11 ms·
Solving My Email Problem
- ttul 8y agoThis is know as Challenge-Response and ... it doesn’t work. What happens when an automated system sends you a message? How do you handle the backscatter problem (ie when spammers spoof the sender address causing your helpful challenge messages to be sent to someone random who then complains..). Laudable effort, but it’s not a solution.
- BeetleB 8y agoHard to say something is not a solution when it's been working for over a year. >What happens when an automated system sends you a message? I'm not sure I see the problem. I don't want automated emails in my Inbox. Period. For the few ones that you'd think I want (e.g. overdue notices), they are in my "other" list - those that don't go into either my inbox or my quarantine - so they don't get an autoresponse email. But frankly, there are very few automated emails that I want. As an example, I've set up Zillow alerts that tell me if a house in my neighborhood is on sale, or has been sold. In one sense, I do want these emails, but I simply don't want them in my inbox. They remain quarantined, and I'll see them whenever I check my quarantine pile. Most of the sites I intentionally signed up for because they occasionally will send me something useful - they all still go to my quarantine pile. I don't need them in my inbox intermingling with more important emails. >How do you handle the backscatter problem (ie when spammers spoof the sender address causing your helpful challenge messages to be sent to someone random who then complains..). If the spoofed email is in my whitelist, they don't get an email. If not, what exactly is the problem? That some random stranger got an email from me? That's just spam for them - I doubt they'll even notice. At best, they may realize someone is using their email address as a From in a spam email. At least in the 1+ year of running this, none of these has been problems.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rakoo 8y agoFunnily you've kinda inverted the mailboxes purpose: your real inbox is called "quarantine", and your actual emails are in your "inbox". Sounds like you could use inbox as inbox and then "archive" when it passes validation. Anyway if it works for you _and_ is simple to put in place and use (as you've shown), then kudos to you!
- amaccuish 8y ago> "In a spammer’s economic model, spending even five or 10 seconds per message could be prohibitively expensive" So, how about a proof of work system like blockchains? Like, if you've never sent me email before, my server returns some work to complete. If I've ever sent you an email, or not marked you mail as spam etc, your MTA won't be challenged etc.
- lgeorget 8y agoOn my own domain where I've set up a mail server, I've never received that much spam. I have the impression that people are more civilized now than in the late 2000s with respect to emails. In my case at least, unsubscribe links work reasonably well.
- cm2187 8y agoThe risk is some dodgy website (small shop, forum, etc) that has been pwned and which leaks your detail to spammers, not so much the company you give the email to.
- altharaz 8y agoIn France we have a software vendor called MailInBlack. Their solution is exactly the one proposed in this article, where the sender has to solve a “challenge” to get in your mailbox. If I think this approach is really effective, it also creates a huge pain for a lot of tools relying on emails such as WebEx invites or when you want to contact someone for sales. As a result I think that this approach might be better if it was for instance triggered only on emails with an “Unsubscribe” link, or on emails with specific keywords.
- getpost 8y agoThis is super-annoying for legitimate, infrequent correspondents. Somebody asks me to email them something, and I need to take the time to notice and read the automated response, click to access an unknown website, and then try to solve the captcha, which sometimes requires multiple attempts. You asked for my recipe, don't hassle me when I'm trying to help you.
- BeetleB 8y agoWhen I set it up, I knew it could be annoying, which is why I automatically whitelisted everyone I knew. I was seriously concerned people would rather just not be able to send me emails and will willfully ignore my emails, but as I pointed out, that's the exception rather than the rule. And I am proactive. If I see an email in the quarantine folder from someone I want to be on the whitelist, I press a button and he's in. This isn't a hard line, binary, black and white situation. I can and do place people in the whitelist. If I've requested something from someone, I don't expect them to respond to the email, and I usually reply back to them with an apology about the email. So far, no one has complained. And I don't use captchas. There's no need for them. All they have to do is click on the link and type in their email address.
