4 ms·
That feels like a weird pattern (for one because you can have async fat arrows), but also because in general I find await request_some_data() much clearer
by joshuamorton 8y ago
That feels like a weird pattern (for one because you can have async fat arrows), but also because in general I find
await request_some_data()
much clearer than
await (async () => {
// just make the async request inline
})()
- danShumway 8y agoWhen arrow functions were first released, they didn't support the `async` keyword. I guess that wasn't fixed until ES2018? Maybe earlier - I think Babel would compile them pretty early on. Regardless, some people who adopted async patterns early got into the habit of avoiding arrow functions entirely, so it wouldn't be crazy to me to hear someone say, "I used arrow functions before I learned async." Otherwise, this is just restating the same arguments people already made above. There's no practical reason why (() => { }()); would be useful but await (async () => { }()); wouldn't be. The scenario you're talking about where async code removes the need to have an anonymous function only makes sense if you were only using anonymous functions for callbacks. In practice, that's not the only (or even primary) use case for people who advocate inlining code in Javascript. They're specifically advising against the pattern where single-use functions are given names and removed from program flow.
- joshuamorton 8y agoCorrect, and I fundamentally disagree with that pattern. If it's more than a single expression, it's doing something complex enough to deserve a name or to be mocked in tests, etc.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]