4 ms·
Morality: 'We can send religion to the scrap heap'
- shawndumas 16y agoTo start up discussion I'll drop a quote from Gordon H. Clark: "I would like to make it clear that sociology, statistics, psychology, or any empirical science can never determine moral norms. Secular science at best can discover what people do; but it cannot discover what people ought to do. From observational premises no normative conclusion follows. Any attempt to define morality by observational science is a logical fallacy. Science can invent new ways of killing people, but science can never determine who should be killed. It cannot determine who should not be killed. It can only invent more effective ways of doing what somebody for some other reason wants to do. [...] Anyone who begins their arguments with statements about man and the universe -- statements in the indicative mood -- cannot end their arguments with statements in the imperative mood."
- AndrewDucker 16y agoThat's because there's no objective "what people ought to do", there's just what people would rather other people did.
- msluyter 16y agoYes, your point essentially mirrors Hume's famous is/ought gap, under which statements about what "ought" to be cannot be derived from statements about what is (factual statements.) This still poses some serious philosophical questions. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem
- brudgers 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalistic_fallacy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalistic_fallacy Kick off with fallacious reasoning. "Questions of right and wrong, good and evil, are questions about human and animal well-being." And replace religion with faith - "Once we accept the idea that right and wrong relate to questions of well-being, and that such questions have answers that will be best illuminated by honest observation and careful reasoning, then we can decide, once and for all, that certain people are not worth listening to on the subject of morality." We can decide certain people aren't worth listening to without accepting the idea.
- ugh 16y agoQuestions of right and wrong, good and evil, are questions about human and animal well-being. I agree that religion can tell us no more about morality than anything else but I’m not sure whether it’s that simple. Watching the discourse in society, however, it does actually look to me that this assumption underlies most of the discourse about moral questions. Nobody, if they don’t want to be laughed out of the room, says “Abortion should be illegal because the Pope who speaks for god on earth says so.”, they say “Abortion should be illegal because of facts A, B and C.” and those facts relate to human well-being [+]. That’s at least my experience with discourse in Europe. You might see overt references to religion but they are really rare. I don’t know how to justify the assumption that human well-being should be the center of our morality in detail (someone help me out please) and wouldn’t talk with the same certainty about it Sam Harris does but I do think that it today shapes much of our discourse about morality. Most people simply agree that human well-being is central to our morality, that’s why we so often can use science when we talk about morality. That’s why we can all agree about most moral questions. All that’s left are rare edge cases like abortion or euthanasia. [+] Even the Pope talks mostly about human well-being and not about scripture when he talks about abortion, see for example: http://www.catholicnews.com/data/stories/cns/0506904.htm http://www.catholicnews.com/data/stories/cns/0506904.htm
- tome 16y agoEven the Pope talks mostly about human well-being and not about scripture when he talks about abortion I think this is expedience on the part of the Catholic church more than anything else.
- JunkDNA 16y agoNot quite expedience. This is a tradition that dates back to the very earliest years of the Church (c.a. 160 AD), starting with Justin Martyr and his writings to the Emperor of Rome (known as "apologies"). Justin was a philosopher convert to Christianity and was known for using the language and reasoning common to philosophers of the time to defend the early Christian Church. He reasoned that if he was going to make a case for the Church, he would have to frame his argument with principles familiar to his audience. This was a novel approach at the time, but it has been emulated by countless people since.
- dazzawazza 16y agoI certainly agree that science can offer a more useful, factual and inclusive set of guide lines than any faith. Consider for example homosexuality which is in general considered a sin by religions. Well science can tell us that in reality it does no 'harm' to society or the individuals concerned. This can be used as a basis for policy in government and morality within society. Now consider slavery which many religion's texts consider acceptable. Science can tell us that it does a great deal of harm to the individual concerned, their close relatives and less but not insignificant harm to the host and parasitic societies. Again this can be used to form policy and wider morality. It doesn't mean that it will always be 'right' but it does mean we will be able to make changes to our moral landscape by learning from past mistakes and studying the data that led to past moral decisions. We will also be able to challenge other peoples morals using data and not ad-hominems etc. At the moment as a species we struggle with: - the false notion that morality is absolute: it never changes and can never change. - lack of data about how past absurd moral decisions were made (for example no gays, but slaves are a go)
- michael_dorfman 16y agoConsider for example homosexuality which is in general considered a sin by religions. Well science can tell us that in reality it does no 'harm' to society or the individuals concerned. Science can't tell us that, really. Even if we had an objective measure of "societal harm", we'd have to normalize somehow for the content of the cultures themselves. In other words, being gay may cause no social harm in a society that permits homosexuality, but may cause significant social harm in a society that does not. Science can be a contributing factor to discussions of morality, but it is not probative. At the moment as a species we struggle with: - the false notion that morality is absolute: it never changes and can never change. - lack of data about how past absurd moral decisions were made (for example no gays, but slaves are a go) In light of your first point: are you suggesting that morality is completely relative? Or merely that it is culturally contingent? If the latter, which portions are to be considered quasi-absolute so that we don't slip into the former? As to your second point: "absurd" by what definition? You are presupposing (by your notion of "absurdity") some sort of measure of "reasonability" that I think you will have trouble defining, especially if you think that absolute morality is a false notion.
- danbmil99 16y agoWhat creeps me out about Harris's ideas on this subject are the fact that he concludes we need a world government and a panel of "well-being" scientists to decide right and wrong. There's no way that could turn out bad, now is there? Sounds like a B- Hollywood script. Spoiler: the scientists are crazy and abuse their power to evil ends. Bruce Willis has to kill them and take over the world government for sane people everywhere.
- known 16y ago"Religion was born when the first con man met the first fool." --Mark Twain