5 ms·
I don't see this as a "don't help the military" post. This is a post about needing a profession of software engineering. There are, clearly, ethical lines. L
by lifeisstillgood 8y ago
I don't see this as a "don't help the military" post. This is a post about needing a profession of software engineering.
There are, clearly, ethical lines. Leaving aside where the line and the military cross, it is important to think how we will build such a profession - and enforce membership (which is the whole point)
Also worth noting is a common medical ethics quiz: You are a ER doctor, and a college football player comes in, RTA, spine shattered, internal bleeding, conscious and not in pain but needs operation to stem the bleeding.
He clearly and openly states that as he will never walk again, he does not wish to live.
Do you operate?
Most doctors it seems operate, and oddly that is a violation of most ethical board recommendations.
- leetcrew 8y agoif i understand correctly, it would probably be illegal (at least in the US) for a doctor not to operate in that situation. the only circumstance i know of where a doctor can willfully allow a patient to die is when a notarized do not resuscitate order has been filed. even in this situation, they would still probably be obligated to try any other means at their disposal to save the patient.
- zbentley 8y agoI don’t think the point is that there is an obvious right answer, but rather that the existence of formalized (ish) ethics and codes of professional conduct frequently distinguishes the medical profession from software engineering.
- leetcrew 8y agosure, but it seemed worth pointing out that the ethical behavior prescribed by the board is probably illegal. i don't want a formalized code of ethics in my field that might require me to break the law.