3 ms·
A really underrated feature of DuckDuckGo is the number/quality of search cards[0]. A lot of Google's search cards just kind of pull from whatever the top resul
by danShumway 8y ago
A really underrated feature of DuckDuckGo is the number/quality of search cards[0]. A lot of Google's search cards just kind of pull from whatever the top result is -- but DuckDuckGo's all have specific algorithms which makes them more predictable.
With Google, I have to take an extra second to think about why they're showing an answer at the top. But if DuckDuckGo inlines an answer from StackOverflow, I know what the algorithm is --> Get top-rated StackOverflow result, get highest rated answer, inline the first X paragraphs, give a button to expand.
I still occasionally use !g for some searches if I strike out finding answers on DuckDuckGo, but I'm at the point where I generally prefer DuckDuckGo's answers. It's really tough to explain what's different about them, it feels like DuckDuckGo has a different "style" of search results or something. Even when I'm using Google, I usually have DuckDuckGo open next to it, because Google and DuckDuckGo feel like they cover different ground.
It's just that by default, the ground that DuckDuckGo is covering feels more relevant for just very quickly getting information and then getting out (especially with the better search cards).
[0]: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=javascript+char+codes&t=canonical&ia=answer&iax=answer https://duckduckgo.com/?q=javascript+char+codes&t=canonical&...
- londons_explore 8y ago> I know what the algorithm is --> Get top-rated StackOverflow result, get highest rated answer, inline the first X paragraphs, give a button to expand. Google couldn't do that due to past court decisions about the maximum they can show being 'snippet length' without getting further into disputed copyright territory. I expect they're working on AI tech which can read the whole web and directly answer your questions rather than having to use an extract of a webpage at all.
- mycall 8y ago> I expect they're working on AI tech which can read the whole web and directly answer your questions rather than having to use an extract of a webpage at all. GDELT
- danShumway 8y ago> I expect they're working on AI tech But that's exactly the problem. Google already will try to auto-answer some questions that you ask. But the way they do it is completely opaque. So I have no idea a) when they'll suggest an answer, and b) why they'll suggest an answer. When I see an answer on DuckDuckGo, it's consistent. I immediately know how much trust to put into it. I don't have to look for the source and try to figure out where it sits on that scale. What's even better is that over time with DuckDuckGo, I get better at phrasing queries in a way that I know an instant answer will pop up. With Google, because they probably already use a bunch of weird AI in the background, I have never been able to predict whether or not a query will pop up a card, so I can't actually rely on getting an answer quickly in advance. These are tiny things that shave time off of my searches. I often use DuckDuckGo's StackOverflow cards as language references -- to be able to say, "hey, jog my memory with a really quick example of this syntax."[0][1] I want to know details like the source of that answer before I search it. AI tech will never be as good as having a consistent algorithm for this -- because even if it got to be as good as a person going out and looking up the answers for me, a person is never going to be as good as a consistent algorithm. This is what people don't understand about natural language interpretation -- they think that there's some theoretical end-point where a computer will be as good at interpreting commands as a human is. But they forget that giving a human commands is already slower and less reliable than giving a computer commands. Having a digital assistant be ridged and predictable is a strength, not a weakness. [0]: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=js+send+a+network+request&t=canonical&ia=qa https://duckduckgo.com/?q=js+send+a+network+request&t=canoni... [1]: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=stackoverflow+linux+find+filename&t=canonical&ia=qa&iax=qa https://duckduckgo.com/?q=stackoverflow+linux+find+filename&...
- gpm 8y agoI've also found that DuckDuckGo's search cards are just more reliably correct. An example I ran into a few days ago: As it turns out there are two "Brent Lee's" in music. This one [0] and this one [1]. If you search Brent Lee on duckduckgo you get the first in the card. If you search Brent Lee on google you get a card that appears to be about one person but includes a mix of information about the first and the second. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brent_Lee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brent_Lee [1] http://www.brentleemusic.com/ http://www.brentleemusic.com/