoEngineers think they could do the business part of they "really wanted to", but don't believe MBAs could do their job. They think they are smarter. Also there's a shocking amount of nerds vs jocks BS that still goes on well into adulthood. Some people never get over high school.
- Jach 8y agoTo be fair, the startup mythos canon supports this. Many examples of programmers learning the business stuff on the fly as they scale, not out of a sense of "if I wanted to" but "now I need to". The opposite? If there are examples, they're not part of the mythos.
- jacques_chester 8y agoIt's generally easier to learn business on the fly if 1) your gross margin is enormous, 2) you fluke into a massive network effect that can scale incredibly quickly because it is not bound by space and matter or 3) someone hands you literally millions of dollars in exchange for equity. Not debt, which comes with serious legal teeth, but equity, for which the worst threat is being upset you didn't get rich. Ask someone who has built a cleaning business, or runs a restaurant, or who works as a roofing contractor, whether business is easy.