2 ms·
For those who don't understand the Black-Scholes references, here is a quick explanation. What Black and Scholes proved in their famous paper is that if you st
by btilly 16y ago
For those who don't understand the Black-Scholes references, here is a quick explanation.
What Black and Scholes proved in their famous paper is that if you start with a portfolio containing a certain fraction of money and stock, and rebalance the portfolio constantly as the stock price moves according to certain rules, then after a fixed amount of fluctuation in the stock price you will be left with either pure stock or pure money, depending on the eventual price of the stock. In short, this portfolio acts exactly like an option. And therefore the price of an option should match the price of the portfolio. If it doesn't match, then you can buy one and sell the other to get free money until they do match.
This is fine, but in the real world we trade options based on a fixed period of time, not a fixed amount of variation in the stock. The answer to this which finance uses is to estimate the volatility of the stock. Given known volatility, and a known time period, you can tell how much variation there is, and then use the Black-Scholes model to price options.
Mandelbrot's critique of this is that volatility itself is not constant. Therefore you can't really predict when the Black-Scholes portfolio will expire. In particular the model systemically underestimates the likelihood of extreme events. When this catches all of finance off guard, the result is frequently some sort of crisis.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]