- dalai 8y agoIf you still check the quarantine folder once a week, do you even need the challenge email? At most it will take a few days longer to reply to a valid email and then you can whitelist the sender.
- alexkavon 8y agoThis also only works until it’s a popular method and spammers automate a solution.
- ktosobcy 8y agoAm I so weird that I don't have problem with my e-mail box? I don't receive spam (gmail, but recently all mail providers got really great at it and even if I do receive some spam is quite sporadic). I don't receive newsletters because (shock!) I don't sign-up for them (and even if I do once every blue moon I immediately click 'unsubscribe'). Yes, there is some small problem of having older messages "waiting for the right time" but this is not the problem of the e-mail itself but rather mental block to dedicate 1-3h to write response (you would spend same amount of time writing regular mail).
- oooglaaa 8y agoYou’re not the only one! I unsubscribed from mostly everything and now my inbox gets anywhere from 1 to 2 new spam messages per week. Still annoying when it does happen, but a big improvement from before when I was getting 40+ emails per day, in which most were newsletters I never opened or just spam
- BeetleB 8y ago>I unsubscribed from mostly everything and now my inbox gets anywhere from 1 to 2 new spam messages per week. That would only work for a while for me. 6 months later new stuff has crept in and I would have to go through another round of unsubscribing.
- oooglaaa 8y agoIf you unsubscribe every time you see a new e-mail that you’re not interested in it’ll help keep it in check. For spammers who don’t respect unsubscribes and you’re using Gmail, you can create a filter which immediately trashes the message based on the “from” address
- BeetleB 8y ago>If you unsubscribe every time you see a new e-mail that you’re not interested in it’ll help keep it in check. That statement gets to the crux of the whole situation. Why should I spend time tending an inbox, continually scanning for the unsubscribe link in any new email I receive? The sender put in almost no effort to send me that email, whereas I the recipient have to expend time getting off their list. I don't want to do that for the rest of my life. I'd rather just remove that email from my whitelist (one keystroke). >For spammers who don’t respect unsubscribes and you’re using Gmail, you can create a filter which immediately trashes the message based on the “from” address Same problem as above. I tried it and in the end found maintaining a blacklist (which is what you're essentially suggesting) burdensome. It's continual work for the rest of my life adding people to a blacklist. I inverted the whole thing. Let the sender work to get on my whitelist.
- teddyh 8y ago> 2. Spamassassin. This worked for many years, but then a few years ago, the accuracy went down like crazy. I switched to Rspamd and haven’t looked back. It’s much better.
- amaccuish 8y agoThis. And it has a nice webui.
- megous 8y agoBogofilter also works quite well if you have enough training material.
- teddyh 8y agoSure, but bogofilter has no pre-made rules, so it makes a bad first impression, and it’s tricky (as in, I wouldn’t know offhand how to do it) to implement site-wide. Rspamd wins on both these points (in fact, its pre-made rules are subjectively better than those of SpamAssassin), and it still has bayesian learning.
- megous 8y agoTrue. I use bogofilter locally just for myself, and I had a set of ~100k ham and spam e-mails for initial training. For single user mail folder/server and local use, it's very simple to set up, compared to anything server side. You basically use 3 commands after initial training and don't need to worry about anything else. I don't want to keep an e-mail archive server side (I use pop3), and that would include a spam filter's database, there are not many other filtering options with that requirements. Anyway, I agree it would not make a good first impression without training data, at all. Though if you train it with what you actually receive, it's quite awesome. I get > 99% accuracy for both false positives/negatives. It's good to keep spam for training.
- self 8y ago> The whole thing probably took a few hours to write. Did you know about TMDA before you wrote it? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tagged_Message_Delivery_Agent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tagged_Message_Delivery_Agent
- BeetleB 8y agoI think someone (you?) told me about this, but I couldn't remember the name and it's hard to construct a search query to find it. Also, almost all their links (Documentation, etc) are not working - I think they're having server issues.
