5 ms·
> It’s mostly a privacy issue. There is a simple way to fix that. You wouldn't want to force everyone to upload anyway (some are on metered connections etc.),
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> It’s mostly a privacy issue.
There is a simple way to fix that. You wouldn't want to force everyone to upload anyway (some are on metered connections etc.), so what you would do is offer a nominal discount for uploading, but if you choose it then you don't just host what you watch, you host whatever needs more hosting capacity. Then random third parties can't tell what you watch because what you host is random.
This reduces the efficiency somewhat, but it's easy to minimize that: Don't give someone a hundred movies to host, give them one movie and have them host it a hundred times (over the course of a year).
- gruez 8y agoresidential customers have really poor upload speeds so how many customers would you need to have to replace 1 caching server collocated at an ISP? short of having FTTH, most customers would have < 10Mb/s up. a dedicated server can have multiple 10Gb/s links. you'd be looking at hundreds or thousands of customers per caching box. the "nominal discount" you're offering would have to be tiny for it to make sense financially. so much so that most customers wouldn't even bother.
- jdc 8y agoWhat does the ratio of customers to caching boxes have to do with the size of the proposed discount?
- gruez 8y agobecause if you're offering customers $1/month discount to use their computers as cache boxes, but dedicated 1 caching box is equivalent to 500 customers in terms of capacity, then if the amortized cost of 1 caching box is less than $500/month, it's cheaper to go with the dedicated cache box than to pay customers to run cache boxes. (all numbers are hypothetical)
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoIf the nominal discount was $1/month, most customers with an unmetered connection would take it because it's effectively free money. From the company's perspective it could even be revenue positive by raising the price $1 and offering it back as the discount. You're also not considering the power law distribution. If nineteen customers have 1Mbps uploads and one has symmetric gigabit, the average is >50Mbps. And the discount could be per-byte -- set it at half whatever the cost of central servers would be.
- gruez 8y ago>most customers with an unmetered connection would take it because it's effectively free money not really, because have to pay for the electricity costs of leaving your computer on 24/7. assuming a modest 50W power consumption for a PC, that works out to 36KWh per month, or $3.6 at 10 cents /Kwh. That alone wipes away your $1/month you're saving. also, that's a third of the monthly plan cost, how much of a discount can netflix really offer here? as for hard disk space, I'll grant it's "free" space (as in the consumer wasn't going to use it anyways), but running consumer drives 24/7 with frequent seeks can't be good for them.
- Declanomous 8y agoHow many people turn off their computer regularly? I suppose people with laptops probably do. I leave my computer on 24/7/365.
- the_duke 8y agoMost people that are not in IT.
- canhascodez 8y ago"Approximately 50% of computers are in On mode for 4 to 5 hours or less." https://ees.lbl.gov/sites/all/files/computers_lbnl_report_v4.pdf I wouldn't have guessed.
- 8y ago
- vbezhenar 8y agoI have unlimited 300 Mb/s upload and it's nothing unusual in my country (Kazakhstan). I guess it depends on country.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoI gave 200MB/s down and 10MB/s up. I suspect this is more normal. Yes, it depends on country. But I also suspect the total upload bandwidth for typical users in typical locations simply isn't there to make the idea work at scale.
- ticoombs 8y agoThere is already a fix for it. P2P over the I2P network. https://geti2p.net/ https://geti2p.net/
- pletnes 8y agoI’m watching netflix on my chromecast or smart tv. There’s no storage to speak of. I’m guessing that only PCs would be suited for what you’re suggesting, and that very few people watch on PCs.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoFor a company like Netflix, the thing to do there is to make your own such device and then you can put whatever hardware you want in it. I'm actually slightly surprised that nobody at Netflix has already done that. Netflix Steambox would be a thing people would pay money for, and then you don't have Google/Apple/Amazon/Comcast/etc. diverting your customers to their video services because your customers are using their devices. Also notice that you don't need 100% of users to upload. Having 10% of users with a 5:1 ratio still cuts your bandwidth costs in half.