4 ms·
Yup. That's why Apple has always sold more computers than IBM compatibles. The fragmentation in the hardware market prevented developers from using MS Windows
by wccrawford 16y ago
Yup. That's why Apple has always sold more computers than IBM compatibles. The fragmentation in the hardware market prevented developers from using MS Windows. And all those versions every couple years... Man, just horrible.
Oh wait, that's exactly the opposite of what happened.
Choice is not bad. Differing hardware doesn't matter.
- apl 16y agoDiffering hardware isn't even the core issue here. It's differing software. Windows was always consistent across Dell, HP et cetera. Android is not.
- CountHackulus 16y ago> Windows was always consistent across Dell, HP et cetera. This is so very far from the truth. Different OEMs ship with different patches, and some have custom drivers written, or "management" software that replaces key windows applications. If you've ever tried to write a game for Windows you'll know that once you get to testing, you'll find a ton of just plain strange setups that make no sense. You are however quite correct in saying that differing software is the key issue here.
- apl 16y agoI guess you're right, yes. From a technical point of view, Windows is quite fragmented. However, it always offered surface-level consistency, with the exception of proprietary management software for certain tasks. Put a customer in front of a Windows machine, and he'll feel at home. Give a customer a smartphone from HTC, Samsung and Motorola, and I'd be surprised if he could tell that it's the same OS on all three. This software fragmentation is both a blessing and a curse. Without it, Android would never have taken off the way it did, because networks/hardware developers like the malleability. However, from a customer's perspective, this is sub-optimal.
- silvestrov 16y agoWindows is different at the OS install level, but at the application level it doesn't matter if your Wintel is from Dell or HP or Gateway or... Photoshop doesn't come in a version for "HP Windows" and one for "Dell Windows", and ... It is the application level that matters for consumers buying apps. Very few users reinstall the OS on their mobile phone.
- Keyframe 16y agoWell, actually, for a while there were some applications available in Windows x86 and Windows Alpha (DEC) versions. Now we have x86 and x64 versions, which is not all that different when you think about it.
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoI've yet to be convinced that anyone making these analogies knows anything about either Windows or Android. The last Dell laptop I saw had a Mac OS X style Dock, as just one example. Before XP service pack 2 everyone added their own software for doing wireless. I had another Dell laptop that included 2 different display settings in the Control Panel, one of which was simply ignored which was frustrating when trying to get it working with a projector, you needed to use the one provided by the maker of the video chip (Intel I think, but could have been ATI). Let's not even start on crapware, trialware and "Control Centres" that try to upsell you various services. Jobs had to describe Windows as "open" to make his rhetoric work, which is a major warning sign. If you have to rewrite the history of Windows so that it's a pristine and consistent experience across vendors then that's a bad sign for your argument too.
- konad 16y agoThat would be true if the fragmentation in the hardware was between Sparc, Alpha, X86, Arm, Etc. The market example you attempted did the opposite, it consolidated around X86.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoNo it didn't. It (largely) concentrated around the x86 instruction set. But there's 32-bit and 64-bit, Intel and AMD (and in the past Citrix, etc.), and let's not forget about the ARM chips. But that's just the CPU. Don't forget about all the different expansion bus designs (ISA, PCI, and a few others through the years), memory bus designs, graphics accelerators (and their interfaces), mass storage (IDE, SATA, a plethora of SCSI variants). We've got multiple types of interfaces for mice and keyboards, printers, The set of computers that I could buy to run Windows on my desktop has a huge degree of variety.
- konad 16y agoCome off it. Making some hardware and writing a device driver is hardly fragmentation. If the SATA drive didn't run on Windows the day it shipped, there would be no point shipping it.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoI think you dismiss my point to quickly. You comment on my point about disk drives. However, the differences between mass storage media is most certainly a factor that authors of many applications need to consider. Capacity and performance characteristics are relevant in video editing, for example. Optical disc burning software must consider the quantity, performance, capacity, erasability, etc., of the drives (and discs) present -- and must deal with different driver interfaces as well. The difference between graphics adapters is an extreme difference. Authors needing advanced graphics capabilities must be able to handle different capabilities (resolution of course, but also shaders, etc.), and in extreme cases, GPU code downloaded to the adapter. They may have to deal with different software interfaces (DirectX vs OpenGL). And the handling of multiple monitors is a common question these days. Even CPUs, as glibly dismissed, have far more differences. For some kinds of applications the developer may need to deal with the presence of SSE2 or SSE3 instructions, for example. There really is a tremendous amount of fragmentation in PC-compatible hardware. And your reply about "writing a device driver" is, of course, part of the answer. When the variance is sufficiently important, developers create abstraction layers so that they don't need to worry about it -- that's the point of things like OpenGL or TWAIN.