2 ms·
> I expect they're working on AI tech But that's exactly the problem. Google already will try to auto-answer some questions that you ask. But the way they do i
by danShumway 8y ago
> I expect they're working on AI tech
But that's exactly the problem. Google already will try to auto-answer some questions that you ask. But the way they do it is completely opaque.
So I have no idea a) when they'll suggest an answer, and b) why they'll suggest an answer.
When I see an answer on DuckDuckGo, it's consistent. I immediately know how much trust to put into it. I don't have to look for the source and try to figure out where it sits on that scale. What's even better is that over time with DuckDuckGo, I get better at phrasing queries in a way that I know an instant answer will pop up. With Google, because they probably already use a bunch of weird AI in the background, I have never been able to predict whether or not a query will pop up a card, so I can't actually rely on getting an answer quickly in advance.
These are tiny things that shave time off of my searches. I often use DuckDuckGo's StackOverflow cards as language references -- to be able to say, "hey, jog my memory with a really quick example of this syntax."[0][1] I want to know details like the source of that answer before I search it.
AI tech will never be as good as having a consistent algorithm for this -- because even if it got to be as good as a person going out and looking up the answers for me, a person is never going to be as good as a consistent algorithm. This is what people don't understand about natural language interpretation -- they think that there's some theoretical end-point where a computer will be as good at interpreting commands as a human is. But they forget that giving a human commands is already slower and less reliable than giving a computer commands. Having a digital assistant be ridged and predictable is a strength, not a weakness.
[0]: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=js+send+a+network+request&t=canonical&ia=qa https://duckduckgo.com/?q=js+send+a+network+request&t=canoni...
[1]: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=stackoverflow+linux+find+filename&t=canonical&ia=qa&iax=qa https://duckduckgo.com/?q=stackoverflow+linux+find+filename&...