- cm2187 8y agoMy solution is to have my own domain, and a little tool to create and delete email aliases. When a company asks for my email, I just give them a new unique alias. I receive spam on this alias, 1) I know who leaked, 2) I delete the alias, stopping the spam. It is transparent to my correspondents (I can reply from the alias), cuts the spam pretty much to zero, and is low maintenance. It also has a small security benefit: even if I were to share a password between websites (which I rarely do), the login (email, or login part of the email) would be different/non guessable.
- 333c 8y agoI do something similar, except rather than creating aliases, I just have a catchall that sends everything to my inbox. Then, if one address starts receiving spam, I create a rule to move all emails sent to that address to spam. As far as responding from aliases, I haven't figured out a way to do that in my mail client (Mail.app), though I am able to accomplish it in my provider's web interface.
- laurentb 8y agoI'm doing something similar with an Office 365 business essentials subscription (~$5/month) my main email address only has the most important stuff while everything else I setup a shared mailbox for. then every shared mailboxes forwards anything received to an office 365 group called Catchall which i have available on the main address and i just need to switch mailboxes if I want to reply from it (you should be able to do this through mail.app afaik). this allows me tighter control on a case by case basis and I get all the benefits of Office365 business.
- BeetleB 8y agoThis was my first idea, scaled up a bit. I wanted a unique email address per person - not just for when I sign up. This way if someone harvested my email address through someone else, I could just delete the alias and give that person a new alias. Way too much maintenance. This solution is easier.
- Pxtl 8y agoGmail has this capability built in because you can just add +whatever to the end of the name and it's an alias to your email account, and you can block the yourname+whatever@gmail.com it as needed. Only problem is many sites mistakenly think + is an invalid char. No overhead of creating addresses, you have an infinite address space for your account to play with freely. More mail providers should offer such a workflow.
- kwhitefoot 8y agoI have used Hotmail for many years and I really don't get much spam. Most of the junk that I do get ends up in the junk folder, essentially anything that doesn't come from someone in my address book as far as I can see. I check my junk folder whenever I expect someone new to send an email to me or about once a week.
- checkyoursudo 8y agoI have had a hotmail account since almost the beginning. Spam hasn't been a serious problem for me in a long time, though occasionally I get a large amount. I've always gotten more spam in Hotmail than in Gmail (not a lot more). But I've had more false positives in Gmail than in Hotmail. Always seems like there's a tradeoff.
- mhjas 8y agoThankfully I don't use e-mail much anymore. Slowly but surely all of my communication have shifted to better, but unfortunately proprietary, systems. As authentication gets more universal this will continue to happen.
- addicted 8y agoSame here. I don’t have an email problem anymore. I have a WhatsApp, Slack, Facebook Messenger, SMS, and Skype problem now.
- lostlogin 8y agoApp spam. It gets annoying working out which app suits the message. A bit “old man shakes fist at sky” but having masses of communication methods increases the noise for me too.
- Pxtl 8y agoI just wish we'd have OS level contact management and app integration for this, like a shell for messaging. "Jeff is contacting you" over what? I don't care, I have a message from Jeff, and I can respond to Jeff over any protocol I choose, and the shell will show me a unified history of my IMs, chats, phonecalls, SMSes, Deathmatches, emails, chess moves, teledildonics sessions, whatever with Jeff.
- mhjas 8y agoNokia N9 sort of had that. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PBWRdtC9Cn8&feature=youtu.be&t=7 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PBWRdtC9Cn8&feature=youtu.be...
