4 ms·
Well, some flaws I see in his reasoning: qualification is based on publications and quality of work is based on citations. With the ongoing discussin about "pub
by hef19898 8y ago
Well, some flaws I see in his reasoning: qualification is based on publications and quality of work is based on citations. With the ongoing discussin about "publish or vanish" (I'm following it as a bystander, not being a scientist in any way myself) raises the question if that is really the best indicator or if less publications are rather a sign of more diligent work. Working at CERN one would think he is in a position to judge the quality of work himself.
Also, this approach fails to identify the underlying reasons for the perceived difference in citations. Is it due to some inherent discrimination that women get publiches less and thus cited less or not. I would have expected some deeper analysis of the numbers and data he worked with. From what I saw he just picket numbers to confirm his own POC, classic case of confirmation-bias and pretty self-revealing.
EDIT: To make it alittle bit clearer. I don't just doubt his conclussion / message, I already doubt the way he is trying to measure the different quality of work done bymale and female physicist as deeply flawed and error prone.