4 ms·
This is a really interesting article that highlights for me a concept that is foreign: paid blood donation. I was well aware of the exploitation of paid US blo
by robbiep 8y ago
This is a really interesting article that highlights for me a concept that is foreign: paid blood donation.
I was well aware of the exploitation of paid US blood donors (for those who have not taken the time to read the article, or are familiar with the history, paid donation comes about with an enormous decrease in voluntary donation, ie. ‘the death of civic duty’.
Aus which is a net plasma exporter and which is a volunteer only country has a strange situation where the Red Cross accepts voluntary donations but then gives (?sells - it was nice and simple when the C in CSL stood for commonwealth) it to other companies which refine it, is predicted to be unable to meet its needs should it introduce paid donations) and i’m not overly surprised to hear of exploitation of Chinese donors.
So nothing so new here.
I will say however that the authour throwing ‘we don’t know what will happen to plasma donors’:
>Apart from economic exploitation, the risk to long-term donors is unknown. The product insert that comes with my Baxter-branded Gammagard immunoglobin stretches several feet long and lists everything from blood clots to fever and chills as possible side-effects. For me, an infusion means feeling, at best, like I have the flu for a few days every six weeks. I don’t know what happens to people who give raw materials, so I watch my infusion nurse – the donor – as much as she watches me.
So the authour has an autoimmune condition that requires the infusion of IVIG every 4-6 weeks or so. Awful condition, great and successful treatment.
I still can’t get behind an elaborate statement designed to cast doubt on the safety of (appropriately scheduled) donation, and actually it is so far from a plausible scientific mechanism of causing harm that I have to call it out. Back in Med school we used to joke about blood/plasma donation as a form of weight loss (‘I just gave away 250g of cells!) - the body then has to spend about x2 that in raw energy in the anabolic process of recreating those cells. The rates of donation that are talked about though, of 2 times a week, are so far above what is allowed in a rational donor program (Red Cross Australia only allows a plasma donation once a month). Still, in a healthy person, that would not be an overt drain on the body’s Capacity to recover.
Really interesting article though and I hope everyone learned something!
- jonwachob91 8y ago> This is a really interesting article that highlights for me a concept that is foreign: paid blood donation. The US does not permit paid blood donation, and this article is not about paid blood donation. It's about paid PLASMA donation. Plasma is 1 of 3 components of blood. Blood donations in the US are unpaid (as long as you don't count that free t-shirt or free movie ticket as compensation). *In High School I ran my schools 3 annual blood drives and completed all the associated training to do the drives. During the 2 years (and 6 drives) I ran the program, we broke the state record for High School donations 3 times. I personally was a whole blood gallon donor before graduating High School. I've also done plasma donations, concentrated red cell donations, and platelet donations; so I've donated the whole spectrum :)
- robbiep 8y agoYou’re correct and I apologise - the US does not pay for red cell or platelet donation
- paxswill 8y agoYour comment about rates of donation caused me to check what the frequency of donation for whole blood in other countries is compared to the US. I was surprised to see that England and Australia both have 12 week periods (at least for men), while the US allows donations every 8 weeks. What’s interesting to me is that the last time I went to donate they had a new info sheet regarding post donation iron deficiency [0] for frequent donors, and I saw that one of the things the FDA was considering was increasing the period between donations. That a majority of the non-supplemented participants hadn’t regained their pre-donation iron levels after 24 weeks was surprising and caused me to start consciously increasing my iron intake after donating (along with starting iron supplements). That study contrasted with a more recent study that found no major downsides to the 8 week interval [1]. 0: https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/study-shows-iron-supplementation-after-blood-donation-shortens-hemoglobin-recovery-time https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/study-shows-ir... 1: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/09/170921095515.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/09/170921095515.h...