- xur17 8y agoThat was my favorite feature about the n900 (predecessor to n9) - sms, skype, hangouts, whatever? They were all accessible in one place in a merged thread. Really enjoyed it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nicwolff 8y agoI did this with procmail 20 years ago: http://angel.net/~nic/spam-x/procmailrc.txt http://angel.net/~nic/spam-x/procmailrc.txt – and then stopped because lots of spam comes with random people's real e-mail addresses as the From, and my challenge autoreplies were quite rightly being reported as spam by their innocent recipients. Now I just use FastMail and let their excellent Bayesian filtering do its job. (Oh, and I filter all mail with "unsubscribe" in the body into a "Bulk Mail" folder".)
- Operyl 8y agoMmm. I have transactional emails in my boxes that still have unsubscribe in the body.
- JimDabell 8y agoBetween then and now, that problem was solved – you send autoreplies to the Return-Path header, which is protected by SPF.
- dredmorbius 8y agoSMTP-time rejection, with a mechanism for specifying workaround ... doesn't exist, but if it did could address this failure mode of challenge-response.
- rakoo 8y agoIt kinda does, it's called greylisting and already works today: the recipient basically says "can't right now, please come back later". A spammer will not bother even reading this and will hit other targets. A proper smtp sender that dutifully respects the specs (the legit ones do) will try again up until a few days later, where the recipient can whitelist the sender. It's all automatic so it kind of doesn't solve OP's issue, but I feel like there should be a proper way to handle the challenge-response part.
- dredmorbius 8y agoGreylisting (e.g., greymilter) has long existed, but lacks a strong and reliable notification / remedy mechanism. It seems reasonably effective and non-noxious.
- arkaine 8y agoMailinblack does this for more than ten years now, mostly in France. This technique is called a "challenge-response" filtering. It does work pretty well with other antispam techniques. Their solution send a daily digest to the user (x per day) of quarantined emails, allowing them to liberate legitimate emails of lazy senders who do not respond to the challenge-response email. They also use outgoing emails from users to populate their personal whitelist. Their site is not shinny but the product does the job. https://www.mailinblack.com/en/ https://www.mailinblack.com/en/
- altharaz 8y agoFrom my experience, it seems that the daily digest is not enough :). And they still seem to blacklist WebEx invitations, which is really weird as it is definitely a "standard" in web-conferences.
- lxmorj 8y agoWhat tool do you use for this?
- antirez 8y agoNot sure how spam is the problem. Mostly solved by good filters. The problem is the amount of legitimate personal emails that one gets, creating the TODO list problem Paul Graham was talking about in his quote at the top of the blog post here.
- spac 8y agoThis is exactly the problem: Some emails you can’t respond because they require taking actions, so they stay in the inbox to remind you. And then it’s the broken window principle... one cool thing I recently found is that on Trello you can have board specific addresses that create a new card when an email is sent to them. This allows me to move the TODO problem outside the inbox.
- GnarfGnarf 8y agoCongratulations. He just re-invented SpamArrest.
- 0898 8y agoYep – this is exactly how SpamArrest works.
- z3t4 8y agoOnly problem this wont work for any automated e-mail. But you could white-list countries where sending spam is illegal.
- xte 8y agoMy personal mail solution is composed of: - a good taxonomy on a maildir in my home and on my IMAP (thanks mbsync+cron+a small script to watch inbox with IMAP Idle) - a good automatic filtering/refiling (imapfilter, for now) - a good spam blocker (spamassassin) - a good MUA which support both physical taxonomy and a search-based one The workflow it's roughly simple: I have some saved search in notmuch-emacs mostly 'unread', 'important', 'inbox', 'live', 'todo'. When I have little or no time I look only at unread+important, when I have time I go through the rest of unread. Live stuff are thing in progress that I have to watch but no action or todo, todo are...todo's...
- wodenokoto 8y agoThe thing is, I use my inbox for receipts of purchases, confirmations of online accounts and all sorts of other stuff where I am interacting with, or storing information from an automated agent.
