3 ms·
Between this crap, and forcing wifi vendors to lock everything down, effectively killing legitimate homebrew, fuck the FCC.
by tracker1 8y ago
Between this crap, and forcing wifi vendors to lock everything down, effectively killing legitimate homebrew, fuck the FCC.
- themodelplumber 8y agoAs a ham radio operator: It is frustrating to see the FCC do stuff like this. https://medium.com/@lucky225/fcc-back-peddles-all-transceivers-capable-of-transmitting-on-frequencies-that-require-40377a3722c5 https://medium.com/@lucky225/fcc-back-peddles-all-transceive... Why not just stop and think about things for a while, as opposed to running around making these executive decisions and annoying people like homebrew operators? Holy smokes. And why not go through back channels, drop some truth bombs on whoever the really big offenders are, rather than scooping up all possible babies to throw out with the bathwater? (Still, I heard from a Russian today that he'd be arrested for taking an HT to the park even just to listen to whatever's on the air. So it's all in perspective, but homebrew is huge for innovation.)
- nerdponx 8y agoIs there any legitimate reason for this rule?
- themodelplumber 8y agoThe major part of it is about controlling what happens on the bands. Which to a degree is a useful function, because the FCC is useful as a sort of arbiter between various users of those bands. Commercial, public sector, amateur, etc. However, the recent explosion in popularity of "transmit on whatever band you please, right out of the box" radios has created a lot of opportunities for idiots to cause limited havoc on one end, and for the FCC to apparently extrapolate that to "omg unlimited havoc" on the other. We'll see how it goes, but there is clearly a lot of B&W (i.e. uneducated or just non-analytical) thinking on the matter currently.
- VLM 8y ago"legitimate homebrew" There's no agreement on what that means in the sense that there's at least one (very old) cultural group that sees it as buying a small pile of generic components and soldering them together by hand on a workbench into a working system of ones own custom design, and a somewhat more recent interpretation that it means buying a commercial product marketed for one group, then because its technologically possible sometimes, using that commercial product for a different marketing group without the support of the manufacturer. Needless to say both sides can't communicate, not even having common terms to discuss. And throw in the FCC which has extensive regulatory support only for the first definition for many decades and has generally opposed the latter definition, its absolute chaos.
- Lucky225 8y agoCouldn't have said it better, but even taking this into account the FCC still would say the former definition would be illegal if the radio is 'capable' of transmitting outside the ham bands. Even a crystal based radio is capable of transmitting outside the ham bands by simply swapping the crystal.