4 ms·
> He also presented data that he claimed showed that male and female researchers were equally cited at the start of their careers but men scored progressively b
by nabla9 8y ago
> He also presented data that he claimed showed that male and female researchers were equally cited at the start of their careers but men scored progressively better as their careers progressed.
Is this evidence for or against discrimination?
Say, both male and female researchers start from the same position but females have 1% change for their work not being cited or published because of their gender every time they publish. Number of publications and citations can cumulatively affect the changes of getting the next publication accepted (citations and publications are used when selecting people into groups that produce more citations and publications) In the start of the career the effect is not noticeable, but it will accumulate over time.
It's infuriating that CERN removed the slides. Strumia presented arguments with evidence that can be used in the discussion to argue that he is wrong.
It should be possible to use Strumia's numbers to calculate bias coefficient to this alternative hypothesis. It should be also possible to do scientific experiments to find out the correct hypothesis. You would think that experimental physicists in CERN could solve this problem.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoCERN is the last place for discussing these kind of social issues which are only going to cause furor. They should well and indeed be studied, but not there. Also, it's a really hard one. Biases abound.
- candiodari 8y ago> They should well and indeed be studied, but not there. Yes, let's discuss them in social sciences (which is presumably what you're advocating). Because then we guarantee * no use of actual facts or figures * idiots will be doing the discussing purely for virtue signaling (looking good, not for doing the right thing) * these people (social sciences) justify their own existence because of a problem ... wanna bet they'll find the problem is worse than we thought ? They are not neutral observers, nor are they even taught to be that (by contrast, CERN is filled with people that are trained to be neutral observers) What's worrying most is that society at large seems to have made the decision that looking good and pretending to be morally correct is far more important than actually achieving something ... The social sciences themselves are designed like that: they start from the goal to modify society to achieve theoretical aims ... Allow me to make some modest predictions: 1) they'll fail 2) they'll do a LOT of damage before they fail 3) they'll cheat, fraud, ... in the process to prove the problem they fix exists and gets worse all the time despite ever more draconian efforts to fix it You cannot - and should not - control society for ANY ideology. You'll end up pushing very anti-women ideologies or worse. * people are now taught to cheat for "good causes" are going to cheat for their own personal ends (much) more as well ? * people will simply lie about things like gender equality, as that's rewarded, so it won't even achieve what you want * people will use these policies to undermine the organizations implementing them (or do you think women scammers are worse than male scammers ? This will be abused) * we are actually going to judge projects ... like the large hadron collider ... based on how much they advance women in science ? If we rate stupidity from 0 to 10, this has got to be well on the way to 20. * and of course there's once again the dedicated victim class. Much too few male mathematicians, for instance, are we going to start sabotaging women mathematicians ? No, only one group gets punished. This is not at all going to lead to resentment ... * it is fundamentally unfair. And no, you cannot fix one kind of unfair with another. This make society more unfair, not less.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoI share some of your cynicism, but let's have faith.
- gpm 8y agoI think you're interpreting that sentence too harshly. CERN has to concern itself with politics, it is a organization funded by them. Controversial discussion endangers that funding. It is perfectly reasonable to ask that this controversial discussion not on their topic of study go elsewhere. That doesn't mean to the faculty of woman and gender studies, or social sciences as a whole. I in particular am delighted that a physicist feels safe enough to discuss it even though I disagree with him. It just means that I'd rather this was broadcast as a paper, blogpost, non-CERN conference, etc.
- KirinDave 8y agoFolks are passing the slides, which don't actually have data (EDIT: supportive of his preference or σ=1.15 arguments, he does summarize and offer a bit of data about how women claim to be marginalized in the field). Folks there say the slides are not reflective of quite how angry and off-putting the talk was. It was not presented calmly. Here are the slides: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1c_NyUhOZ8erdqU2AGZJZtNfFeA91Kefj/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/1c_NyUhOZ8erdqU2AGZJZtNfFeA9... WARNING: These slides are not very good or compelling and invoke, "Cultural Marxism" as a causal agent for why women want to and feel entitled to a fair shot at STEM positions by merit. You can be modestly sure anyone who says, "Cultural Marxism" (a direct invocation of the specter of Nazi propagandists' "cultural bolshevism") isn't arguing with the best of intentions. Folks invoking that nonsensical saw aren't about to present a huge quantity of well sourced and organized evidence. Usually that phrase is associated with statistics about the number of Jewish investors in the US, how CoCs are destroying culture, how dangerous Muslims are to "European cultures," or how women and socialism caused the fall of the Roman empire.
- nabla9 8y agoI agree with you about "Cultural Marxism", the author clearly is not presenting neutral facts. However he also poses a theory based on existing data. --- For those who don't know: "Cultural Marxism" a term with two meanings: Obscure and irrelevant meaning and more common based on conspiracy theories. If you have been reading about "Cultural Marxism" and have thought it's something you can just drop into dissuasion, maybe check your facts. It's about as neutral and academic term as "capitalist pig" or "Illuminati".
- wmil 8y agoIt's not really accurate to call it a conspiracy theory. It's really just an attempt to name a group of ideas. The "conspiracy theory" charge is just push back because it's easier to criticize ideas if you can name them.
- KirinDave 8y agoPersonally I think that it's much better to point to it's near-indisitinguishability from "Cultural Bolshevism" which was an anti-jewish & anti-worker-union movement in Germany prior to WW2. It's a real problem for anyone seriously attempting to use the term. It makes me wonder why people cling to it as a classification (when literally hundreds of other options exist), which are more descriptive and don't try and invoke the specter of authoritarian Russian regimes. What's actually "marxist" about it?