- BeetleB 8y ago>The thing is, I use my inbox for receipts of purchases, Stuff like Amazon.com emails are whitelisted. They go into the "low priority" folder, not my inbox. For one-off vendors, I simply "save" their emails without adding them to the whitelist. It's easier to understand if you've used notmuch. I simply remove the quarantine tag from them and they're stored in the email database. One keystroke. I'm not any different from you. If I purchase anything on the Internet and get a confirmation email, I aim to keep it. I still check the quarantine folder from time to time. >confirmations of online accounts I'm not sure I see the problem. I still can see the quarantined emails. If I'm expecting such an email, I check it within a few minutes. I click on the link to confirm my email address - I merely do not add the sender to the whitelist. >all sorts of other stuff where I am interacting with, or storing information from an automated agent. An example would help. Some use cases from me: - Calendar reminder emails - Whitelisted: They go to the low priority folder (as counterintuitive as the phrase sounds). They do not go into my inbox. - Library overdue emails - same as above - Emails from my medical provider (e.g. "new test results") - same as above If you get automated emails for which you have automated actions, those can go right into the Python script and handled before they are quarantined.
- wodenokoto 8y ago> I'm not sure I see the problem. I still can see the quarantined emails. I completely misunderstood that the quarantine is just a folder next to the inbox. It's the obvious solution, from both a technical and usability point of view, and takes care of all my points. Thanks for clearing it up.
- niftylettuce 8y agoI think I'm going to add this approach to https://forwardemail.net https://forwardemail.net when I implement the DNSBL.
- masukomi 8y agoE-mail is currently useless for me. people have been talking about going through and unsubscribing from things. NOT counting the spam folder i have 52,541 unread emails. I am not going through all of that to click a bajillion unsubscribes considering i never actually chose to receive email from 99% of the people / companies sending me email. I'd forgotten about the whitelist strategy. I'd written it off as obnoxious to the sender, but as i am reminded of this years later i'm thinking it's more obnoxious for me to never respond to people, partially because i miss their emails, and partially i don't bother looking most of the time because there's too damn much to deal with.
- CogitoCogito 8y agoMark all old mail read and start over today? Just unsubscribe going forward.
- masukomi 8y agothe strategy of continuing to unsubscribe from things is based on the flawed idea that i want to opt-in to an ongoing maintenance task for the rest of my life. I do not. We shouldn't just _accept_ the idea that other people / companies can assign us ongoing unpaid work for the rest of our lives.
- BeetleB 8y ago>We shouldn't just _accept_ the idea that other people / companies can assign us ongoing unpaid work for the rest of our lives. This is exactly my perspective as well - I even said in another comment "I don't want to do this for the rest of my life". Reading the comments, it is clear not everyone has assigned the same roles to email as I have (which is understandable). For some people, opt in as a default seems to be acceptable. I don't know - perhaps because I had email for some years without getting all these emails, I may simply have a different reference point than many who grew up at a time when communicating individually over email was the rare use case (as opposed to being notified of sales, meetings, etc). (Note: Definitely not complaining or being sarcastic here - to each their own).
- nickjj 8y agoMy inbox is at 0 and other than gmail's auto-filtering tabs I don't have too much extra filtering going on (most of it is related to Google Alerts). For the last 20 years my rule has been "If I check my email and inbox > 1 then deal with the email right now". I usually check my email every few hours. I'm not Mr. popular, but I'm also not anonymous. I do personal support for 30,000+ people who have taken one of my online courses so I get a fair amount of email and other things. I tend to write massive responses from scratch for a lot of them as well. The key is not to let it build up. Then you'll have 99 problems but email won't be one of them. Also I'm not sure if this is related but I'm one of those people who think it's unthinkably rude to ignore someone. I would never in a million years read an email and not respond to it (unless it clearly wasn't meant to be responded to). Likewise, if I see a > 1 inbox I feel compelled to handle it ASAP because I don't want to keep that person waiting. (Of course there's exceptions, like I'm not responding to pure spam, but I do get about 50 emails a week where people ask to post a guest post on my blog and I always manually respond nicely to them with a "no thanks but good luck" type of message along with some context around their niche).
