3 ms·
You can't always deploy your altered versions to your devices. Carriers have been experimenting with various techniques for locking down devices that have been
by wtallis 16y ago
You can't always deploy your altered versions to your devices. Carriers have been experimenting with various techniques for locking down devices that have been rooted in any way, and the only completely unlocked Android phone (Nexus One when sold through Google) was a flop.
If your reply to this is that you can always bypass whatever DRM they put in place: well, you can do that on the iPhone too. And if you're willing to count something as "open" when reverse engineering is required to use modified software, then the availability of source code for a reference implementation ceases to be a meaningful difference. Android is no more "open" than iOS under that definition, just easier to work on.
- biafra 16y agoYou mean: You can't deploy your altered version to any device Assuming you did not break it while altering. Then you can always deploy your altered version to the ADP-Phones. For example the Nexus One. And this is not a theoretical possibility. I have done it. It works. I use it every day since.
- wtallis 16y agoOpen is not the same as "open, if you run it on special developer hardware". The Android platform cannot really be said to be open if none of the consumer products based on it are open.
- biafra 16y agoThe Nexus One is a consumer product. You do not have to be a developer to buy it nor is it special developer hardware. Those other devices are still closed because people still buy them. Vote with your wallets and you will have freedom.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- biafra 16y agoThe easiest way to find one depending on your location might be ebay. There are a lot of new & unused N1s on ebay.de and ebay.com
- kelnos 16y agoSo then by that logic Linux itself isn't open, because manufacturers run it on locked set-top boxes. With a bit of work you can probably get Android to run on commodity hardware.
- calloc 16y agoThose manufacturers are not touting their locked set-top boxes as being an open platform...
- biafra 16y agoI am with you here. The manufacturers should not be allowed to call their phones open if they lock the bootloader so you cannot install unsigned images. But Android as a platform is still open. The same way that Linux is still open.
- kelnos 16y agoAre they? Does HTC, Samsung, etc. actually claim that their phones are "open"? It's Google calling Android open.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]