5 ms·
I don't want to start an environmental flame war, but... Isn't the disposal of inert materials in landfills one of the lease important environmental problems?
by jessriedel 16y ago
I don't want to start an environmental flame war, but...
Isn't the disposal of inert materials in landfills one of the lease important environmental problems? Yes, if you're cutting down rain forests to make your cups, infusing them with CFCs, or using terrawatts of fossil-fuel-based power, then there are issues to discuss. But if you're just putting paper in a big pile somewhere, there's basically no issue. For all intents and purposes, our space for landfills is unlimited.
Could someone fill me in on any aspect of this I'm not considering?
- robryan 16y agoWell, if we were recycling all our current paper based waste then less rain forests would have to be cut down to keep up with demand. Have been thinking about advertising catalogues you get in the mail and phone books as well today, both products that use a lot of paper for marginal benefit these days.
- ars 16y agoNot a single sheet of paper is made from rain forest trees. In fact almost nothing is made from rain forest trees. They are usually cut down to use the land, not for the trees.
- jessriedel 16y ago> Well, if we were recycling all our current paper based waste then less rain forests would have to be cut down to keep up with demand. Rain forests are cut down to clear land for farming in developing countries, not for wood.
- kia 16y agoLandfill space is not unlimited. I understand that you are talking about US, but some countries (Japan) have huge problems with space. The less you have the more you should think about doing things right.
- ohyes 16y agoYou are coming at it from the wrong angle. The disposal of inert materials in a landfill is trivial. The problem is that we are disposing of otherwise useful materials, in a landfill. If I'm putting paper in a big pile of paper, and not using it for anything, I'm wasting resources, I could use that big pile of paper for something else. Landfills can also be a problem, as they can have negative effects on things like local water quality. If we are using landfill space when we don't need to use it (things that are inert and recyclable), it is a waste of landfill space, which we should try to minimize and use for things that actually need to be disposed of safely.
- ars 16y agoPaper uses more resources to recycle (especially water) than it uses to make it fresh. It's a feel good thing that does more harm than good. Putting paper in the ground is excellent from a CO2 sequestering point of view as well.
- ohyes 16y agoA quick Google search makes me think your first point is not true. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recycled_paper#Rationale_for_recycling http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recycled_paper#Rationale_for_re... Granted, it is Wikipedia, and I'd welcome data to back up your point, but other sources seem to say similar things. Barring a great internet hippie recycling conspiracy, I'd say you are wrong. The article seems to be focused on the idea of composting the cups anyway.
- maukdaddy 16y agoAwww don't disappoint me like that Ars. Paper in the ground is the opporite of CO2 sequestering because you had to cut down a TREE to make that paper. A living tree is, by definition, a CO2 sequestering machine. Also, throwing paper and organic matter into modern landfills, which promote anaerobic breakdown, produces methane. As you know, methane is a much more potent greenhouse gas than CO2.
- ars 16y ago
- ars 16y agoYou are completely correct. The only aspect you are not considering is the "feel good" greenwashing. There are far far far more important goals than recycling or composting paper.
- TorKlingberg 16y agoSource please.
- maukdaddy 16y agoAccording to the WWF (http://www.worldwildlife.org/sites/TED/change.html http://www.worldwildlife.org/sites/TED/change.html) it takes 53 gallons of water to make 1 latte. A great deal of this water is used in making the cup. So why use all that water for a product that gets trashed?
- ars 16y agoWe use water for lots of things. Why are we focusing on the cup? There are much better places to conserve water. Crop irrigation, and getting rid of septic systems would be where I would start. Don't grow crops in places where you need to irrigate (or at least reduce it), and septic systems waste water, instead of recycling it like a sewer does.
- robryan 16y agoI think that for a company that is supplying billions of cups a year that end up in landfill focusing on the cup should be a priority.
- Retric 16y agoThe cost of 1 gallon of water is something like 1/100th of a cent in most areas. If you want people to conserve water increase its cost, anything else and it will just be "wasted" somewhere else. http://paul.kedrosky.com/archives/2007/04/semiconductors.html http://paul.kedrosky.com/archives/2007/04/semiconductors.htm... Note: $27 per acre-foot = 0.008 cents per gallon.
- stellar678 16y agoIf you design systems to have a one-way flow of materials, they are inherently unsustainable. At some point, you'll run out of source materials and/or space to put waste.