- glitchc 8y agoThis is a wonderful, but unfortunately very naive, approach to email. That you firmly believe this approach just means you haven't worked in a govt. dept. or any kind of position where your response represents the response of the organization (or a sub-set thereof). In such circumstances, emails that are open-ended (responses risk being misunderstood), ambiguously phrased (responses will be twisted to server the author's needs) or controversial (any response paints the organization in a negative light) are often best ignored. If your question is ambiguous, a busy boss or colleague does not owe you an answer or vice versa. Sometimes people respond out of anger or frustration. You could respond in kind, and escalate the battle, or simply wait and let the individual calm down. Not responding is a very useful technique when conflicts arise between team members or in the management chain. I would rather ignore an angry abusive email from an upset colleague who is having a rough time in life, than respond in kind and escalate it into an HR battle. Of course if the behaviour continues, there would be no choice, but most people are rather contrite and apologetic after a brief outburst and it's much better for everyone to just pretend that it never happened. People make mistakes after all.
- r3vrse 8y agoUnfortunately, in the Enterprise space, this setup is likely to be a zero sum game, as the challenge email would get dinged 90% of the time for spammy wording like "quarantine" and links to unknown domains (and/or blocked entirely, because inbound filtering != outbound filtering). Large-scale email in its current form sucks, even with the Office 365 ATP tools or similar equivalents.
- nulbyte 8y agoThis is interesting. I was initially tempted to replicate something similar to try it, but then took a moment to think about what my real gripes with email actually are. Then I went to work on solving them, one by one. First, I have a tendency to keep emails in my inbox as well, thinking I will do something with them at some point. I can't say I've ever waited a year to respond; however, I have probably waited several months before deleting (archiving, since I use Gmail) an email. This often comes after realizing that I am not, despite my earlier assessment, going to do anything about this particular email. Second, the endless notifications are abhorrent. Today, I finally got around to adding some little used account information into my KeePass database and archived two emails. Then I realized I wasn't going to do anything with the other 20 emails in my inbox, so I archived them, too. Then I turned off notifications on my phone. I turned off Outlook's toaster at work years ago after I was frustrated with the amount of useless junk my colleagues or other work groups keep sending me. Unable to remove myself, I just decided to deal with the junk and all the other emails I get on my time, not anyone else's. I took that practice to my personal accounts, after deciding that if I won't waste my time even when I'm getting paid, I should definitely not waste my time when I'm not. Now if I could only talk my employer into letting me disable my email account when I go on vacation, a la Daimler: http://time.com/3116424/daimler-vacation-email-out-of-office/ http://time.com/3116424/daimler-vacation-email-out-of-office....
- napsterbr 8y agoAh, like many people, I'm also one of those who let thousands of messages build up and respond them maybe a year after they were sent. But my reason for such slow response, I believe, is a little bit different than most. I have social anxiety, and reading email is extremely painful to me. Not replying, but reading. I almost never open my inbox. The last email I sent was six months ago. Sigh. Anyone with similar issues?
- ryuushen 8y agoAhhh, don't I ever. Too scared to have an engage with most online communities, let alone e-mails directed at me. I probably won't read any replies but I wanted to enjoy this brief connection with someone with a similar experience.
- danaliv 8y agoI just want to be able to classify email by “sent by a human” and “not sent by a human.” My inbox isn’t a (bad) todo list, it’s a (bad) notification center.
- fdavison 8y agoI filter anything with the word "unsubscribe" into a separate folder, then add a few filters to handle the exceptions. What is generally left in my inbox is stuff directly mailed to me that deserves attention. 90% of the stuff in the unsubscribe folder get deleted without looking beyond the subject line.
- kardos 8y agoSo your system automatically sends back messages to the non-whitelisted addresses. Those messages will eventually be classified as spam by big operators such as gmail. How do you prevent that from reducing your "email reputation" and ending up on spam email blacklists?
