4 ms·
Most of the programs that you're publishing on your "app store" have independent monetization channels, including direct donations from their users via accounts
by woodruffw 8y ago
Most of the programs that you're publishing on your "app store" have independent monetization channels, including direct donations from their users via accounts that they control. They might be surprised (and annoyed) to discover that you're charging for their work, even if the majority of that money ultimately makes it to them.
As others have pointed out, you probably have the legal right to run this sort of store. However, you should strongly consider consulting each project before listing them -- you might find that many are hostile to this sort of platform, and would prefer not to be hosted on it.
- adius 8y agoThat's what I did! Most were excited for an additional source of income as (who would have guessed it) their donation buttons don't yield a lot. It's also about discoverability and usability. Some projects have really complicated donation terms and hide the respective links on some nested sub pages. On cliapp.store I want to make it easier and more natural for users to support the developers.
- joshka 8y agoAs a suggestion, perhaps it would be better to start talking with homebrew for this instead, and generally bolting on top of existing package managers rather than adding another place to get things from.
- mikemcquaid 8y agoI'm the Homebrew lead maintainer and I can publicly confirm you have not had any contact with our project to discuss monetisation.
- FooBarWidget 8y agoSuch a double standard. Every time an open source project complains about the challenges of monetization (see the recent Redis controversy), people say "Don't like other companies making money off your software? Then don't license it that way!" But now that someone is actually doing that, people are not happy. My hypothesis is that people's opinion on this subject depends on what's convenient for them, and is not necessarily a reflection on whether the act itself is a good one or not. People can already get all these CLI apps very conveniently from a package manager, for free, and that is the reason why the idea of a paid app store disgusts people. Every time a GPL vs BSD conversation comes up, most people support BSD, saying that it's "more free". But I think the true reason is that people want to be able to use BSD-licensed libraries in their apps, which they profit from. Why were so many people against Redis Labs trying to protect their revenue streams? I think it's because people felt threatened that they may have to pay more in the future. We, as a community, need to make up our minds and stop being misled by our own agendas. It is fine to have one's own agenda but stop conflating that with moral issues.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoThose are different issues entirely. Right now, a party that is independent of the original developers has attempted to charge money for the work. There's no indication that the original authors consented to this, and there's no assurance besides some platitudes in a blog post that the authors will receive any part of the payment
- FooBarWidget 8y agoBut the seller does not need consent from the original authors! That is the whole point of open source licenses and of my comment! Amazon did not have to ask for consent to make money off Redis or Linux or anything else, but that is exactly why Redis Labs was not happy. See also https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/selling.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/selling.en.html
- woodruffw 8y agoYou're responding to the legality of this store, which I addressed in the original comment. Everybody is on-board with the idea that selling other peoples' open source work is legal, and there's no particular problem with that. The ethical problem, here in particular, is presenting yourself as an official storefront for the open source community. I don't care if Amazon integrates my projects into their infrastructure (they probably already do!) -- they don't present themselves as my financial middleman.
- detaro 8y agoThey are openly lying about the terms. Click the "trial license" (what?) text on any of the shop pages and read > You can try out Pandoc for free. To use it regularly, you must buy a license. They do not detail how they intent to share the money with the authors. Did they prepare with all the authors, are or they collecting money in their name without them agreeing to that? E.g. money paid to buy something is different than a donation from a tax perspective: how many authors are actually going to go to the paperwork to get the money?