4 ms·
The last three paragraphs kind of throw cold water on the hopeful implications. Marriages are more stable because the working class is increasingly living in un
by emodendroket 8y ago
The last three paragraphs kind of throw cold water on the hopeful implications. Marriages are more stable because the working class is increasingly living in unstable, informal relationships.
- koboll 8y agoIs that not a good thing, though? Especially for the working class, breaking up via an expensive divorce, after an expensive marriage, seems objectively worse than breaking up a lengthy partnership, for all involved.
- mijamo 8y agoNot if you have kids or any valuable belongings. Then it can become incredibly messy.
- emodendroket 8y agoYeah. Divorce are messy and expensive in part because untangling a long relationship is complicated.
- bilbo0s 8y agoI think his material point was that dealing with custody matters for never married parents is no more, or less, messy than dealing with custody for married parents. So what's the benefit drawn from being married? I can tell you right now, if you go into a family court here in the US believing you will get more access to your children because you were married, you're liable to be disagreeably surprised. Whether married or unmarried, just protect your legal rights as best you can. And, no matter what happens, abide by the judgement of the court. Appeal later if you're upset.
- emodendroket 8y agoCustody maybe. But being married makes a difference when you're trying to end a relationship and you have to break up your shared assets
- gamblor956 8y agoThere are significant custody-related benefits that accrue only during marriage, like for example being allowed to pick your children up from school, medical decisions, etc., that automatically flow to married fathers that don't flow to the unmarried fathers who don't have the proper paperwork on hand. (As with all things related to domestic laws, this is highly jurisdictional.)
- emodendroket 8y agoDivorce proceedings offer protection to the lower-earning partner. But also a marriage usually means more pooled resources (which counts more if you don't have much) and a more stable environment in which to rear children.
- blotter_paper 8y ago>But also a marriage usually means more pooped resources Are you suggesting that marriages cause overeating? ;)
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoYes and no. It is rather unfortunate that splitting up costs so much. But at the same time, these folks lose all of the protections and benefits that the legal framework of marriage gives. For example, health insurance coverage will not extend to your loved one without the legal framework for it to exist. You might have raised your partner's child since birth or not long after their father/mother passed on, but you'll have no legal right to them if something happens. Even something as simple as taking care of school business for the children gets muddy. You, in general, will not get a say in their care during an emergency situation. Being low income also generally means you do not have the means to have such a legal paper put into place. It also means that you do not get any sort of protection or help with breaking up. No one is going to step in to say that you have to share the apartment until you save up money or that one should be the one to move out, let alone help to make sure that each of you gets to keep a vehicle if they were both in one person's name.
- liberte82 8y agoWhat's wrong with that?
- mythrwy 8y agoStability is good if you have kids.
- Operyl 8y agoEDIT: retracted, the article title was similar to something else I read that didn’t mention kids, when it isn’t, darn memory.
- mattmanser 8y agoArticle contradicts you and supports mythrwy: Many poorer and less educated Americans are opting not to get married at all. They’re living together, and often raising kids together, but deciding not to tie the knot. And studies have shown these cohabiting relationships are less stable than they used to be.
- Operyl 8y agoOh crap indeed you’re right. I read another similar article that I thought this was, it didn’t talk about kids. EDIT: worth noting that I’m not sure who downvoted him, but I have him a vote to try and counter it
- emodendroket 8y agoWhat? It says they're having kids right in the article.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- astura 8y agoI mean, people usually consider stability to be a good thing, especially when there are children involved. Beyond that, legal marriage has benefits that (for lack of a better word) "pretend marriage" doesn't. Some examples include potentially lower taxes, employer benefits for spouses (such as insurance), spousal social security, spousal pension benefits (widows/widowers are often allowed to collect their spouse's pension for the rest of their life), no gift tax between spouses, Spousal IRAs, military benefits, automatic tax free inheritance, next of kin status (which matters if the spouse is incapacitated), lower insurance rates, spousal immunity in court, eligibility for FMLA to care for a sick spouse, eligibility for bereavement leave if a spouse dies, eligible to sponsor a spouse for immigration, etc. Married couples have the "benefit" of going through divorce if they break up. Divorce proceedings allow a (hopefully) neutral third party to order legal division of marital assets. I've seen some incredibly messy non-marriage breakups, where going through divorce once would have been less messy. There might simply also be a social component of marriage that cohabitation simply doesn't provide. If you are married you may work to stay together rather than just split up when you hit a roadblock. Whereas if you're just dating then you might just break up at the first roadblock rather than try to work things out. No data or anything, that's just my "gut feeling" on the matter, it just "seems" like that's the case. Of course it could just be the people who break up rather than work on issues are just not getting married.
- camelCaseOfBeer 8y agoIf only marriage implied raising a family...