- BeetleB 8y agoTo be frank, this is a concern to me, and I think I'm already on some spam lists. Recently two folks using Gmail told me my (regular, written by me) email showed up in their Junk folder. I checked others who use Gmail and it showed up fine for them. I may end up using a separate domain for those emails. I'm pretty sure that's a weak solution.
- kardos 8y agoHmmmmm, the spam list downside is a non starter for me. It sounds like you've invented a captcha for email. If that ever took off and became widely used, it would be rather easy for the spammers to write a script to comply with the scheme. Followed of course by the usual escalation to adding an image-based captcha, and then efforts to beat the captcha, and so on. As an aside, you could do it entirely in email as well by sending a response that requires a specific reply to join the whitelist. That is you could eliminate the webserver and the mildly-questionable-looking URL.
- m-p-3 8y agoGoogle Inbox was a nice way of setting up emails as tasks, but unfortunately Google is killing it, and Gmail doesn't come close to it. I use Google Tasks as a workaround (link a task to an email conversation) but it's still clunkier than Inbox.
- hzhou321 8y agoI use my own simple email scripts with simple rules and it also works! Over the time, my system has become even simpler. I used to have Procmail as mda, now simply a 5 line Perl script. I used to have spamassissin as pre-filter, now I skipped it altogether. I used to have a database for whitelists, blacklists, and filter lists. Now I simply have hand-coded rules (several) and hand edited whitelist/inbox lists. There are three areas for my emails: inbox (as well as a dozen categorized ones, important boxes also sends notification to my phone), unsorted (handful every day), and spam box (hundreds every day). I do check my unsorted box about daily; I only grep my spam box if I am expecting something and something didn't come. Every time I got a spam leaked (into unsorted) and I am annoyed or I want certain mail go to certain inbox, I simply edit my scripts (which I know exactly where and how). It is easier than -- e.g. -- reading procmail's man page. Specific, simple, personalized approach is surprisingly effective than any generalized approach. The latter is a hard problem, but the former often isn't. The former I can choose my own compromises.
- purplezooey 8y agoAny mutt users tried notmuch? Is it any good? Only for emacs users? :)
- dredmorbius 8y agoA Challenging Response to Challenge-Response MAY 19, 2003 BY ED FELTEN https://freedom-to-tinker.com/2003/05/19/challenging-response-challenge-response/ https://freedom-to-tinker.com/2003/05/19/challenging-respons...
- BeetleB 8y agoGiven that it was written in 2003, and here we are 15 years later with CR working, I don't see much value to the post. The author there is hypothesizing, whereas in reality we have functioning CR systems. Now I'll grant there is a critical mass beyond which CR won't work. Looking at the comments here, the likelihood of hitting that critical mass is almost zero. Most people don't like the idea. So CR will continue to work.
- dredmorbius 8y agoC-R has been very thinly used.
- akho 8y agoWhat I’d love to see is an email-like system where each message is accompanied by a small sum of money (1¢ or so). If the message is not useful to the recipient, they are free to take the 1¢, otherwise, if the message is useful, they wouldn’t (and it will return to the sender either when the email is replied to, or, say, in a week). This would very quickly kill all spam-type business models, and would be unlikely to cost anything for legitimate users.
- JeanMarcS 8y agoI’ve made something like that 15 years ago. It didn’t worked. People receiving the quarantine mails often misunderstood it or dismissed it without reading it. We tried with CAPTCHA, without, nothing worked. Our users had to spend a lot of time checking for false positives. In the end we gave up. Oh, and if you want to do something like that, add a reasonable delay for your response as some Spam list check for automatic responses and consider them as SPAM and will ironically block you for that ! Been there...
- jscholes 8y ago> No - I check the quarantine folder regularly - usually daily. So what's the point? The whole exercise is intended to cut down on looking through non-personal./junk email, but you have to look through non-personal/junk email daily anyway.