2 ms·
Could you elaborate? Maybe it's not convenient for developers, but the result is better for users than an ad hoc mix of old web technologies that is seriously
by amichail 19y ago
Could you elaborate?
Maybe it's not convenient for developers, but the result is better for users than an ad hoc mix of old web technologies that is seriously lacking in features and plagued with compatibility problems.
- wmf 19y agoIt appears that AJAX cross-browser compatibility problems can be solved using infinite money. Besides video, what compelling Flash features aren't available in JS+HTML?
- amichail 19y agoWhich would be better for building a word processor or illustrator service? And even if it is not necessary (e.g., for an email service), users still like to use a more professional looking site.
- DougBTX 19y agoEven if we take your first question as true (and that is highly doubtful) it is far from clear that users prefer sites which "look more professional", cf: plentyoffish.com It's also far from obvious that an all-flash site looks more professional than a flash-free one: if you want to make a site look tacky, just throw in some gratuitous flash or animated gifs and you're away.
- gus_massa 19y agoFlash is useful for single player, little games, that you can play in the browser without installation.
- Hexstream 19y agoIn other words, flash is an awkward adaptor (plugin) to support a form of media (fully interactive games) on a platform (web browser) that was never really intended to support it.
- nostrademons 19y agoLike Tetris? http://halogen.note.amherst.edu/~jdtang/tetris/ http://halogen.note.amherst.edu/~jdtang/tetris/ FWIW, I'm using mixed Flash & JavaScript for my startup (Flash for embedding, JavaScript for the site itself). I've got Asteroids, Pong, and Brickbats all working in pure JavaScript. And I'm just hooking up code right now that lets you edit the games in real-time, no need to reload anything. That ranges from very-difficult to impossible with Flash.
- baha_man 19y agoFrom the Google Webmaster Central Blog: "Try to use Flash only where it is needed... this makes you[r] site accessible to a larger audience, including, for example, blind people using screen readers, users of old or non-standard browsers, and those on limited low-bandwidth connections such as on a cell phone or PDA." http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2007/07/best-uses-of-flash.html http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2007/07/best-uses... I can think of a few good examples of web sites which use Flash effectively, e.g. the BBC 'Get Cooking' site: http://www.bbc.co.uk/food/get_cooking/ http://www.bbc.co.uk/food/get_cooking/ However, Flash normally seems to be used for displaying pointless, obnoxious splash screens which add no value for the user.
- aneesh 19y ago> I can think of a few good examples of web sites which use Flash effectively Youtube!
- amichail 19y agoBut why not use Flash for the entire site rather than just the video player?
- technoguyrob 19y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=164464 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=164464
- sunkencity 19y agoyou gotta be trolling...
- xenoterracide 19y agobecause flash isn't always cross platform. those of us on linux had to wait 2 or more years (I really don't recall) for adobe to roll out a flash 9 from flash 7 for linux. It took another year after that to get it stable. Also if you are blind how do you view flash websites? it has serious problems with usability for those who are disabled. it also has usability problems for those who aren't disabled. I don't like flash websites because I can never find my way around. I can't run them through translator's either (an artist I like, who's native language is spanish, website is in flash, I can't read or translate the spanish because of that, and the english version has been coming soon for 2 or more years).
- CPops 19y agoTo some extent, you can ameliorate these concerns, but using Flash for a website generally leads to usability issues. Here's an article from me explaining why, if you're interested. http://informationrain.com/2007/07/25/why-i-dont-make-flash-websites/ http://informationrain.com/2007/07/25/why-i-dont-make-flash-... In my opinion, flash should mainly be used for what it's great at....making games, some types of interactive tools, and a decent quality cross-platform video solution.
- Goladus 19y agoActually it's not always better for users. There are usually tradeoffs when choosing technologies and this is no exception. There are two (maybe three) fundamental issues with Flash. The vast majority of internet content is conveyed with text, links, and images. Even a with a site like YouTube, there's a host of information related to each video that is best conveyed using text, links, and images. And apart from the rendering part images are essentially just links. Flash has a whole lot of overhead and does not perform basic text and linking tasks very well. The second is that it has limited access to the underlying operating system. The third is that it's a proprietary environment controlled by Adobe.