4 ms·
At the last Tesla shareholder meeting five months ago, some investors wanted Musk to give up the chairman post (while remaining CEO of course) but he refused: h
by pavlov 8y ago
At the last Tesla shareholder meeting five months ago, some investors wanted Musk to give up the chairman post (while remaining CEO of course) but he refused:
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.apnews.com/amp/386447de1b8a45f0a8ed8b95224479cf https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.apnews.com/amp/386447de1b8a...
Would have saved $40M cash and billions in shareholder value if he’d taken the hint then. Nobody should think themselves that irreplaceable.
- ec109685 8y agoIf he wasn’t chairman, they couldn’t have taken that away from him in the settlement, so he might have suffered a different punishment.
- threeseed 8y agoThey likely would’ve just pushed for more independent board members. It’s very clear what the SEC has done. Which is send a warning sign that this is Musk’s last chance before he is fired. I don’t think they wanted to punish him any more than that.
- pavlov 8y agoMy train of thought was that Musk probably wouldn’t have ended up tweeting “funding secured” in a situation where he’d be accountable to an external chairman of the board. A bit of governance might have been useful these past months.
- cryptonector 8y agoExactly. It wouldn't have been his place to negotiate, not without chairman approval, and certainly not by himself. There would have been an adult in the room.
- ccorda 8y agoIt wasn't just Elon who turned that down, it was put to a vote and "More than 86 million shares voted against the proposal at a shareholder meeting in June, while fewer than 17 million voted in favor, Tesla said." https://www.reuters.com/article/us-tesla-musk-blackrock/blackrock-voted-to-replace-teslas-musk-with-independent-chairman-idUSKCN1LG01R https://www.reuters.com/article/us-tesla-musk-blackrock/blac...
- pavlov 8y agoIf Musk had come out in favor of the proposal and said: “Yes, it would actually be a good idea to hold Tesla to a higher standard of corporate governance and have someone take on part of my workload, so I’m not going to vote for myself” — do you think he’d be chairman against his will?
- icelancer 8y agoShareholders massively voted that initiative down.
- robertAngst 8y agoStrong disagree. Leadership is key. I dont like Elon's propaganda machine which IMO is what feeds his cult status, but HE is the reason Tesla is a thing. Believe in Him. Tesla as a company has no chance against GM or Ford. Elon has a chance because of what he has accomplished. They say history is events and people. Electric cars are something every company will have in the next decade. What company is going to get an Elon?
- newtisinal 8y ago>Elon's propaganda machine source?
- sfifs 8y ago> say history is events and people. Electric cars are something every company will have in the next That's one view of history - popular in common discourse and historians. Another view of history is that it is largely driven by economics with historical personalities riding on the coat tails of underlying situations with a very few unique genius exceptions (think Newton, Alexander, Ceaser etc). Also remember that most of history has happened when our population has been 1/20th of what it is today - so we are 20x more likely to have interesting characters even if something depends on genius It remains to be seen what Musk will be - I actually feel underlying economic growth, material science development in battery technology and need to tackle pollution especially in Asia would have anyways driven electric vehicles rapidly and indeed I wonder if Musk jumped the gun on battery giga factory since we're just at the beginning of battery science - but time will tell.
- slfnflctd 8y agoThe true heroes - the actual researchers and engineers putting in ridiculously long hours out of pure passion and thereby making the steady stream of breakthroughs necessary to allow new technologies to flourish - rarely get any press or credit. However, there are circus ringleaders (as Elon has been accused of being), and then there are true polymaths who can both competently direct large scale engineering efforts and deal with entirely disparate realms such as corporate governance, marketing and negotiations. He may not have been getting enough sleep lately, but I think he's more the latter than the former. You don't get put in charge of revolutionary payment systems, luxury vehicles, interplanetary transport and energy storage one right after another purely by accident.
- turtlecloud 8y agoMan that guy sounds so smart in retrospect. My props to him as an investor