5 ms·
Something that's completely socially unacceptable to say: The real thing that put Hitler in power to begin with was the horrendous war reparations Germany was
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
Something that's completely socially unacceptable to say:
The real thing that put Hitler in power to begin with was the horrendous war reparations Germany was saddled with from WW1 because it was "last man standing" on the losing side. You get called a Nazi sympathizer and things like that for trying to provide that context, but to my mind that is the real reason they said "Never again" and instituted global protections for financial stuff at the end of WW2.
People seem to forget the entire world was suffering through a depression prior to WW2 and most wars are, at their root, motivated by resource limitations.
- stordoff 8y ago> The real thing that put Hitler in power to begin with was the horrendous war reparations Germany was saddled with from WW1 because it was "last man standing" on the losing side I'm not sure why this is socially unacceptable - I thought it was widely accepted that Hitler rode the economic woes into office, and used them to blame the Jews (amongst others). Now, if you start using that to justify what the Nazi party did, I can see why you might be called a Nazi sympathiser, but I don't see why that statement on its own is particularly controversial (if perhaps only presenting one factor). The question does remain though - would the Great Depression on its own (without reparations), or had Germany been in a better economy situation, been sufficient to result in Hitler's rise to power?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoMy mother is German. She once said to me something like "Hitler was doing good things for the country -- until he went nuts." I brought that up on a forum. It isn't justification for Nazi atrocities. It is insight into how the people on the ground suffering hardship saw him in his early years. He was perceived to be a good leader doing good things for the people, at least at first. But, hey, my previous comment is already deep in the negatives, so I'm guessing HN won't be much more reasonable than Reddit was when I tried to make that point. People also seem to forget that the entire point of Milgram's experiments was to prove that something like that absolutely could not happen in the US. The theory was that there was something peculiar to the German people. His experiments proved the exact opposite, which was quite shocking at the time and likely part of why they are so very well known, though most people appear oblivious to the origin story.
- mikeash 8y agoThere is a massive difference between saying that the treatment of Germany after WWI set the stage for Hitler, and saying that Hitler did good things for Germany until he went nuts. The former will find wide agreement, while the latter is just apology for Nazis, who were evil from the start, and just took a while to really ramp it up.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoNo, it is not apology for Nazis. FYI: My initial comment was well into the negatives for a time. A lot of people simply cannot look objectively at anything related to WW2. They know how it ultimately turned out, so they basically ret-con it as "they were pure evil from the start." The problem is such mental models foster convenient explanations and justifications, not solutions for making sure such things don't happen again.
- olivermarks 8y agoMost people's perception of WWII has devolved into 1950's type Hollywood western 'white hat' 'black hat', good versus evil story telling with little understanding of substance. Presumably this is because the generations that experienced it have died or are too senile to discuss it publicly these days. We will never learn
- DoreenMichele 8y agoFollowing WW2, an awful lot of our fictional villains were German. That's changed relatively recently. Germans were the "trope" evil bad guy. WW2 is actually even inspiration for, say, Star Wars. Darth Vader and his troops are something of a cross between Japanese samurai uniforms and WW2 German uniforms. It's so deeply embedded, we don't even notice the connection. We don't question where those images come from. We just accept it as "Yup. Totes The Bad Guy! Looks Bad to me!"
- mannykannot 8y agoThere's a rather awkward question about when one thinks Hitler went nuts. To think the early years of the Nazi regime were acceptable requires overlooking the thuggery they used to get power in the first place, the brutal (and not secret) things they were doing to 'undesirables' already, and what Hitler had revealed of himself in 'Mein Kampf'. On the other hand, I agree that no nation or ethnic group can assume itself intrinsically immune to such things.
- Sag0Sag0 8y agoWhat do you mean horrendous war reparations? Germany remained independent, lost barely any territory and were allowed to delay paying war reparations. Germany's other allies were far worse of losing far more territory and descending into anarchy all the way up to the second world war. Hitler got into power because of the great depression and the German populations attraction at the time to authoritarian nationalist political party's not because Germany's war reparations were so horrendous.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI'm finding myself at a loss for how to engage your remark. I don't think I'm wrong, but it possibly isn't phrased that well. In a nutshell, the seeds of WW2 were planted in WW1. This is a longstanding human tradition and is in part related to the historical practice of extracting war reparations, but there was other stuff as well that wouldn't, strictly speaking, be classified that way, yet still had a negative impact. I've read a fair amount of history. I was a history major for a time. My ex was career military and particularly interested in military history and had an extensive book collection. We sometimes looked up the actual battles while watching movies. The American Civil War is notable for being singular and not the beginning of a series of civil wars. Grant was an alcoholic and ne'er-do-well and this has been credited with his unprecedented choice to set very merciful terms of surrender. Not only were war reparations not extracted, he insisted that the South accept help for rebuilding. This has been credited with being the roots of similar tactics post WW2 where America occupied and helped rebuild both Japan and Germany. I hope that's a little clearer. I don't know that it is. I have a raging headache.
- jsiepkes 8y ago> The real thing that put Hitler in power to begin with was the horrendous war reparations Germany was saddled with from WW1 because it was "last man standing" on the losing side. I live in the Netherlands and I remember being thought that in school as one of the reasons of Hitlers rise to power. The Dutch wikipage [1] of the Versailles treaty also reflects this in a section called "consequences of the treaty" (De gevolgen van het verdrag). [1] https://nl.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verdrag_van_Versailles_(1919) https://nl.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verdrag_van_Versailles_(1919...
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThank you. The English translation of that section ends with: On October 3, 2010 were the last debt repaid by the Germans.
- flosim 8y agoI was also taught in French schools that the Versailles "diktat" was a good reason why Hitler rose to power.
- mintplant 8y agoSame, in the US (Louisiana and then California).
- robhu 8y agoThis was also part of my UK education on why Hitler rose to power.
- dagw 8y agoYou get called a Nazi sympathizer and things like that for trying to provide that context Where? I learnt WWI & WWII history while at school in England, and that was exactly the version we were taught. Although modern historians somewhat dispute the simplicity of that narrative.