3 ms·
The appearance of this is significant. For many years, I was annoyed whenever I saw one of these “hardening” or “securing” guides (for any platform), without k
by teddyh 8y ago
The appearance of this is significant.
For many years, I was annoyed whenever I saw one of these “hardening” or “securing” guides (for any platform), without knowing why. But I eventually figured it out: If you have to do extra steps to your system to “harden” it or otherwise secure it, it is either a toy system not meant for production use, or it is an old system which has ossified and needs hardening because of a lack of upstream updates and maintenance. And it annoyed me because you shouldn’t be running any such systems in production anyway – “hardening” such systems is not tenable in the long run.
The fact that macOS has been neglected by Apple should not be news to anyone (earlier it was especially obvious for the Unix parts, but lately it has been all of it), but this is another sign of it.
- ricardbejarano 8y agoI agree that "secure by default" should be, well, the default. I envy OpenBSD's way of delivering a secure system out-of-the-box, instead of everyone else's "pretty much secure but...".
- matthewmacleod 8y agoYou’re talking nonsense. There have been hardening guides for macOS for ages. Linux too. In reality, security is a sliding scale between “everything is root and there’s no password lmao” and “so secure it’s impossible to actually do anything useful”. Different risk levels are appropriate for different users in different situations. For example, this guide talks about turning off a bunch of features that I use a lot - like continuity and handoff between iOS and macOS. These features might feasibly be a security burden—as in, they might increase the attack area, despite having no known vulnerabilities—but in exchange they improve usability. I can’t reasonably agree that this is some kind of indication of failure. MacOS is a consumer operating system; it seems like the security it offers is generally reasonably optimised for that role.
- ricardbejarano 8y agoI don't think he meant "failure" so much but rather criticise the fact that operating systems sometimes deliver not-the-greatest defaults. To be fair, macOS has a very strong default set, this just takes it the extra mile.
- brilee 8y agoIt's been a truism in security that the less usable you make your systems, the more your users will work around it, thereby defeating the security. E.g. passwords written stickies to defeat password expiration rules. There's a sweet spot for security for the average user, where it's secure but usable enough that the user doesn't attempt to defeat it. For users who are willing to put up with less usable systems, more security can be had.