2 ms·
Berkeley Lab Building Own Open Architecture Quantum Chips
- ThePhysicist 8y agoIrfan Siddiqi is one of the leading researchers in the field of quantum feedback and has done some really awesome experiments. I think developing new architectures for superconducting quantum chips is very important and there are many things that are still unresolved. John Martinis' group had (and maybe still has) a very open-source approach to this as well, they published most of the source code and custom-built electronics they use in their labs for controlling qubits (the architectures themselves are documented more in papers and theses). It seems their wiki is no longer reachable from the public web, shame. The quantum computing startups try to convey the impression that they solved all problems for building real-world quantum computers already, I think that many things are still open though (and so far none of the startups has really produced convincing evidence that they really have a working quantum computer, or even an interesting qubit chip). What I'd like to see from these startups are at least some basic measurements that characterize the quality of single-qubit manipulations, two-qubit gates and qubit readout. With that one could at least estimate what one could do with their quantum devices.
- mishurov 8y ago>and will work to integrate the higher-level Q# and other quantum languages when possible From the architectural point of view it could be something like heterogeneous programming i.e. CUDA kernels.
- asimpletune 8y agoDoes anyone know how things are leaning as to whether useful quantum computing is even possible/scalable? I recall reading somewhere that it’s an unanswered question, and that people are optimistic but it may be that there’s some undiscovered law of information that forbids it.
- deepnotderp 8y agoGil kalai's argument is essentially that quantum error correction is impossible because he believes that the error will affect too many qubits at once.
- deepnotderp 8y agoTo clarify, since I can't edit anymore: I don't agree with him, I'm just adding the viewpoint.
- greeneggs 8y agoThe broad consensus in the physics community is that quantum computers are in principle scalable (using either software error correction or, speculatively, still-hypothetical topological quantum devices). As for anything, there are of course still some naysayers. (Gil Kalai, mentioned in a sibling comment, is not a physicist and does not have a proposed physical model behind his objections, but his intuition could be correct.) If some undiscovered law of physics forbids it, that would be amazing! A more likely obstacle, though, is that it is just a really hard engineering problem.
- randomsearch 8y agoI’m guessing you mean in the abstract rather than in the short term, but it’s unclear. In the abstract, the jury is still out. I think many scientists would say - yes, provided the hardware guys improve the fidelity of operations and make things scale, it will be possible. But you’re going to need a very large number of qubits to do things like factoring large numbers, and we’re probably going to wait a long time for that. Short term - we’re going to be playing with “toy” examples for now. There’s a lot of focus on achieving “quantum supremacy”, which is a silly term, and finding things small enough and resilient enough to hardware limitations that are also mildly interesting.